6 ms·
Another discovery that something thought to be uniquely human really isn't that hard.
by Animats 4y ago
Another discovery that something thought to be uniquely human really isn't that hard.
- catach 4y agoIt seems to me that the human effort spent in creating the original images in an AI's data set is an important element to consider when thinking of the "difficulty" here.
- lifthrasiir 4y agoYes, that 4 GB of data can't be really independently generated, but the fact that a large chunk of that effort can be compressed into 4 GB is still amazing.
- CamperBob2 4y agoIf your life's work can be compressed down to 2 bytes, it wasn't that hard. OTOH, if the 2 bytes is an index into a larger corpus of collected works, the question becomes more interesting. OTOH, if the corpus is an ensemble of other 2-byte objects...
- causality0 4y agoCertainly, but those human artists were also trained on a data set their whole lives. Raise a baby with no training data set and they might produce a handprint on a wall or a rectangle of facepaint. There's a reason indigenous tribesmen don't spontaneously invent hyperrealism.
- catach 4y agoAbsolutely. Though I think that speaks to one of the ways we tend to discount the difficulty of developing human artistry, rather than a defense of AI gen being "not hard".
- bayindirh 4y agoHowever, there's a major misconception about training of humans and AI. Image generating AIs are trained with massive amounts of images and text, however image generating humans train with much broader spectrum of experience. Also, feeding a model tons of images created by humans (directly or by proxy) and claiming that AI is generating something completely new is a bit naive IMHO. Humans mix a much more broader and deeper experience pool to create things without prompts. An AI model blurts out something derived from a corpus of images and text created by humans, that's all. The technology is impressive for sure, and it marks a new era in terms of possibilities, but it doesn't take my breath away, sorry.
- catach 4y ago> claiming that AI is generating something completely new is a bit naive IMHO. I don't see how AI art is less new than the vast majority of human art. Both can create unique compositions that are still deeply rooted in patterns and principles thousands of years old. > Humans mix a much more broader and deeper experience pool to create things without prompts. AI does not have understanding, but it's stealing the underlying patterns that are the end result of that human experience.
- quitit 4y agoFurther to your point, comparing humans to AI is not just misunderstanding AI, but also looks past how humans create and choose the styles which this AI is now reproducing through a statical approach. Without the human guidance the AI would be bland, AI is limited to the walls of whatever it has been exposed to - humans are not. The AI emulates. Humans create. - The significance here is not trivial.
- practice9 4y agoHumans emulate as well, and produce bland art as well. I've seen lots of human-made art (especially on Artstation) that failed to elicit any emotional response in me. The reason people are having this discussion is a fear of AI creating aesthetically pleasing and deep emotionally through statistical approach. And the deeper fear that AI can potentially "hack" our senses by providing us with exactly what we want to see, read or hear (statistically). i.e. if some subset of art is pushing our biological buttons more than all other art, and the effect is generalizable over human population, what would that say about us?
- betwixthewires 4y agoWho would've thought art would get automated before driving.
- JohnFen 4y agoIt depends on what you mean by "art". There's different sorts of art for different purposes (commercial, fine, etc.), and for many of these sorts of art having an AI make it would be acceptable. But when I think "art" without a qualifier, I think "fine art". And the purpose of fine art, for me, is human communication of ephemeral things that aren't possible to communicate in language. I don't want AI generated fine art because it turns the art into just a pretty picture. It's no longer about another person communicating something significant and human to me. It removes its purpose for existing. In that view, I totally understand why some art communities would ban AI-generated art. I don't see a problem with it. I'm sure other communities will not ban such art. That's fine, too. But I know which community I would be more interested in paying attention to.
- practice9 4y ago> It's no longer about another person communicating something significant and human to me. There is a person thinking about the prompt, typing in the prompt, painstakingly selecting the image that matches what they imagined in their head. It just less elitist, as now even a child can create a complex, meaningful and beautiful images by leveraging the essence of human art (compressed into a single ML model). I, for one, never had the time & chance to learn painting. Even if I did it as a hobby, it would take me up to a decade to become proficient at it. And now I can ask AI to paint what I dreamt about last night (!!!), or create an impressionist painting almost exactly like I see it (or even better). Fun factor is also there: I can see how an anime character could look in real life, or put a movie character in a new context , or just generate cute corgis wearing funny hats and driving cars
- andsoitis 4y agoHow would you describe a Rothko in words? Can you create a Van Gogh painting by incantation?
- Hayarotle 4y ago> There is a person thinking about the prompt, typing in the prompt, painstakingly selecting the image that matches what they imagined in their head. Which does make this a type of art. It just isn't the same form of art as digital painting, the same way painting a tree is not the same type of art as growing and 100 trees, choosing one of them and taking a photograph of it. Photography is definitely an art-form, but it's a different art-form from digital painting, even if the end result of the both of them can be a digital image. Not better or worse, but definitely different.
- xani_ 4y agoThat's like saying "well, making knives is easy" while ignoring everything that is needed to make materials then shaping them into final form. It's only "easy" because bunch of people over years perfected every step of the process.
- sinenomine 4y agoCan't help but think about the obvious: maybe we should just skip all the drudgery of the natural convulsive progress and ruthless competition, push "accelerate" and get to the mature AGI civilization regime as soon as possible? And there we should just ask our new creative oracle machines the obvious: "devise an understandable minimally invasive method of uplifting our own cognition and extending our biological lifespan". Surely at least some gene/cell/whatever therapy which does what we need is theoretically possible - the human beings aren't special enough for this not to be the case. At least that's the zeitgeist I perceive among others who understand the significance of the unfolding progress.
- mLuby 4y agoPushing "accelerate" costs a great deal. Investors will want a return on their capital: either in money pressed from unequal access to the resulting paradise or in direct power over this new god.
- sinenomine 4y agoWith billions upon billions spent on Big Science, asking the government to spend just 1 billion on an AI training run with guaranteed spectacular results doesn't sound too outlandish. Why should we pay taxes, if the government won't even train AI for us, given such opportunity?
- mLuby 4y agoAGI is an existential threat to human-led governments. Why would they build something to displace them?
- sinenomine 4y agoWe all know that analogies from Hollywood classic scifi movies aren't productive or even at all useful in our mundane reality. The general-purpose AI is going to be a very useful, obedient, capable tool, and the great powers are going to seek ownership over it, like they do with various military and space technologies.