2 ms·
One way to look at pedantry is that it's when someone emphasizes technical correctness, even when another person's actual intent is understood. If it's the mid
by kelnos 4y ago
One way to look at pedantry is that it's when someone emphasizes technical correctness, even when another person's actual intent is understood.
If it's the middle of July, and someone in California sets up a meeting with someone in New York, but tells them "9am PST", it would be understood to actually mean "PT" or "PDT". I suspect only certain kinds of neurodivergent people would show up for the meeting an hour off. And hopefully someone who genuinely thought PST was the intention would ask for clarification. Most people, though, who would bring it up do so just for reasons of pedantry, not because they're actually confused.
- kragen 4y agoNeurodivergent people, or people who aren't in California, which is actually more than 99% of people, and who therefore have to look up the timezone offset somehow. It's probably true that the <1% of people you hang out with most of the time can correct the error without even thinking about it because they live in California too. But that doesn't make it a pedantic error; it's an error that regularly has serious consequences, precisely because people's actual intent is misunderstood.
- kragen 4y agoThis is really the same kind of reasoning as "most people know how tall five feet is" or "most people know that 'wicked' is a compliment" or "most people know that 0.59¢ per minute really means 59¢ per minute". It's obnoxious, back-slapping ethnocentrism masquerading as common sense. Most people don't know how tall five feet is, because they use the metric system, and they don't even speak English. Most people in California and New York know those things, and they're also likely to know that you don't really mean "PST" if you're talking about a date when California is on daylight time. But most people don't know those things, and so if what you say is the opposite of what you mean, you can expect them to be confused when they look up the definition. If that's what you're shooting for, then by all means, go right ahead. But if you're trying for clear communication, you might want to get a little bit clearer about the kinds of things "most people" know and the kinds of things most people actually know. Daylight savings time transitions cause me scheduling grief on a regular basis, not because I'm "neurodivergent" but just because I don't know what dates Belgium or California or Chile does their stupid clock changes, because I don't live there, and they all do them on separate dates.
- kragen 4y agoAs mentioned in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32860778 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32860778, timezone confusion led Scott Aaronson to miss an important meeting just today. The problem is real. (But no word on whether the cause was a daylight-time/standard-time mixup.)