5 ms·
> There’s nothing wrong with this. These are standard ratios, not some dirty secret. There's a lot wrong with this, but not in a moral sense. For all his faul
by jiggawatts 4y ago
> There’s nothing wrong with this. These are standard ratios, not some dirty secret.
There's a lot wrong with this, but not in a moral sense.
For all his faults, Elon Musk made a good point about the space industry near the beginning of SpaceX. He asked a team of "rocket scientists" how much a rocket cost. They said something like $100M. Then he asked them to sum up the material costs. Sheetmetal, tubing, rivets, etc... They said something like $500K.
Where did the other $99.5M get spent on, you ask? Inefficiencies such as having PhDs doing welding and riveting instead of hiring contractors with more experience. Even if you say you need aerospace-grade rivets, Boeing and co hire thousands of people with those skills at a much lower cost.
Similarly, if you look at retail prices, the majority disappears into having staff stand around the store while there are no customers, lighting, cooling, retail shopfront rents, etc, etc...
You're not paying for an "HiFi amplifier model X", you're paying for a "storefront in a shopping centre with a HiFi amplifier model X thrown in almost for free."
This issue is most obvious when in some industries, returned items are simply discarded, because they're not even remotely the majority of the total cost! Repackaging and restocking the item would cost more than manufacturing it half way around the world and shipping it across an ocean. That's nuts.
Even EBay and Amazon have only just started chipping away at this problem. There is still enormous inertia.
For example, I recently purchased a flagship TV that costs $5,995 retail. Nobody had it for more than a $500 discount, including online stores that are just warehouses! The actual TV probably cost about $800 to $1000 to manufacture and ship internationally.[1] Where did the other $3500-$4000 go!?
What's happened here is that traditional retail has forced the prices up, and then Amazon -- a near monopoly -- doesn't feel the need to compete on price because they win sales even if they're just a little bit cheaper.
True competition would be if I could buy the TV for manufacturing cost +30%, not manufacturing cost x3.
This won't happen while traditional retail is propping up prices and has no real competition. We need a "SpaceX" to shake things up. Unfortunately, Amazon wasn't it.
[1] This isn't the cost of running the machines in a factory. It's everything up to the point of getting the goods into a cardboard box and on a ship. Design, profit, staff costs, material costs, energy costs, capital, etc...
- mc32 4y agoThat other 3500 - 4000 is definitely not majority profit. If they could make better profit on your purchase they would, they really don't want to leave money on the table. MFG, shipping, handling, warranty, returns, accidents, fraud, R&D, operations staff, etc. It's not getting done by volunteers.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tuatoru 4y ago> ... how much a rocket cost.... The "rocket" example is as silly as the "Moore's Law applied to vehicles" arguments that used to crop up on Slashdot decades ago. "If cars improved according to Moore's law, they'd get XXXX miles per gallon and go YYYY miles per hour". Yes, and they'd also be smaller than matchboxes while seating thousands of people. Exceptional situations are exceptional. Good on Elon Musk for realising that there was a large latent demand for launch-to-orbit services. Well done, that chap. But you can't generalize from that to everything else. Or anything else, really.[1] With respect to the rest of your argument, I understood that Amazon makes most of its profit from AWS, while stories about its ruthless exploitation of its warehouse staff are legion. Those factoids don't square with your argument that Amazon is making excess profits. 1. Take luxury yachts for example, which are about as expensive as rockets. The bill of materials would be a slightly larger fraction of the final cost than for rockets, but the same reasoning would seem to apply. Why has no-one "Musked" luxury yachts?
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agopart of the reason is that the point of a luxury yacht is to be expensive.
- thayne 4y ago> With respect to the rest of your argument, I understood that Amazon makes most of its profit from AWS, while stories about its ruthless exploitation of its warehouse staff are legion. Sure, but from what I understand, businesses generally list goods on Amazon for close to MSRP, possibly for contractual reasons. Some of that certainly pays for Amzazon fees, but where does the rest of the difference from wholesale price go? > Why has no-one "Musked" luxury yachts? Well, for one thing, a luxury yacht is a status symbol. If it became less expensive, more people would be able to afford them, and the wealthy would feel less special about being able to own one. Certainly not the only reason, but I'm sure it's a contributing factor.
- Max-q 4y agoWhat Elon saw, was that the rocket companies was multiplying BOM with 200, when it could have been a smaller number. There is nothing wrong to multiply BOM with 10. It’s almost as low as you can get it when operating a business. But when you find a market which is marking up with 200, you have found yourself an opportunity for a competing business.
- mk_chan 4y agoIt’s not so simple. Many manufacturers set a minimum advertised price which would require legislation to change. Additionally advertising a certain price and actually selling at a different price is a surefire way to get delisted from google for example. This is why the whole promotion codes/voucher concept is popular.
- Bakary 4y agoThe real insight I'm gettimg here is just to curb our consumption to a great extent. The fact that shipping new products is cheaper than reinventoring used ones is an indication that we are on a death spiral. Having the move fast and break things crowd come up with a solution to consumer electronic prices is just going to accelerate pollution that much more. And I am aware of the sweet irony of typing all this on a phone whose low price depends on complex supply chains.