2 ms·
Technical safeguards against insider threats do not actually protect you from insider threats - the fact that your behavior is logged and you will get fired and
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
Technical safeguards against insider threats do not actually protect you from insider threats - the fact that your behavior is logged and you will get fired and sued into oblivion works very well.
Technical safeguards against insider threats protect your insiders. They give your insiders cover in situations where they might be coerced to do things.
When I was at G, I likely could have read some data from cloud customers with some social engineering and the permissions I had. It would have taken hours to get the first byte, and I would have been fired within 10 minutes if I did without a good reason. The fact that it would have taken hours and some social engineering would let me plausibly tell the police (or the Chinese government or the mob or anyone else), "no, I don't have access to that data." Twitter's engineers didn't have that cover.
- bink 4y agoNot to defend Twitter because their lack of oversight and security controls around who can access what sounds completely inadequate and borderline criminal... but comparing any company to Google is unfair. Very, very few companies have the resources and experience that Google has dealing with these types of threats.
- MattPalmer1086 4y agoI like your take on it providing cover for insiders against coercion. I hadn't considered that aspect before. I'd slightly disagree that technical safeguards don't provide any protection against insider attacks. But yes, the deterrent effect of having a high chance of being caught is very effective.
- sangnoir 4y agoWeren't those controls added after some Googler stalked teenagers[1] via their chats for months? That event generated bad publicity in the press, and some years later, the same thing happened at Uber, with the euphemism "LoveOPS" being used, IIRC. High-growth companies prefer to prioritize features and kick the access control can down the lane until they absolutely have to. Without looking at revenue and employee numbers, I suspect 2010 Google and 2016-ish Uber are comparable to current Twitter, IMO. Edit: the Googler story is far worse that I remembered: he had unfettered access to underaged victims' mailboxes, chat logs, contacts and Voice accounts and used that information to taunt one victim, and unblocked himself from another victim who had blocked him on Gchat - Google only became aware of it when it was reported externally. 1. https://www.businessinsider.com/google-engineer-stalked-teens-spied-on-chats-2010-9?amp https://www.businessinsider.com/google-engineer-stalked-teen...
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThat incident inspired the alerts and the permissions checks. There were a few other incidents (not heinously bad if they were public, but potentially bad for G) that made them go all the way.