I like this. These are good points. I think it's worth noting that your position is not the same as GP's, however. One small objection: I assume you lead with

I like this. These are good points. I think it's worth noting that your position is not the same as GP's, however. One small objection: I assume you lead with "of course" in your first sentence because that value is intuitive to you. It's intuitive to me, too, but I don't have an argument for why it's moral.