23 ms·
Regardless of the content, it strikes me that this author is a bit stuck in his own head? He uses rare words when common ones will do ("dyad"? What's wrong with
by stavros 4y ago
Regardless of the content, it strikes me that this author is a bit stuck in his own head? He uses rare words when common ones will do ("dyad"? What's wrong with "pair"?), passingly mentions obscure terms for no reason, and in general writes like the less the reader understands, the smarter the material was.
- actionfromafar 4y agoOkay, playing the devils advocate here, but sometimes the "lingo" is useful. Grabbing a "couple of beers" could really mean a "bunch of beers". But a "dyad of beers" is very explicitly exactly two beers.
- stavros 4y agoBut so does "two beers", and it doesn't require you to know a random Greek word. I mean, it doesn't necessitate you to ken an aleatorial Hellenic lexis.
- ciphol 4y agoSo is a "pair of beers".
- actionfromafar 4y agoTo me "a pair of" can colloquially (see, I did it again) mean "a bunch of".
- jdmichal 4y agoI'm with you on "couple" potentially not being exactly two, though I tend to default to using "few" in such cases. But I can't sign up for "pair" not being exactly two. Yay language!
- ramphastidae 4y agoIf someone puts on a pair of jeans followed by a pair of socks, how many articles of clothing have been put on? :)
- jdmichal 4y agoA pair!
- sdwr 4y agoDont mean to pile on (still better to write than not, glad it was linked, etc!) but I agree. It reads as language-fetishizing to me, too in love with little turns of phrase and eddies in the current. Noticed the same thing in Bo Burnham's Inside (lots of attention placed on aesthetic details), maybe it's a consequence of doing it all solo. The older I get the more I admire people who are straightforward and cut through the gloss. If something is worth saying, it's worth saying simply.
- throwaway_au_1 4y agoFrom a practical perspective, I found myself in a sort of context switching throughout the piece, looking up various bits to make sure I understood their use, but also finding myself disappointed when I came to the conclusion that the use of a given piece of jargon didn't seem warranted over a simpler version of the phrase. I liked the topic so I pushed through, but it made it tougher to read than it seemed to need to be.
- swatcoder 4y agoOr it’s just a style that they write in, plainly inspired by the stuff they like to read. We can have a discussion about whether it’s good delivery of that style, or whether the style itself is accessible, but I’m not sure what we gain by trying to analyze someone’s personality through it.
- stavros 4y agoI didn't mean it as an analysis of his personality (how can you do that from a blog post?), it's just shorthand for "I dislike this writing style in this specific way".
- alvincodes 4y agoI'm at the point now that I'll immediately stop reading whenever I see obscure expressions in latin or French.
- ARandomerDude 4y agoEnglish is basically Latin + French + a few other sprinkles. These expressions are pretty trivial to pick up, especially if you have read much history, logic, etc. For example, his phrase cum hoc, ergo propter hoc is a pun on post hoc, ergo propter hoc, which is a well-known logical fallacy.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agocum hoc is another well known logical fallacy https://www.fallacyfiles.org/cumhocfa.html https://www.fallacyfiles.org/cumhocfa.html
- rjbwork 4y agoWell, it's more German than either of those, especially wrt structure, conjugation, and helping verbs. But we do take a huge amount of vocabulary from Latin and the romance languages, especially in the realms of the arts and science.
- jdmichal 4y agoEnglish is a Germanic language that was injected with a large amount of French vocabulary. Latin and Greek are typically used in very specific jargons, such as philosophy or medicine, with some phrases escaping confinement and reaching a larger population. English being a Germanic language is why the whole "no prepositions at the end of sentences" thing never made sense. That was a Latin rule. But Germanic languages have a property of augmenting verbs using prepositions. In German itself these are called "separable verbs". Ich stehe auf. I stand up. "Up" is not a preposition in this sentence. It's an integral part of the verb. That is, the verb is, in its entirety, "aufstehen" or "to stand up". Meanwhile, this same phrase in Spanish uses reflexivity: Levanto me. I lift myself.
- mellavora 4y ago
- bckr 4y agoDisagree: I found it highly readable partially because it was just a shade more colorful and elegant than the typical stuff, without trying too hard.
- glenngillen 4y agoIt’s a term I wasn’t personally familiar with until a few months ago. But my introduction was via my 8 year old son! They were using it to explain concepts in class at school. Now I’m wondering if there’s some larger trend/influence that has introduced it into a collection vocabulary that I’ve missed?
- aquova 4y ago"Force Dyad" was a plot point in Star Wars: Episode IX (2019), which I would imagine would be a noteworthy enough source.
- underdeserver 4y agoUnless you refuse to acknowledge that that movie came out.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoWhat movie?
- swyx 4y agodisagree - writing advice has skewed too much towards pg-style "write for a 5th grade reading level" making everything sound plain and bland. while thats an appropriate style for clear communication, sometimes you just want to flex your literary muscles, and English offers so many wonderful ways of self expression that are slowly being lost due to boiled down business writing. Coda's technical chops are undisputed AND is a well known technical communicator, dont cramp his style, there are few enough of him as it is
- Tade0 4y ago> sometimes you just want to flex your literary muscle If so, then you usually don't want to mix it with profanity. I mean, you can, but it's a style that went out of fashion years ago.
- seanw444 4y agoWho cares if it's out of style? Sounds like an excuse to kill creativity.
- sbdncuvh 4y agoI find there is a time and a place for this in your work though. You don't have to use obscure words nonstop, use them where people can learn or figure out just from context. Sometimes thats not possible but it usually is. If you think it isn't, maybe you've got a new writing skill to learn and improve on. Writing for the reader is important if you want your work to be read. Write to think all you want but don't expect other people to read your unedited drafts.
- quickthrower2 4y agoAll I will say is if I need to use the dictionary on every paragraph it is probably a bit too much! Props for where he linked to definitions though.
- stavros 4y agoEh, as the sibling comment says, it's about the ROI of the new word. If you're defining something with it that would otherwise take many words to explain, or if you want to introduce a new idea, or otherwise use it as shorthand, great. If you're using a new word only once, then why even use it?
- Simon_O_Rourke 4y agoYes, I got that "look at me, I'm so smart" vibe off the writing too.
- togs 4y agoaffectation
- boxed 4y agoLike how all tech blogs nowadays writes "leverage" instead of "use". "I leveraged a hammer on these nails" sounds hilariously stupid, but it's quite literally using the word leverage for an action that has leverage, unlike tech blogs.
- taneq 4y agoOh don’t be silly, you don’t just leverage a hammer… you leverage the synergy of your entire toolchain! ;)
- Dave3of5 4y agoReads like a lot of Uni material. We actually had a course at our Uni to stop us writing in this style. The Professors had become sick of reading white papers that said something straight forward in this strange Academic language. I'd be willing to bet this person is very well educated or has maybe has worked in Academia.
- brian_cunnie 4y ago> author is a bit stuck in his own head ... passingly mentions obscure terms for no reason My sentiments exactly.