4 ms·
They shouldn't be expected to update these for as long as they're useful. They should be required to open up the hardware if they refuse to update the software.
by pessimizer 4y ago
They shouldn't be expected to update these for as long as they're useful. They should be required to open up the hardware if they refuse to update the software. That should be the rule: you get to pretend that locking people out of the hardware is for their own good as long as you continue to update their software for free. You can't just be allowed to arbitrarily EOL perfectly functional hardware.
- ElCheapo 4y agoIn all fairness, as longs as patents exist you simply can't "open up" a piece of technology. What you can do is reverse engineer it, since it's allowed becausenof the manufacturer's drop of support
- causi 4y agoIn all fairness, as longs as patents exist you simply can't "open up" a piece of technology That's not true at all. Divulging data without offering license terms does nothing to hurt your ability to enforce intellectual property rights. The people using that data just do so knowing they're technically breaking the law. Patents are not trademarks.
- wongarsu 4y agoUnlike trademarks, you can selectively enforce patents without risking them. And in a way, the patent system is exactly about "opening up" technology. After all the idea of a patent is "you tell everyone how to build it, in return nobody is allowed to use that knowledge commercially for X years unless you allow it. This aligns great with "give us the tools to modify the software of hardware you find commercially unattractive".
- nrclark 4y agoI realize that is a bit of a topic change, but do you think that ideal reflects the reality of patents today? I've read a lot of modern patents, and not one of them was written to convey useful information. They're all dense legal writing, and as vague as the author can get away with. Most medium/big companies have patent attorneys whose entire job is writing patents. They don't care about the patents having any useful details to make it a useful reference. Usually the attorneys aren't subject experts on the patent topic, and couldn't make it accurate even if they tried. Modern patents are a game where you file a whole bunch and then wait for somebody to step on one by accident with a parallel invention. Then you sue them unless they have enough patents to also sue you. Patents don't promote innovation at all, at least not any more. If anything, they're a tax on our industry and they stifle small players - exactly the sort of person who they're supposed to help.
- bluGill 4y agoI think that is something to write our congressman about (or equivalent if not in US). Right now not only are patents written for lawyers, but the law encourages you not to look at patents since if you don't know about something relevant and you reinvent it you owe less damages than if you knew and still chose to infringe. For patents to be useful they need to be writing in the language of experts in the field -not lawyers. And the law needs to make it best for my employer to make me search for and read potentially relevant patents before doing anything. That is infringing after making an effort to avoid a patent (that the courts decide is not enough effort) is better than infringing without knowing.
- bzxcvbn 4y agoI don't really understand your comment. The whole point of a patent is that the description of the invention is made public. If you don't even want your competitors to know how you do it, then you keep the IP as a trade secret, but then you can't enforce a non-existent patent.
- Volundr 4y ago5 years is also shockingly short to me for a piece of networking hardware. One more reason to avoid Cisco.
- illiac786 4y agoPlease provide examples?
- genmud 4y agoI mean a 25 year plus run on the 6500s is a pretty good example. Or even the 10 year run of early nexus products. https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/support/switches/catalyst-6500-series-switches/series.html https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/support/switches/catalyst-6500...
- illiac786 4y agoI do not see 25 year of software support on these? There is threes years between End of Sale and End of Vulnerabilty and Security Support (Patching) on the 6503-E for example [0] If you mean the time between the first day of manufacturing and the end of software patching, it will be higher, but it’s definitely not 25, years. The 6503 (not the 6503-E) went end of hw support in 2012 [1], patching must have stopped a couple of years prior to this, but it’s so old I can’t find the EoL notice for this… Finally if you mean “time between first day of manufacturing and end of patching”, then the the RV110W has at least 7 years. I can find article listing it in 2011 already [2], end of patching was 2018 [3]. I completely agree on the idea of pushing for open sourcing hardware and firmware when a device becomes end of support, but we also need to get the facts straight. Headlines like “cisco won’t patch legacy VPN routers” are simply disingenuous and pure clickbait. But they do make me smile =) so it’s not all bad. [0] https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/collateral/switches/catalyst-6500-series-switches/eos-eol-notice-c51-741568.html https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/collateral/switches/c... [1] https://www.curvature.com/resources/tech-guides/cisco-6500-end-of-life/ https://www.curvature.com/resources/tech-guides/cisco-6500-e... [2] https://www.cnet.com/videos/cisco-rv110w-wireless-n-vpn-firewall/ https://www.cnet.com/videos/cisco-rv110w-wireless-n-vpn-fire... [3] https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/collateral/routers/small-business-rv-series-routers/eos-eol-notice-c51-738249.html https://www.cisco.com/c/en/us/products/collateral/routers/sm...
- thunderbong 4y agoI totally agree. Not to sidetrack your assertion, but even Google and Apple do this for their mobiles. Perfectly usable old mobile phones don't run the newer version of the apps at all. This seems to be more and more prevalent even in other areas like washing machines, microwaves and even cars. I don't get old parts. Even the service technicians throw up their hands and say "Just buy a newer model".
- bombcar 4y agoThe problem with the parts is once the machine is no longer being made, they stop making the computer board for it, and the part inventory dwindles. And when it’s $300-400 for a computer board, you might as well get a whole new machine. The only way I’ve found to counteract that is to look for commercial or commercial-based units that share parts for years or more. But this can be harder for some classes of equipment ( commercial ovens are NOT at all like residential - they’re usually not insulated) but it can be a start.
- pessimizer 4y ago> The problem with the parts is once the machine is no longer being made, they stop making the computer board for it, and the part inventory dwindles. But that's nobodies fault, as long as companies are required to release any protocols or specs for interop. You can't sensibly force companies to turn back the clock forever or stay in a business they don't want to be in. You can sensibly force companies to fully describe the products that they sell unless they are willing to continue to maintain them. If they're required to release the specs of parts that they won't replace, Chinese factories would flood ebay with any of them that they think they can move 50K units of.
- zibby8 4y agoApple seems pretty good at keeping old phones up to date. The iPhone 6S is still supported, which was released 7 years ago.
- dont__panic 4y ago
- lazyier 4y agoIf you are buying a Cisco router you are buying a closed source product. Why would you expect them to open source anything when you are happy to give them money for closed source firmware? You are literally paying them for being closed source. Stop rewarding these corporations for screwing you over and they will cease to screw you over. Either they will change their ways or go out of business if enough people feel the way you do. And, regardless, you would have solved these sorts of problems for yourself long before that happens. It's been a very long time since Cisco was the only game in town for enterprise networking. Companies like Broadcom have released powerful ASICs that allows practically anybody to build a high performance routers and switches.
- salawat 4y agoI would not hold up Broadcom as being any better than Cisco in the openness department. If anything it's just more of the same, which while it technically satisfies the definition of competition, does not largely modify the lands ape of networking dedicated hardware in the more open direction.
- Kinrany 4y agoRelying on people to magically solve tragedy of the commons by themselves never works.
- nsteel 4y agoDon't Cisco use those exact Broadcom chips in these types of low-end products? A high-performance chip is just one part of the product, you need software also.
- hansel_der 4y agotrue hyperscalers got into building their own switches a decade ago. whitelabel silicon and software _IS_ available, but the entrenchement is still huge as noone ever got fired for buying cisco.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoI wouldn't hire someone that mentioned we should purchase Cisco.