5 ms·
> Even if you compare Instagram photos to professional Adobe Lightroom plug-ins, Photoshop Actions, and all the tricks and desktop software that photographers u
by jacobolus 15y ago
> Even if you compare Instagram photos to professional Adobe Lightroom plug-ins, Photoshop Actions, and all the tricks and desktop software that photographers use, Instagram photos have a decent quality. The Instagram images are certainly not comparable, in terms of quality or resolution, duh, but the images are at least interesting.
These two sentences are exactly contradictory. 1) “If you compare... Instagram photos have decent quality.” 2) “Instagram images are certainly not comparable in terms of quality”.
In any event, the second version is right. Instagram photos are cute gimmicks, and applying predetermined filters to snapshots can be fun, but the results are not remotely comparable in terms of “quality” to work by competent photo printers (whether in a darkroom or in Photoshop).
- blhack 15y agoOne of these is comparing object qualities like resolution and effective dynamic range, the other is comparing subjective qualities like "how cool does this photo look".
- jacobolus 15y agoThat’s not what the article says, but you might well be right; the author’s conception of photographic quality (sometimes “technical quality”) and articulation thereof are entirely incoherent. He shouldn’t attach 3 or 4 entirely unrelated meanings to one word, or should at least attempt to distinguish them somehow. Anyhow, that one ambiguity is emblematic of a broader sloppiness at all levels in the writing of the post, which abounds with droopy clichés and empty puff. I wish the author and his editor had made a firmer commitment to prose quality.
- Turing_Machine 15y ago> "These two sentences are exactly contradictory. 1) “If you compare... Instagram photos have decent quality.” 2) “Instagram images are certainly not comparable in terms of quality”. Quality is a continuum. Decent < great < excellent < superb. There's plenty of room for them to be "decent" but still be of lower quality than you'd get with professional-grade hardware and software.
- jacobolus 15y agoHe directly says (1) you can compare, (2) you can’t compare. Either you can or you can’t. If the author actually means to say “you can get pictures that are better than come from supermarket-aisle instant cameras but not as good as come from a DSLR + a Photoshop expert”, he should just say that.
- stdbrouw 15y agoSorry mate, but that's not how the English language works. They're comparable as in "you can compare them" but not comparable as in "said comparison shows a clear winner and loser".
- Turing_Machine 15y agoOh, I see where you're coming from. Words in English can have more than one meaning. http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/comparable http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/comparable adjective 1. capable of being compared; having features in common with something else to permit or suggest comparison: He considered the Roman and British empires to be comparable. 2. worthy of comparison: shops comparable to those on Fifth Avenue. 3. usable for comparison; similar: We have no comparable data on Russian farming. It seems clear from context that he's using sense 1 in one sentence and sense 2 in the other. As the other poster said, that's just the way natural languages work. :-)
- minikomi 15y agoThe context of viewing is everything. Instagram is good enough for the situations it is mostly viewed in - iPad iPhone without pinch to zoom. Also, the photos are not heavily scrutinized. They're one-glance, quick-bursts of diary like slithers from people's lives, slightly enhanced the way a good story is.
- callmeed 15y agoAs someone who sees dozens of portfolios every day, I think you vastly overestimate the "quality" of most people who call themselves professional photographers–especially those who shoot weddings and portraits. Also, the latest version of Instagram saves high-res versions of manipulated images to your camera roll. With the iPhone 4s having an 8mp camera, resolution is not the issue. Yes, Instagram's filters are exaggerated and images are cropped square, but they aren't that far off from a lot of things I see people doing for money. People buy a DSLR at Costco for $600 and a website for $250 (hopefully from me), and they are now a "professional" and shooting weddings on Craigslist for $800 or portraits for their Facebook friends. Without technical skills, high-contrast, over-saturation, blown-out, tinted looks become "in". Similar to the bible verse, "Photoshop filters cover a multitude of sins"
- billpatrianakos 15y agoSo true. Just like everyone who buys "Websites for Dummies" and becomes a professional web designer. I see that a lot too. By the way, how do you only charge $250 for a website? Is this like a hobby or do you have a bunch of templates you sell or do you just do small sites super fast and work in bulk? I'm in the website biz myself and my minimum is $1200. Just curious how others run their pricing models.