3 ms·
What rail needs next is better co-ordination. Connecting multiple carriages together to form a train was an amazing innovation - those carriages are separated
by londons_explore 4y ago
What rail needs next is better co-ordination.
Connecting multiple carriages together to form a train was an amazing innovation - those carriages are separated by inches, whereas trains are separated by miles.
If everything could be separated by inches, we could have a network with 1000x the throughput. 1000x the throughput means we can use all the existing (expensive) rails, and be able to transport everything the interstate road network does today.
And, with enough innovation, that's possible. Imagine an infinitely long train. If more cargo needed to be added to the train, while in motion at say 60 mph, one link in the train could be broken, the gap widened to fit an extra carriage, and then an extra carriage comes in from a side rail, just like merging on a highway, and the whole lot is reattached again. All while still moving.
Infinitely long trains already exist - for example an escalator is a continuous 'train' of steps in a loop.
Disconnecting trains while in motion already exists - it was done regularly on the british railway 50 years ago.
And the rest is just a coordination and timing problem - one that computers are really good at.
- twobitshifter 4y agoEh, not really that simple. The coupling forces with very long trains can cause the trains to break apart. You need to distribute locomotives throughout the train to provide power not just insert new cars. The freight railroads are already running very long trains based on computer modeling and they’re getting pushback from the govt. https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/railroads-use-of-long-trains-to-go-under-the-microscope/ https://www.trains.com/trn/news-reviews/news-wire/railroads-...
- mellavora 4y agoSo, kind of like consistent hashing?
- mschuster91 4y ago> If everything could be separated by inches, we could have a network with 1000x the throughput. 1000x the throughput means we can use all the existing (expensive) rails, and be able to transport everything the interstate road network does today. The problem: most rail runs above ground, with level road crossings. Running trains at the same spatial density as cars would massively impact wildlife, and you'd need to rebuild all the road crossings as well. Additionally, you'd need to reconstruct a lot of bridges and other infrastructure as it was never built to handle that amount of load and traffic. Another limiting factor is that switches need time to operate, you don't want to end up with the tip of the train going straight and the rear part of the train going off. That requires a further minimum distance between trains.
- its_bbq 4y agoAnd waiting for a train to pass through the road is already bad enough
- SECProto 4y agolevel crossings are terrible for a number of reasons
- themikesanto 4y agoIf these ideas were viable, the class 1 carriers would have already implemented them.
- ARandumGuy 4y agoRail doesn't need technological pipe dreams. A well run rail network is already really good at moving freight and passengers. The issue in the US is decades of cost cutting by the freight operators. This includes a lack of infrastructure investment, optimizing cost over speed, and overworking employees to an extreme amount. The technologies for better rail already exist. We just need to actually use them in America.