5 ms·
delinka (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3282503 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3282503 )'s response is the first one that comes to mind: if you need
by JadeNB 15y ago
delinka (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3282503 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3282503 )'s response is the first one that comes to mind: if you need to monetise your review business, and if people are (rightfully) suspicious about your company accepting money from the companies that it reviews, then why not ask for money from the reviewers?
Of course, the obvious answer is "They won't pay"; so why not ask for money from the consumers of the reviews? OK, it's still pretty idealistic, and people will still go for free, but imagine a whole gamified review platform: to read reviews, you need to spend credits. To earn credits, you can either spend a small amount of money, or leave reviews yourself. This offers an incentive to leave positive reviews—it gives you access to more of others' reviews. Of course, the big problem with positive reviews is that people usually can't even think of their positive experiences; so prompt for a small amount of personal information: "Where do you live? … OK, people in Chicago are looking for reviews of Thai restaurants. Have you been to a Thai restaurant lately?", &c.
Your review will be decorated with an Amazon-style "This review was helpful" thumbs up / thumbs down button; and, the more helpful reviews you leave, the more weight your later reviews will be given. (The main problem that I have with review sites is companies posting spurious reviews of their own products.) Have comments be the last word, or allow threaded discussions (without moderation, or with moderation only for content violations); I'm perfectly happy with allowing businesses to respond—there are definitely unreasonable companies out there—as long as the whole exchange is out in the open.
Sure, the revenue stream from people willing to pay to read reviews is fairly small, but, if you build up a trustworthy review site, then surely people will come to it in preference to the current crop of useless ones out there, and the ad impressions will start to mean something.
- jhdavids8 15y ago> Your review will be decorated with an Amazon-style "This review was helpful" thumbs up / thumbs down button; and, the more helpful reviews you leave, the more weight your later reviews will be given This is exactly what I've been thinking for the past 6 months. There's no reason the rating given to a business should be the generic average of reviews provided. A weighted average considering various realistic factors would provide a much more representative rating for a business. I hate to do this sort of self-marketing, but issues like these are exactly what I'm trying to solve with my startup (skipscotch.com). Very interesting idea about gaming the review platform. I'm trying to game it a bit, but the idea where reading reviews require credits you earn by writing reviews is a interesting concept. I just wonder how much of an audience you would be limiting from your platform by implementing it. I suppose you could allow anyone to view ratings, but actually reading reviews would require credits.
- blahedo 15y agoI would totally use that site, but are you thinking micropayments or subscription?
- JadeNB 15y agoSince review-reading is usually a one-off thing—I've never found myself thinking, “I'm going to need to read lots of reviews this month”—it's hard to imagine much of a market for subscriptions; so I guess micropayments.