19 ms·
> I bash unfounded claims about it, such as those made in this discussion: […] that all other designs are "fringe" You're mischaracterizing Mr Walton's argumen
by littlestymaar 4y ago
> I bash unfounded claims about it, such as those made in this discussion: […] that all other designs are "fringe"
You're mischaracterizing Mr Walton's argument here: it's not “non-Rust” design which are fringe, it's “non-memory safe”, and he's arguably correct on that front: no mainstream (even in the broadest sense) language that ever came after C++ was memory-unsafe. And C++ has been progressively abandoned from every domain where its performances characteristics weren't enough of an argument. It is the consensus in PL design, whether you like it or not, and Zig is going against that 30+ years old consensus. Rust is simply the first one to seriously challenge C and C++ on their remaining domains, but memory-safe languages are ubiquitous and have been for years.
> that it's achieved extreme success
For the domain Rust is aiming at, no other languages has ever reached this level since C++, that's it. Rust hasn't taken the crown, but it's doing things that have not been done before, and it's a hell of a success for a programming language designer!
> This one gave me pause, but I think you'll find that what mostly triggers my HN comments is not so much Rust but claims related to software correctness. […] (just as before we heard similar claims about Haskell, that triggered me just as much)
I think it's mainly a thinking framework issue. You can view software defects as belonging to one of two classes: (1) design errors, and (2) programming mistakes (typos, copy-paste error, forgetting to call a mandatory function, etc.). TLA+ is a wonderful tool to make sure that your design is correct, but it's helpless against programming mistake. Respectively, the ML family of languages (and Haskell) offer really powerful tools to reduce the number of programming mistakes in shipped code (if it compiles, it has likely no programming errors) but it is completely helpless against broken design.
The frequency or gravity of software defects caused by those two kinds of bugs are context dependent but they are both sources of bugs, so in a sense (even discounting memory-safety) Rust is improving
software correctness by reducing the number of programming mistakes, even if does nothing (if we set memory issues aside) to reduce design errors.
There is no Rust vs TLA+ like there is Coq vs TLA+, Rust doesn't claim it can prove the high level requirements of your problem, it just claim it can prove memory-safety and thread-safety and give you a nice mistake-prone development environment. If you want design correctness, use Rust to implement the design you've validated in TLA+!
> Actually, out of job postings, which, however imperfect, is the best metric we have: https://www.devjobsscanner.com/blog/top-8-most-demanded-lang https://www.devjobsscanner.com/blog/top-8-most-demanded-lang...
Ctrl-F for Rust on this page returns no results…
> Objective-C is irrelevant (as its adoption is tied to that of another product, kind of like VBA), and with the exception of Python, pretty much yes (I said neared or reached, not reached). Other than Python, no language showed surprising growth after a decade, including C (1983) and C++ (1995).
That's a surprisingly high number of wrong statements per n-gram…
As an aside, in a non-emotional discussion about a programming language, you should probably refrain yourself from insulting one of its designer. Because, yes, saying to a PL designer that his language is “struggling to find relevance” is an insult, the same way calling someone else's mom “fat and ugly”, regardless of the factual accuracy of the statement.
- pron 4y ago> and he's arguably correct on that front: no mainstream (even in the broadest sense) language that ever came after C++ was memory-unsafe. I don't understand that logic, as we're only talking about low-level languages. Of all the low-level languages developed after C++, including D, Rust, Zig, Odin, and JAI, the majority aren't memory safe. > It is the consensus in PL design, whether you like it or not It clearly isn't even the majority opinion in low-level PL design, let alone the consensus. > but it's doing things that have not been done before, and it's a hell of a success for a programming language designer! Sure, by that metric it is a great success. > it just claim it can prove memory-safety and thread-safety I know, but the reason it does so is as a means to an end. The reason why anyone wants memory safety is that it eliminates certain classes of bugs that can be quite harmful. The reason why we may not want memory safety is that sometimes it can come at the cost of other bugs, overall not helping correctness. Anyway, software correctness is a complex issue, and it is not currently known whether Rust's approach or Zig's -- if either -- is more effective at achieving correctness. > Ctrl-F for Rust on this page returns no results… Yeah, it's an image or something, but it's there. > you should probably refrain yourself from insulting one of its designer. Sorry about that.
- littlestymaar 4y ago> Of all the low-level languages developed after C++, including D, Rust, Zig, Odin, and JAI, the majority aren't memory safe. It's funny because you've included a language built around garbage collection (D), and a language that doesn't really exist yet (Jai, which is actually a placeholder name). Btw, this list (which basically contains only names we can see every once in a while on HN) shows you're really not familiar with the PL design space (which is fine actually but you should probably not be arguing about academic domains you're not familiar with). > I know, but the reason it does so is as a means to an end. The reason why anyone wants memory safety is that it eliminates certain classes of bugs that can be quite harmful. The reason why we may not want memory safety is that sometimes it can come at the cost of other bugs, overall not helping correctness. Anyway, software correctness is a complex issue, and it is not currently known whether Rust's approach or Zig's -- if either -- is more effective at achieving correctness. The idea that Rust may cause more bugs than it avoids is backed by zero evidence. Is Rust worth it, from a engineering team perspective, given its other constraints (low number of trained practitioners, slow compilation time, or even an hypothetical productivity cost) is a fine question, especially when I see Rust being used for back-end roles where other entrenched languages are doing fine, but claiming that “maybe Rust some unknown type of bugs we cannot be sure” is a fallacy (same fallacy applied to a different context: “climate is a complex issue, maybe there's some non-anthropic cause for global warming”). Zig doesn't particularly address “correctness”, more than any typical language: it doesn't address “design errors” more than Rust, and is arguably addressing less “programming mistakes”. There is no trade-off in correctness between those two (Rust is trading learning curve against correctness, and it might even trade productivity for correctness, but it's not trading one kind of correctness in favor of another). One can argue that “programming mistakes” are unimportant overall, because they get ironed out easily, and that it's a matter of team experience and proficiency, and in fact in managed languages it may be true, and that would explain why functional programming never took off, but when in comes to memory management, we've had enough CVEs to show that no, programming mistakes don't get ironed out easily. If you want to see “Zig safety story” in action, have a look at the only commercial user of the language, and go search for “segfault” in the github issues…