3 ms·
I think we're under-calling the negative effects of the lockdowns. The economy seems substantially less stable, inflation isn't going to get attributed to the C
by roenxi 4y ago
I think we're under-calling the negative effects of the lockdowns. The economy seems substantially less stable, inflation isn't going to get attributed to the COVID response but realistically is related. Humans suddenly seem to be facing a bunch of energy and food problems that weren't feeling quite so urgent in 2019. The global situation w.r.t war is suddenly a lot more tense and there are serious concerns about several nuclear-armed nations moving their armies about.
No scientist is going to link those things to the COVID response, because the link is too vague. And there is a chance that maybe all this stuff was going to happen anyway and the timing is a coincidence.
But there is a good reason that "freedom" is a higher civilisational value in the west than "be healthy". Allowing small councils to decide that people can't go to church, meet their neighbours or run a business is a very effective way to bring down a civilisation. It is impossible to do that and enjoy a high standard of living.
- skeeter2020 4y agoI think you've summarized my more vague feelings well. Add to this that people uncomfortable with the actions taken range from nut-job conspiracy theorists to immature opposition-defiance disorder sufferers to those who took many precautions but put aggregate quality of life over quantity. Then look at the down-voting in this thread spanning the spectrum of opinions... It's going to be hard to reach any sort of nuanced consensus or agreement.
- danaris 4y agoWhile this may be true, I think it's important to remember that the negative effects of not doing the lockdowns would have been much worse. A million people died (and more are still dying! the pandemic is not over!) in the US alone, even with the partially-effective measures we took. Imagine if we hadn't even tried to reduce transmission. Hospitals would have been rapidly overwhelmed (many already got overwhelmed at the peaks, others came very close), and even people who could have been treated—both for COVID and for other health issues—would have died because they couldn't get access. What are the negative economic impacts of having, say, 3% of your population (10 million people) die over a two-year span? What are the negative economic impacts of the terrible psychological toll of all that loss? And of the government and other institutions just...not caring?
- gjsman-1000 4y agoThe problem with that “it would’ve been worse” is that the timeline didn’t happen that way, so it is merely conjecture by people who have every incentive to save face for their decisions. The other problem is that it isn’t true. Florida has had 10,000 deaths less than California, despite no lockdown and more old people.
- munch117 4y ago> The problem with that “it would’ve been worse” is that the timeline didn’t happen that way Ah, but we did see it. In Italy in the first week of March 2020, we saw what an unchecked epidemic looked like. The health care system was overwhelmed and in chaos. Funeral services couldn't keep up because people were dying in large numbers. > Florida ... no lockdown Here's a story about the Florida lockdown being lifted: https://abcnews.go.com/Health/florida-lifts-covid-19-restrictions/story?id=73294496 https://abcnews.go.com/Health/florida-lifts-covid-19-restric... The differences in approach between US states aren't as big as you remember them.
- kcplate 4y ago> While this may be true, I think it's important to remember that the negative effects of not doing the lockdowns would have been much worse would is definitive. You don’t know that, and there seems to be plenty of real world examples of hard Covid mitigation policies to soft Covid mitigation policies that indicates it’s not that simple. Could it have been worse? Sure, but frankly it could have been better too with less lockdown.
- munch117 4y agoThe global situation w.r.t war and the ensuing energy and food shortages were caused by Vladimir Putin starting a war. How exactly is it that you think lockdowns influenced Vladimir Putin to do that?
- roenxi 4y agoWell, the lockdowns triggered a general collapse of oil prices as using oil suddenly became illegal. The oil price went negative (!) for a few amazing moments. Possibly that destablisied the Russian economy, spooked Putin, and convinced Russian high command that a desperate gamble was needed to try and unite the public against a foreign foe. China could do something similar, Xi wanting to unite the people behind a patriotic war to distract from a Hindenburg-style economic explosion. The protests in the US got noticeably more violent in the US around the same time as the lockdowns which is probably related to the economic stresses of the shut-down-the-economy policies. I imagine it would be worse in countries that aren't democracies; there are less outlets for the anger. And it seems obvious to me that we're feeling the snap-back effect of all the oil fields being shut down, + the inflation from rather extreme money handouts during the pandemic. A lot of the current economic troubles (which would also tend to contribute to people feeling stressed and war-like) are probably linked to the lockdowns through that mechanism.
- munch117 4y agoThe Russian military action against Ukraine started in 2014, long before that.
- roenxi 4y agoAre you going to argue that the present situation in Ukraine is equivalent to the situation at the start of 2020? I suppose it might be, I wasn't paying a lot of attention. But my strong suspicion there has been a bit of a turning point that happened after COVID hit, possibly on or about 24 February 2022. It is notable that there was a long stretch of relative calm that ended around the time everyone switched off their economies. The original Crimea annexation didn't have all these headlines of global food shortages and energy crisii either, raising the questions of "why is this time so much worse?" and "why is this escalating?". You can blame Putin if you want, but lets be real - economic stresses are a big factor in war and peace.