2 ms·
This is a fantastic point, and (IMO) reveals the government’s actual intended strategy here. For better or worse, the government seems to be intent on making a
by woodruffw 4y ago
This is a fantastic point, and (IMO) reveals the government’s actual intended strategy here.
For better or worse, the government seems to be intent on making a lesson out of the Tornado Cash developer, rather than attempting (probably pointlessly) to shut down all of Ethereum. The point seems to be to send a message: if you publish the brick blueprint, you will be considered the entity responsible. This accomplishes both of the government’s goals: it disincentives future attempts to launder money through smart contracts, and it avoids a protracted legal and technical battle over individual cryptocurrencies and their networks.
Edit: And there are clear parallels in existing legal reasoning: we do not prosecute steel factories for following a client’s specification faithfully, even if it’s later revealed that the specification was in furtherance of something illegal to manufacture (like an unregulated weapon). The exception is when the factory goes to unusual lengths to turn a blind eye, which the government might present evidence to argue negligence or conspiracy.
- DennisP 4y agoIn that case the government runs into First Amendment issues. Bernstein vs. US ruled that source code counts as protected speech, and courts do consider chilling effects to be infringement.