5 ms·
Where does the hydrogen come from, or is this just natural gas with extra steps? What's the state of the art on producing hydrogen from electricity without inc
by pjc50 4y ago
Where does the hydrogen come from, or is this just natural gas with extra steps?
What's the state of the art on producing hydrogen from electricity without incredibly expensive catalysts again?
- goethes_kind 4y agoThe German chancellor recently signed a deal from Canada which will provide us with green hydrogen produced by wind farms in Newfoundland.
- nelgaard 4y agoThere is no deal. They just signed a "joint declaration of intent". They still have neither the wind turbines nor hydrogen production facilities.
- credit_guy 4y agoThis is still important, even if right now the hydrogen comes from natural gas. Otherwise, it's a chicken and egg problem: if there's no demand for hydrogen, people won't build plants to make green hydrogen, and if green hydrogen is not available, people won't build the trains and other vehicles to use that.
- a3_nm 4y agoThere is in fact already significant industrial use of hydrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production#Use_of_hydrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrogen_production#Use_of_hyd... -- independently from the use case of replacing fossil fuels. So there is already significant demand for hydrogen that could be green, but the vast majority of hydrogen produced today is from fossil fuels.
- credit_guy 4y agoThat is true. But the vast majority of the hydrogen produced today is used for things hydrogen was used for decades (fertilizers and oil refining). As such it already has its infrastructure in place, so it's quite a change to migrate to a new way of producing this hydrogen. New uses can demand green hydrogen however. Germany in particular has a number of green hydrogen producing projects. [1] is a very good source. [1] https://www.iea.org/reports/hydrogen https://www.iea.org/reports/hydrogen
- WJW 4y agoState of the art is about 93% efficiency for electrolysis of water "in the lab". It was about 80% efficient at industrial scale back in 2017 (see https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2017/7/5/hydrogen-made-by-the-electrolysis-of-water-is-now-cost-competitive-and-gives-us-another-building-block-for-the-low-carbon-economy https://www.carboncommentary.com/blog/2017/7/5/hydrogen-made...), so we can expect that to be a few percentage points higher today. Apart from the aforementioned hydrogen agreement with Canada, construction is underway for a wind-powered multi-GW electrolyzer plant in the Netherlands, which is pretty much next door to the German trains from TFA.
- ThomPete 4y agoIn the lab is a very very very very very different thing than at scale. Hydrogen is not feasible anytime soon. Maybe when we get Fusion but then it's most likely going to be used for materials not energy.
- ben_w 4y ago4% of current industrial hydrogen production is from electrolysis. This is 8 GW electrical for a production of about 3.5e6 tons/year, i.e. 72 MJ/kg, compared to the energy density of hydrogen of 120 MJ/kg is an efficiency of 60% in the actually deployed systems. While we know how to do better even at industrial scale, PV (in the right place) is so cheap that even 60% makes sense economically. Technologically, hydrogen electrolysis predates batteries by nearly 50 years, and practically speaking it is so trivial today that I first did it when I was single-digit-years-old. Not sure what you're thinking of when you suggest fusion might be used for materials instead of energy. Transmutation?
- ThomPete 4y agoFusion is the sun. In the future we will be able to do what the sub does which is to create the raw materials we all do. Keep in mind fusion is not just another way to power our lightbulbs, it's a different type of energy among others with the ability to get us to 10% of the speed of light. Electrolyses uses mostly fossil fuel and will continue to do so. It's a simple question of physics.