3 ms·
Thoughts that come to mind as I read: - why has increased energy availability stopped increasing cognitive ability in the massive leaps it used to? - I defini
by renewiltord 4y ago
Thoughts that come to mind as I read:
- why has increased energy availability stopped increasing cognitive ability in the massive leaps it used to?
- I definitely know there are things that I struggle to grok that a few people rapidly do, and there are things that I rapidly grok that others fail to - and often this appears monotonically so general intelligence appears real
- is modern intelligence just the result of sufficiently diverse training? i.e. do we have similar brains to our ancient ancestors just with far superior stimulation?
- I suspect that all sorts of models will arise from the same base machine (our brains) scaled up (more neurons with more density and more energy). It's likely that physical constraints - energy use, mother birth canal - are bigger determiners since we have decoupled high intelligence from gener survival now
- I find the simulation discussion tiresome. It seems masturbatory because it is so indulgent but does not advance thought. No one ever provides future hypotheses that are useful from a sim perspective or future thought experiments that go anywhere or testable experiments. I think the sim theory is a philosophical dead end and we'll conclude that one day.
- If new cognition is needed, is it possible from the brain scale-up I mentioned before? Or is it like an aleph0 to aleph1 transition? I suspect there is a Turing completeness to cognition - in that there are some base laws which makes access to all math possible.
- however, if scale-up is possible and if math is all accessible, we could imagine set-sets who are specialized optimized intelligence. Does the general absence of these imply that we haven't yet decoupled general intelligence from individual outcome?
- I don't think direct experimentation on the limits of our intelligence will yield any outcome. I do think that we will eventually invent either biological or electronic super intelligences and this will likely result in conclusions that reveal something here.
- I do notice that on psychedelics I become more susceptible to the idea that there is some greater truth out there that I'm just barely missing but considering that I never produce anything from that - perhaps this Missing Greater Truth feeling is actually a lesser form of consciousness - I.e. it's what you get when you leave intelligence and full consciousness behind. It's what bootstraps things. Anyway, I subscribe to that side because I find a slightly losing-myself feeling when I attempt to fully chase the "ideas I can't hold" concept.
- sinenomine 4y agoI like the questions, esp. this one: > If new cognition is needed, is it possible from the brain scale-up I mentioned before? Or is it like an aleph0 to aleph1 transition? I suspect there is a Turing completeness to cognition - in that there are some base laws which makes access to all math possible. There is indirect evidence from multiple studies of ML models and animal intelligence pointing in the direction of "scaling up is good for intelligence, if your system isn't limited by global connectivity too much". If you want to know more, see https://www.gwern.net/Scaling-hypothesis https://www.gwern.net/Scaling-hypothesis and Haier's The Neuroscience of Intelligence.
- renewiltord 4y agoI follow Gwern's Twitter but I must have missed that. Thanks for the two recommendations.