2 ms·
tl:dr if you need it, go for it :) my 2 cents is not needed at home and even for some of my clients the complexicty vs a simple setup and a few min downtime sti
by woopwoop24 4y ago
tl:dr if you need it, go for it :) my 2 cents is not needed at home and even for some of my clients the complexicty vs a simple setup and a few min downtime still speaks for MTTR instead of HA which noone can debug.
not about stress but to have HA proxmox cluster you will need at least 3 machines or fake one with a quorum machine without vms on it. Sure your vms will run if one machines goes down, but do you have HA Storage underneath? ganesha would work but more complexity or another network storage with more machines. Don't get me wrong it is fun to play with, but i doubt any homelab needs HA and cannot have a few minutes downtime. Or what do you do in case your internet provider goes down or when you have a power outage? i don't want to provoke, i have fiber switches and 10G at home and have 2 locations to switch in case one location goes down but i can live with multiple days of downtime if i have to, or if not i take my backups and fire some VM's on some cloudprovider and be back online in a few min and pay for it because backups are in both locations.
i would much rather develop a simple LB + autoscaling group with a deployment pipeline (lambda or some other control loop) and containers on it than a k8s cluster the client is not prepared for. if they outgrow this, most likely the following solution is better than going 100% "cloud" the first time. Most clients go from java 8 Jboss monolith to spring containers in k8s and then wonder why it is such a shitshow. but yeah pays the bills so i am not complaining that often ^^
- j45 4y agoYour right that an HA bar is a higher one. And the more ornate your tech stack the more work for HA. More reasonably, mirroring a few Intel NUCs isn’t that far fetched where backups can spill off to a pair of mirrored nas’. If storage failover is needed, it’s not hard to find a used fibre channel storage array on eBay. For the network, lots of capable little devices like the edgerouters. 2 internet connections (Cable/dsl + LTE) isn’t that crazy anymore. Starlink will be interesting too. Power? A UPS or two can keep up a few hours on a low wattage system. In turn can be run by a bigger deep cycle battery, maybe feed by some solar or a small generator.