6 ms·
Do University Diversity Statement Requirements Violate the Constitution?
- unconed 4y agoIt seems so stunningly obvious that: - diversity statements are an intrusive ideological test forced upon fields that are entirely unrelated, under pain of ostracization by a mob of students, taught to do so by activist professors who don't teach how to think but what to think. - the kinds of colleges that demand them are insanely expensive, have a bloated administration, and offer value nowhere near what they cost, demonstrating that true inclusion and equity is the last thing they care about. - the people who support them are intolerant, not interested in open inquiry, and do not understand the first thing about the principles they are claiming to uphold. - the grievances they are obsessed about are situated in a very narrow, american-centric, pampered point of view, which treats history as a fairy tale where only white men had agency, and are responsible for all the ills of the world. Whether or not it violates the constitution is entirely immaterial seeing as it simply violates common sense, and ticks every box of totalitarian conformism... the kind of thing universities are supposed to protect enlightened societies from. Insane that people don't see this, but here we are.
- tarakat 4y agoThere's a second, usually unaddressed question: given these diversity pledge requirements, how should we recalibrate our view of universities? Suppose universities, as in Volokh's example, required candidates to show what they did to support the war, or required membership in the Party. Later, those universities produce research concluding that the war is justified, and the Party is good. Should we trust those conclusions? Someone says "universities are overwhelmingly pro-war/Party because those things are true, and smart people are better at finding the truth" - should we find that inference justified?
- UncleEntity 4y agoThey can’t produce anti-war research if they have any hope of keeping their job because it directly contradicts the pro-war requirements to keep their job. So all you will see is “two legs good, four legs bad” propaganda coming out of these institutions and with “scientific consensus” being the driver of truth these days…
- cuteboy19 4y agoI attended a session about "Navigating Diversity Statements" once out of morbid curiosity. You you think (even hope) that those people are quite cynical themselves about all this, but it seemed as though they genuinely believed in what they said
- olliej 4y agoWhat do you mean? (As in what were they saying that incorrect?)
- zibby8 4y ago> But wouldn't the message be quite clear—if you want a job here, or if you want to keep your job (especially if you're untenured), or if you want a promotion, you'd be wisest to express pro-war positions, or at least keep your anti-war positions to yourselves? And is that consistent with the First Amendment and academic freedom principles? Yes, the message is quite clear. Universities want people who appreciate diversity. I'm not sure the war analogy is the amazing argument the author thinks it is. Like the author is saying, "wouldn't it be wrong if universities asked a leading question about war? Then why is ok to ask for DEI statements?" But what the author misses is that, if being pro-war aligned with the university's goals, then yes, the university would be right to ask a leading, pro-war question. I'm sure departments ask plenty of leading questions on more mundane, less contentious topics. There's a reason why individual universities gain reputations for having specific "schools of thought." There is always an element of self-selection.
- throwaway1851 4y agoI appreciate the point you’re making, but I think it (and the article) glides past something important. The bundle of ideas called “DEI” don’t refer to broad, time-tested principles that are inherently aligned with the mission of higher education. Instead, they refer to a prescriptive and narrow political ideology — one that is modern and largely driven by groupthink. It is very possible to be thoroughly committed to the underlying aims of DEI while critiquing its methodologies. Yet, fealty oaths like those discussed in the article arguably create a chilling environment where such intellectual exploration cannot thrive. And that DOES conflict with some very time-honored ideas about what universities are here for.
- olliej 4y agoMy first thought it that in the US universities are largely private institutions so the constitution isn’t relevant - you’re looking at legislation like title 9. The next thing to ask is how do you rectify decades of explicit discrimination against a variety of groups, and then the subsequent less overt discrimination following the passage of the CRA? Given that every piece of evidence shows bias in people from X recommending and/or hiring from X and X adjacent universities and facilities - including getting into labs at other universities if you’re looking at some form of postgrad - how do you compensate for unintentional biases? Eg someone isn’t intentionally racist but they prefer recommendations from people they went to school with, and none of them work at/with HBCUs. Universities with hereditary enrollment are inherently racist, as many explicitly did not allow black Americans to be students until relatively recently, and even when the CRA passed continued a variety of explicitly discriminatory policies. The result of which is that the hereditary enrollments have a huge bias against PoC. I am not saying diversity statements are what has to happen - I think such are largely puffery that is easier than working out how to actually fix things - just that the problem is not trivial, and the seeming alternative people propose is simply to say “just keep doing what we are doing now” as we aren’t being explicitly biased anymore, which is actively harmful BS.
- FateOfNations 4y ago> My first thought it that in the US universities are largely private institutions so the constitution isn’t relevant Approximately 3/4ths of college students are attending public universities. https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d21/tables/dt21_303.10.asp https://nces.ed.gov/programs/digest/d21/tables/dt21_303.10.a...
- Gunax 4y agoAdmittedly I did not watch the debate (perhaps tomorrow), but I think the crux of this disagreement seems to be the essence of what diversity statements are, and whether we believe the institution's stated goal. Proponents are arguing they are mundane statements aligned with the goals of the institution. But opponents are skeptical--they see it as a motte and bailey. They are, in reality, a test of politico-ideological adherence. The institutions only use the 'we just want to ensure we have fairness and equality' as a fallback, according to detractors. What they are actually asking is not what is being asked. Following up on their war analogy, it is as if the university asked 'How have you contributed to your society and neighbourhood?' but in reality, only accepting contributions related to the war effort. Writing about generic charitable efforts does not count--and definitely don't mention any anti-war contributions. Allegedly of course--I have no particular knowledge in this area.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoReason has a long history of being on the wrong side of this kind of thing but talking as if they aren't. Here's an article they wrote, to refute the allegation that they were pro-apartheid: https://reason.com/2014/07/19/reason-spuriously-accused-by-conspiracy/ https://reason.com/2014/07/19/reason-spuriously-accused-by-c... They say, that as well as all the pro-apartheid things they wrote (the more recent of which didn't count because they were just knowingly lying for political motives) they also wrote lots of articles about how apartheid was terrible. But if you read those articles, they all basically follow the pattern of "apartheid is terrible, but the thing that people are doing to combat apartheid is worse". They suggest that boycotting apartheid regimes would lead to more apartheid, and the best way to get rid of apartheid is to mostly do nothing. The opening quote that they deny, literally says they attacked anti-apartheid sanctions. They say that's a lie, but it's obviously true from their own article in defence. I suppose you could still argue they were correct in what they argued (even if they are a bit coy about admitting it now), but other people disagree: > The African National Congress, which was the leading anti-apartheid movement in South Africa, has published extensive documentation to support their assertion that the boycott campaign [...] was, indeed, instrumental in ending apartheid. A very strong echo. edit to add this quote because it's right at the bottom after all the denials: > the biggest category I left out were the Reaganite proxy-war correspondetry of Jack Wheeler, which had much less to do with South Africa's domestic policies, and more with its role in the Cold War (which, as I argued in my Nelson Mandela obituary this year, had the effect of warping America's policy and values toward apartheid) So it wasn't their fault, it was America that was wrong about Apartheid and had warped values.
- tarakat 4y agoAnd that is why this article is wrong, I see, yes, well put. In fact, all the countries and universities that don't require diversity pledges (i.e. the great majority of them) are in fact morally equivalent to apartheid.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoYes, I have to assume that an institution that has repeatedly lied about important topics that are much more impactful than this, and later admitted that it lied about them for political ends, is this time telling the truth about this not very important even if what they claim is true matter. And if I don't, I'm the bad guy. You'd think after the first few of your writers deny the Holocaust or openly advocates stoning gay people to death you'd start to ask questions about the way you go about things and attract followers. > Ames is correct that some of the contributors to that issue developed an interest in or were fellow travelers with that most pathetic area of study known as Holocaust revisionism or denialism. That scurrilous topic is not the focus of any of the articles in the issue, but the inclusion of contributors such as James J. Martin, who would go on to join the editorial board of the contemptible denialist outfit the Institute of Historical Review, is embarrassing. Another of that issue's contributors, Gary North, would later be excoriated in this 1998 Reason article for arguing in favor of violent theocracy and the stoning of gays and others. https://reason.com/2014/07/26/did-reason-really-publish-a-holocaust-de/ https://reason.com/2014/07/26/did-reason-really-publish-a-ho... Why do these fascists keep writing articles for my libertarian magazine? is clearly a question they've not grappled deeply with. In that article they claim it's awkward that the guy funding the stonings is also funding them.