2 ms·
It's a weather app. There is no monopoly on weather info. The data is pretty much public and anyone could start their own alternative.
by Gigachad 4y ago
It's a weather app. There is no monopoly on weather info. The data is pretty much public and anyone could start their own alternative.
- wpietri 4y agoIn which case, it sounds like there was no need for Apple to buy this.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe reason seems pretty simple, because it was cheaper to buy it than to pay their own people to try and recreate it.
- wpietri 4y agoFunny, you just explained how easy it was. But now it's so hard that Apple engineers can't just rebuild the parts they need? I think the simpler explanation is one you'll find in many comments here: Dark Sky was unusually good, and Apple bought it to get all that goodness to themselves.
- TillE 4y agoThis is just asking why acquisitions happen. There are plenty of reasons, and they typically don't demonstrate monopolistic behavior, certainly not in any legal sense.
- wpietri 4y agoExcept for the sense where it's an anti-consumer concentration of market power. Something Apple is fond of. [1] Is this particular action currently illegal? Probably not, because in the US we're in an era of extreme friendliness toward companies from anti-trust regulators. But that doesn't mean no reasonable market regulator would ever frown on acquisitions like this. [1] E.g.: https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/8/23343336/apple-tim-cook-imessage-blue-green-bubbles-texting-rcs https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/8/23343336/apple-tim-cook-im...
- abduhl 4y agoHow is it anti consumer? What harm has a consumer suffered? It seems like your only answer to this is “there’s less weather apps”? If your viewpoint were the one used for antitrust then no acquisition ever would be acceptable.
- wrycoder 4y agoMany people love Dark Sky, and Apple simply killed it.
- wpietri 4y agoExactly. Comments here show that people had a good thing. Apple took it away from them to get a competitive advantage.
- abduhl 4y agoWhat did Apple take away here? The app icon? Android support has been gone since 2020 and most (all?) of the features of Dark Sky are integrated (and enhanced apparently) into iOS 16. So you have a situation where all the people that "had a good thing" now have it by default without an extra app they have to click on and now more people will have that good thing by default for free. If anything, this is anti-anti-competitive behavior because it's PRO-consumer. Apple is literally giving away a $4 app that was previously available ONLY to iOS users to all iOS 16 users. If this is anti-consumer in your mind I would really like to hear what acquisition is not an antitrust problem from your perspective.
- blue_cookeh 4y agoAndroid support was killed post Apple purchase so I'm confused as to how you could possibly _not_ see this as anticonsumer. Apple purchased Dark Sky and then they proceeded to remove access to it for the majority of the world's mobile users.
- fileyfood500 4y ago
- freetime2 4y ago> Funny, you just explained how easy it was. But now it's so hard that Apple engineers can't just rebuild the parts they need? The parent said that the data Dark Sky uses is public and that anyone could start their own alternative. They did not claim that it would be easy to do so. They also said that it was probably cheaper for Apple to buy Dark Sky than build it themselves. That does not mean that Apple can’t build it themselves if sufficiently motivated. I don’t see any inconsistency here in the above statements.
- wyre 4y ago> anyone could start their own alternative. They did not claim that it would be easy to do so. Saying that anyone can accomplish a task posits some level of triviality or easiness that enables anyone to be able to accomplish it. If I say anyone can lose weight, it is safe to assume that I mean losing weight is easy enough that anyone can do it.
- freetime2 4y ago> If I say anyone can lose weight, it is safe to assume that I mean losing weight is easy enough that anyone can do it. I would interpret “anyone can lose weight” to mean that anyone has the capability to lose weight, not that it is easy. On the contrary, I find losing weight to be pretty hard! I do recognize that the phrase “anyone can do x” can often carry the connotation of being easy. But it depends on context. Since we’re talking about a proprietary weather forecasting model and accompanying UI, I see no reason to assume it would be trivial. But rather that the data is available for anyone to use, should they decide to attempt to build the next Dark Sky. This is in contrast to building the next Google Maps, for example, where just getting a hold of the necessary data would probably cost a good deal of money.
- lynndotpy 4y agoI believe the point of Dark Sky was that they used air-pressure sensor data from the phones they were installed on. That was the secret sauce that (used to) power their hyper-local forecasts.
- cryptoz 4y agoDark Sky did not explain themselves with the barometer data thing. Their actual algorithm did radar-based extrapolation, meaning they used statistics to 'move' radar features like rain into the future. This is why Dark Sky always had a problem with forecasting new rainfall and was better at forecasting existing rain moving into your location based on wind speed. They claimed something about barometer data but I don't honestly believe that they used it to improve their forecasts. I worked on this problem at different companies for many years, and with academia, and found it to be quite difficult. Possible, doable, but very difficult to demonstrate actual improvement. Significant academic work was done after Dark Sky made their claim, and the papers published used ensemble kalman filters among other on-device data-cleaning techniques that I do not believe Dark Sky implemented. So I doubt their barometer claims.
- freetime2 4y agoI had never heard of this before, but a quick Google search did turn up a bunch of news stories from 2015 [1] covering the announcement of this feature. I'm not sure if it's something they still do, though, and I haven't really heard anything about it since then. [1] https://www.zdnet.com/article/dark-sky-weather-app-iphone-6-plus-barometer/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/dark-sky-weather-app-iphone-6-...