5 ms·
The monarchy has only fared well if it changes with the times, which it has, gradually giving more power to parliament over the centuries. We have gone from a s
by geenew 4y ago
The monarchy has only fared well if it changes with the times, which it has, gradually giving more power to parliament over the centuries. We have gone from a system of divine right to a harmless institution that provides an apolitical centre. In a practical sense, the institution today is unrecognizable from the institution 1,000 years ago. And there is no reason to think it will not continue to change, gradually, as social change requires.[1]
For better or worse, the monarch is the legitimate sovereign. There is a chain going back almost 1,000 years.[2] Are we, now living, the ones who get to break that? If we are, then we should have a good reason to do so.
A future change where the monarchy effectively ceases to exist is entirely plausible. But any change like that should only happen by agreement. And there is no pressing need for it that I can see.
[1] Take, for example, the Crown Estate. Lands that the sovereign controlled but which were effectively given to the state. A huge transfer of economic power, done bloodlessly and within the laws of the nation.
[2] Yes, there was a civil war. But there was also a restoration.
- doctor_eval 4y ago> For better or worse, the monarch is the legitimate sovereign. Legitimacy is not a currency; it derives directly from consent. If the “we, now living” no longer consent to a monarch, then the monarch has no legitimacy.
- HyperSane 4y ago" If we are, then we should have a good reason to do so." Its mere existence is sufficient reason to end it. The very concept of Kings and Queens is anathema to democracy.
- nly 4y agoI mean I think it's clear Harry and Meghan saw the writing on the wall a number of years years ago and decided to go and establish a backup income, separate from Royal ties, in California. Signing lucrative Netflix contracts, selling "Sussex" branded trinkets, going on Oprah, and bringing out autobiographies (no doubt containing scandal) has no doubt already made them a 7 figure sum.