3 ms·
It is a common misconception with a grain of truth to it. The Planck length is more than just a unit. It can be derived as the point where quantum mechanics an
by jfengel 4y ago
It is a common misconception with a grain of truth to it.
The Planck length is more than just a unit. It can be derived as the point where quantum mechanics and general relativity conflict. Planck-wavelength light is its own black hole.
Which does not mean that the Planck length is a fundamental unit, but it's the starting point for some beyond-the-Standard-Model physics. Most popularly, Loop Quantum Gravity (the main alternative to string theory) does use the Planck length as its fundamental granularity of space-time.
The fact is that most people have no business having an opinion on String Theory vs Loop Quantum Gravity. But it makes good copy to play it as a David-vs-Goliath story in popular science publications. And those publications are a double-edged sword. For a few, they are a crucial stepping-stone into deciding on science as a career (even though vanishingly few will do fundamental physics). For the many, they are entertainment, and leave them squarely at the top of Mount Stupid[1].
Munroe is well past Mount Stupid, and knows everything I've just said. But it's a trope he'll play with on his way to some other educational/entertainment end. He's explicitly referring to "quantum foam", a property of Loop Quantum Gravity, which does include P_l as a fundamental unit.
As I said, I'm always wary of that kind of popular science. It's hard for me to tell whether it's a net benefit, whether it informs more than it misinforms. But I can say that I would not have gone into science without starting there, even though I was told an awful lot of lies in my early science education.
[1] https://www.ascpsychological.com/blog/mount-stupid/ https://www.ascpsychological.com/blog/mount-stupid/