6 ms·
The chief purpose of a mixer is financial privacy. It’s just that on a public blockchain privacy from snoops and privacy from law enforcement can’t be different
by adastra22 4y ago
The chief purpose of a mixer is financial privacy. It’s just that on a public blockchain privacy from snoops and privacy from law enforcement can’t be differentiated.
- woodruffw 4y agoIf the Treasury or Dutch authorities are to be believed, the chief purpose of this mixer was to facilitate money laundering. That is key to this entire discussion: they have reason to believe that Pertsev knowingly ran a money laundering service, rather than running a service that criminals can abuse to launder money.
- dannyw 4y agoThat's interesting. As a Tornado Cash user, I have never associated this with an intentional money laundering service, but rather a bunch of developers advancing zk-SNARKs and other cryptographic primitives. As someone who was excited by the original Bitcoin whitepaper back in 2011, zk-SNARKS was what excited me about cryptocurrency again in 2021.
- woodruffw 4y agoYour association isn't what regulators are concerned with. They're concerned with the intent of the creator and operator of the service, which is why he's the one who's been arrested.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoAnd you're buying into propaganda suggesting someone pushing the envelope in cryptography is creating tooling specifically for money laundering. 30 years ago, the NSA toed a similar line in their war on PGP, saying it was used in practice for "money laundering, child pornography, and terrorism" - https://reason.com/video/2020/10/21/cryptowars-gilmore-zimmermann-cryptography/ https://reason.com/video/2020/10/21/cryptowars-gilmore-zimme...
- woodruffw 4y agoFor the umpteenth time in this thread: intent matters. Regardless of what the NSA said 30 years ago, it is manifestly apparent to every single person in this conversation that neither HTTPS nor PGP nor any other cryptographic scheme designed for individual privacy was designed with money laundering in mind. At the absolute worst, they were agnostic to the presence of criminal activity. This is in contrast to Tornado Cash, which was repeatedly told that their service was being used to launder money.
- throwaway742 4y agoSo if the developers of PGP were told that ISIL was using their service to facilitate terrorism should they shut down the project?
- woodruffw 4y agoWhat project? PGP was bundled up and thrown onto the Internet; there was no development or services community established around it. The US Government threw a hissy fit over that and they ended up distributing it as a "book" instead, converting it into a question of free expression. There is no meaningful sense in which PGP could ever be said to "facilitate" terrorism in the same way that Tornado Cash is rightfully characterized as facilitating money laundering. PGP is a program that runs on your host, encrypting your email. Tornado Cash is a service, run by an individual who was warned to cease serving sanctioned entities, and failed to do so.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoIgnoring the front-end (which is unnecessary to use it), Tornado Cash is a protocol, run by a decentralized network of computers. The code for the protocol is shared by a network of computers execute this code according to specific rules and validate transactions. A specific deployment of the code was sanctioned, but this means anyone else using the code (which has to be deployed to this network to be used trustlessly) is risky to use now
- 4y ago
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> have never associated this with an intentional money laundering service Most customers of a canonical money launderer, a laundromat, don’t realise it’s a front. That doesn’t matter if the owner is laundering money. Tornado laundered money for North Korea [1]. (It announced this months before the sanctions, a period in which the developers could have reacted but didn’t [EDIT: in any meaningful way].) That it was also obfuscating legitimate flows is frankly irrelevant. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-08/crypto-mixer-tornado-cash-sanctioned-by-us-treasury-department https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-08-08/crypto-mi...
- adastra22 4y agoWhat could the developers have done?
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> What could the developers have done? Not sure. Their problem. If the only option was shutting it down, that. It would have looked better, which could have prompted sympathetic legislation. At the very least, it would have likely avoided sanctions.
- adastra22 4y agoYou can’t just say “they had months to react but didn’t” if you don’t have any idea of what they could have done differently. React how?
- hef19898 4y agoClose down until you figured out a way to react. Money laundering is serious crime, helping North Korea is as well. Tornado cash did apparently both, and authorities gave them a heads up. If it was me, I would close my shop down.
- douglaswlance 4y ago
- TechBro8615 4y ago
- phatfish 4y agoNo, that would be the chief purpose of reddit.com. Try posting CP to r/furries and see how long that sub, (or reddit itself if they ignore it) stays online. Tornado Cash ignored the warnings. Enabling money laundering and providing a means to avoid economic sanctions will get you in serious trouble.
- everfree 4y agoThere's nothing inherent to Tornado Cash that makes it better for money laundering than for privacy. It's very basic software from a functionality perspective. You put coins into a pool, then at a later date, you take coins back out of the pool. That's all. It's hard to ascribe specific intent to a system like that, beyond the intent to give people a tool to transact without the entire history of their account being broadcast publicly and permanently on the blockchain.
- abigail95 4y agoWhen we say he ran it, did he actually deploy resources that laundered money or just publish a spec that others used to do the laundering? Like how far am I allowed to go to describe how you might launder money on a blockchain before I get arrested?
- TremendousJudge 4y agoThat probably depends on your lawyer. If he's bad enough I'd guess you can get a penalty even if you didn't see any financial gain from the scheme.
- salawat 4y agoMost ledgers are not public, or based on any methodology requiring public view, because the only way to both transact, keeping intact a tightly coherent paper trail as required by law is, and ensure privacy is to not make the ledger available in all it's glory to everyone. Doing what Tornado.cash does, is by definition, laundering, and if you didn't want your financial matters known to the world, mayhaps you should not have used a technology based on public ledger?
- adastra22 4y agoTornado cash does something different from money laundering. If you use TC you can actually provably undo the mixing and reveal your financial history to a third party. If the government came and asked “what’s the source of these funds?” You could open the commitment and show which input is yours. It just breaks the last model law enforcement is used to where they just siphon up all private financial data for their own uses.
- salawat 4y agoIn the U.S. this is a no go for criminal investigation, as there is no way law enforcement to compel you to offer up that proof that isn't able to fall under 5th Amendment protections, whereas Third Party Doctrine actually gave them a way to get at the tramsaction chain through the service provider. Now, unless you want to run into some creative reinterpretation of the 4th and 5th amendments a la the definitional butchering that is generally applied to the 2nd you can't push that question onto someone who is the subject of credible allegations of money laundering Believe it or not, there is such a thing as a pointedly not implenented feature. This has been one of them, because it is the difference between essentially making financial crime tractable to investigate vs. not. I'm not taking a side, just trying to make more obvious some of the more subtle nuance most people won't articulate for you, as it tends to be part of "the quiet part". You must employ 2nd and higher order thinking to the U.S. and international regulatory state.
- mikece 4y agoYou hit it on the head: this is a War on Privacy being presented as a war on money-laundering. The biggest money laundering schemes involve commercial banks and real estate (*ahem* TRUMP! *ahem*....) and not online cryptocurrency schemes. It's not like the North Koreans have no other way to mask the trail on what they steal, and I suspect those saying they are certain the North Koreans are bad guys here will insist they cannot divulge how they know this (under the aegis of National Security or some other excuse).
- PuppyTailWags 4y ago> I suspect those saying they are certain the North Koreans are bad guys here will insist they cannot divulge how they know this (under the aegis of National Security or some other excuse). My understanding is that the aegis of National Security isn't unwarranted sometimes. For example, if they know NK are bad guys here because one of their spies literally witnessed the laundering (as a secretary, paper-pusher, programmer, or similar) then there is no way to disclose the source. Even a "we have an eyewitness" will tip NK off to look into the people in the process (NK will be able to definitively rule out their technology being hacked, or a bug planted somewhere).
- ashwagary 4y agoToo bad for national security that people have rights. I saw a post recently about the fact that nobody could easily identify the users of pay phones in the past and how modern day lawmakers would probably ban them out of fear of anonimity. It showed just how much privacy the average person has lost over the years...there has to be pushback.