4 ms·
I don't claim any physical engineering skills, but don't you need a mechanical (non electrical) system for parking breaks?
by ben_w 4y ago
I don't claim any physical engineering skills, but don't you need a mechanical (non electrical) system for parking breaks?
- hollywood_court 4y agoNope. Many modern vehicles have push button electric parking brakes.
- KingJulian 4y agoI would think so too. Any parking brake has to be a fail-safe type brake which has to function in the absence of electricity. Hence, as you mentioned, purely mechanical.
- kwhitefoot 4y agoIt only has to remain engaged, engaging it in cars with push button parking brakes requires electricity to drive a small electric motor at each wheel.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoThey need to be able to remain applied without power, but the application can require power. In my Tesla, I push a button and I can hear an electric motor engaging the brake.
- londons_explore 4y agoYou do, yes. But that can be a metal pin the size of your pinky finger. It's a super easy engineering challenge compared to the regular brakes that slow down the car, which, when emergency braking a 2 ton car from 100 mph, needs to briefly absorb nearly 1 megawatt. Thats the power used by 1000 houses, which is a lot to absorb in a lightweight system that needs to still work if part of the system fails.
- thatcat 4y agoThe parking brake is the emergency brake, cant be a pin
- 2III7 4y agoYou don't, many modern cars have electronic parking brakes with small electric motors mounted on the rear calipers which push the brake pads against the discs when activated.
- nicoburns 4y agoIf it's using brake pads, then it's still a partially mechanical suggestion. The comment at the top of the thread was suggesting doing away with brake pads entirely!
- forgetfreeman 4y agoI am very glad you commented here as my initial skepticism of your claim lead me to do a spot of research that answered several unresolved questions I'd had about one of the most obnoxious features I've ever seen in a new car. My mother in law has a car with (apparently) electronic parking brake and I have loathed everything about it from the moment I first sat down in the car. This at least explains why an utterly unintuitive double toggle button replaced the "standard" mechanical lever on the center console and what notional benefits (hill holding) come with this system. I'd hate this a lot less if the manufacturer had included a tell-tale of some kind to visually indicate if/when the ECM thinks the P-brake is engaged.
- jasode 4y ago>, but don't you need a mechanical (non electrical) system for parking breaks? To some of the replies... I think some clarification needed because the wording caused folks to think of something else such as electronically _controlled_ physical brake pads: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_parking_brake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_parking_brake I think the gp was trying to ask about feasibility of electric _powered_ magnetic field resistance braking ... similar to an exercise bike ... which would require constant electrical power source. (Similar to : https://www.google.com/search?q=magnetic+resistant+braking+of+exercise+bike https://www.google.com/search?q=magnetic+resistant+braking+o...) Magnetic field resistance brakes is practical for regenerative braking but not safe for parking brakes on an incline if the batteries run out of juice. The context is the gp's premise of no physical friction brake components via "(ie. no hydraulics, drums, rotors, or pads)."