4 ms·
I do not see any necessity to be either/or. The relative "amounts" should be in some balance, but its impossible to equalise, in any meaningful sense. One is a
by ggm 4y ago
I do not see any necessity to be either/or. The relative "amounts" should be in some balance, but its impossible to equalise, in any meaningful sense. One is a fleeting experience, the other has sustained value at a lower intensity. They are probably different emotional effects on your wellbeing, and have different outcomes.
experience things, and take joy in simple experiences, and do acts which add value, and avoid harms to others.
I can have hedonic happiness eating well cooked rice, and eudaimonic sharing it
with friends. MFK Fisher writes how in old age, a simple dish of green peas can be more satisfying than a rich Escoffier sauced dish. thats zen class hedonic.
- hunter-gatherer 4y agoSounds like you are in complete agreement with the article.
- ggm 4y agoyes. I wanted to avoid doing what another thread pointed out was needless argumentative oppositional voice on HN. Maybe I should have said "I agree" fundamentally, I think this is a false dichotomy. I don't think the author proposed a strawman to knock down, but I do think its an instance of a faulty model: the implicit either/or in "two kinds of.." don't apply.