3 ms·
The 1.3% number is clearly nonsense. It links to this paper: https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/LandFossil.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/g
by hedora 4y ago
The 1.3% number is clearly nonsense. It links to this paper:
https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/LandFossil.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/group/efmh/jacobson/Articles/I/Land...
The biggest line item in the estimate is oil wells. They assume an active oil well consumes 12 acres (0.05 sq km) of land. There’s no way that is close to accurate. The well and pump head use a few hundred square feet, max. They usually have an area around the well head that’s mowed for access, and also an access road. Typically, there is also a pipe to carry the oil away. Even if there is on-site storage, the tanks are at most 100’s of square feet.
An acre is over 43,000 square feet. My estimates would have to be off by a factor of 1000 for a well head to occupy 12 acres.
The idea that we would use ~ 1% of the earth’s surface for wind, solar and hydro is similarly nonsensical. Wind farms can be dual use (e.g., cows can live on them).
Solar panels can more than power a one story building on average while using less than the entire square footage of the building. The earth’s surface is no where near 1% buildings. Cities account for less than 1% of the surface.
- kbenson 4y agoInstead of using estimated based on what you think the equipment should take up, perhaps you should take a look at the google maps link your sibling posted, and zoom into some oil wells (the cleared land lots) and use the measurement tool (right click) to get the area of some of them (which it shows if you create an enclosed area). I just measures three, with the following square footage: 443k sq ft, 338k sq ft, 164k sq ft. Each lot looks to have multiple wells, but there's a lot of just cleared empty land for each lot, so I suspect you're being very optimistic on your assessment of how much land is used for each well. The study cited may be overestimating also, but they cite their sources (even if they aren't explaining exactly where they get well land use amount from), so perhaps there's an explanation buried deeper in there.