3 ms·
You're right, that's a concern. The solution is to get everyone in the DNA database beforehand so there's no marginal cost of getting swabbed with a rape kit.
by pfdietz 4y ago
You're right, that's a concern. The solution is to get everyone in the DNA database beforehand so there's no marginal cost of getting swabbed with a rape kit.
- zaroth 4y agoTotalitarianism is always a solution, it’s just also always the wrong solution.
- pfdietz 4y agoThat's true, but it isn't relevant to the comment you are responding to. I'm getting strong Godwin's Law vibes from your response, btw.
- manicdee 4y agoGodwin’s law doesn’t apply when talking about actual Nazis. Pre-collecting DNA from everyone to use as evidence against them in future criminal investigations is way over the line when it comes to “is this behaviour totalitarian or fascist”. Using DNA from a rape kit to identify someone in a crime is a clear violation of the 5th amendment. Just because you can do something doesn’t mean you should.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIf the people vote for the government to collect everyone’s DNA at some future point in time, that’s just how a democracy works. Freedom and liberty includes the freedom and liberty to make poor decisions.
- zaroth 4y agoA democracy without the guardrails of a constitution can absolutely slip into totalitarianism thru entirely democratic means. The majority vote can be rallied through fear and propaganda into vesting ever greater authority in a centralized seat of power, with any opposition vilified as an existential threat. The only way democracy survives is through a watchful and untrusting populace that constantly holds its government to account and seeks to limit its power and pervasive reach into the lives of the citizenry. Freedom and liberty require at its core the ability to dissent. Dissent in turn requires privacy because dissent by its very nature will be suppressed by those in power. I would theorize that mandatory en masse DNA cataloging is anathema to democracy because it inevitably is far too powerful a tool to suppress dissent.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThe constitution can be almost arbitrarily amended, or even replaced almost entirely, if 3/4 of voters agree, or 3/4 of their representatives in a constitutional convention agrees... you do realize a specific portion of the U.S. constitution explicitly enumerates that possibility?
- manicdee 4y agoIf a population votes for the least worst government that doesn’t give that government permission to turn to autocracy slightly slower than the other option.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoThe government is given permission, presumably, for whatever the voters voted for.
- akudha 4y agoThat is what the Kuwaiti government did, years ago. This might work for authoritarian governments, should not work in democracies
- pfdietz 4y agoWhy shouldn't it work for democracies? In what sense is maintaining a DNA database incompatible with democracy?
- manicdee 4y agoBecause using DNA collected from a victim of crime to prosecute them for a later crime is probably a violation of 5th amendment rights. The next logical step if you don’t think the 5th was violated is collecting DNA from everyone (eg: repurposing COVID swabs) so you can identify all the potential suspects from your sampled population while completely ignoring that someone from outside the sampled population could be the person you are looking for.
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThe direct proposal was not to collect data from victims, but all innocent parties . no need for extrapolation.
- pfdietz 4y agoI don't see how this is unreasonable, when already we collect photographs (with ID cards). Or, more aptly, we already collect footprints of newborns, for purposes of identification. Collecting DNA for purposes of identification is almost the same thing. Being able to positively identify people is a reasonable function of a government, including democratic governments.
- manicdee 4y agoDNA testing is not positive identification.
- 4y ago