4 ms·
No thanks. I'd rather have my own vehicle. Much more convenient.
by matheusmoreira 4y ago
No thanks. I'd rather have my own vehicle. Much more convenient.
- kelnos 4y agoThat's fine, I guess, but I think plenty of people would get rid of their car if public transit was more ubiquitous, reliable, and convenient. Even people (like myself) who would choose to still have a car in that scenario, we might use the car less often, which would reduce wear and tear on it (thus increasing the length of its useful life). That would also serve to reduce demand for new vehicles.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoSure. Good public transportation is always desirable. I just don't want it to be an argument against electric cars which would be a huge improvement.
- sanxiyn 4y agoSince money is fungible, argument for good public transportation is argument against electric car subsidy and vice versa, whether you like it or not. Like, we could scrap electric car subsidy and use money on public transportation instead. And I argue we should: at the moment, electric car subsidy is stupid, people are in line to buy electric cars, there is no need for subsidy.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoI'd rather have a private jet, too, but I don't think my personal desires are the only salient factor here.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIf desires aren't a factor, they should be. I'm willing to spend money on a car that I can charge at home like a smartphone. It would reduce my fuel costs to zero because I have a lot of solar panels. I'll even install more solar panels if necessary. The so called free market needs to make it happen. If there's a lithium shortage, then mine more.
- pajtl 4y agoThe question is whether we're pricing in externalities appropriately. We've had the market do it once with ICE cars and it is painfully obvious that the pricing involved was only a fraction of the true cost to the environment. Planning to 'just mine more' of whatever and completely replace all of private transportation infrastructure sure sounds like another path to environmental disaster. That's not to say we should drop EVs or anything like that. But we should at least think twice, especially when there are perfectly good alternatives.
- supertrope 4y agoIf you could ask a fish what swimming in water is like, they would answer "What's 'water'?" People are so used to in kind subsidies for cars that many don't realize the extent of these supports. Toll-free highways and roads. Mandated parking minimums. Free on-street parking. Zoning laws banning anything but single family houses cite increased traffic and parking demand "caused" by denser construction (but this exclusionary zoning itself increases demand for driving). If you hit someone with your car, stay at the scene, and are not drunk criminal liability will not attach. Driver's license and insurance requirements are kept low. The US Government finances moving to suburbs with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. The Federal Reserve buys mortgage backed securities. In many cities the majority of downtown land is roads and parking! When you have lived your whole life in cities that are designed automobile first and automobile only, and public transit is either non-existent or still underfunded compared with cars, then you will ask for a car based solution. An individual can only choose between choices they know exist, based on the information they have access to.
- jjav 4y ago> Mandated parking minimums. Have you lived in areas without mandated minimum parking? I have and it is a nightmare I don't care to ever repeat. There are good reasons for such rules. In a perfect idealized world with excellent public transit, there's no need for mandated minimum parking, I agree! But that perfect world mostly doesn't exist (maybe Manhattan, only some areas). When there is no parking, but people absolutely must have their car to get to work to be able to survive, it is mayhem. Violent fights over parking with human and property damage, people circling for hours and hours all night trying to park, you can't leave your house to go to important things because you lose your spot, and so on. The positive way to do it is to solve for public transit first, so that most people are happy to not have to have a car. Then parking becomes a moot point, no rules needed. If you force people to have a car to exist in society and simultaneously force them to have no place to park, it is a disaster.
- philliphaydon 4y agoIn Singapore. Cars are not convenient. MRT is far better than owning a car.
- natch 4y agoSingapore is relatively small.
- pajtl 4y agoWhat does this have to do with anything?
- supertrope 4y agoShorter distances between destinations encourages walking, biking, and mass transit use. Longer distances between destinations encourages automobile use.
- pajtl 4y agoLonger distances also encourage plane and train use. Public transport is not about distance, it's about density.
- supertrope 4y agoTo be more precise I am referring to relative distances within a city. Both density and distances are crucial. Compact cities mean shorter public transit lines, faster trip times, and more efficient use of transit worker labor and vehicles (more route loops per hour and passengers reached per hour). Sprawled out cities have a vicious cycle of more miles/kilometers to cover which means longer trips and therefore less attractive service. The same shifts and vehicle miles serve less people.
- JoshGlazebrook 4y agoSingapore is 281.3 mi², Texas (a single US state) by itself is 268,597 mi². The level of public transit that some countries and cities have and people expect are simply not feasible in a lot of places simply due to the sheer size. And even cities within these states are larger than some countries.
- throwaway892238 4y agoI'd rather you didn't have your own vehicle. Much more convenient for everyone else.
- CamperBob2 4y agoWait'll you hear about the plans I have for your life.
- pxmpxm 4y agoCollectivists are always shocked when they get sent to Kazachstan because someone decided that we need more combine drivers than sportscasters.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoI'd rather other people didn't have their own vehicles too. In my perfect world, 99% of people would be using public transport in order to allow me to drive on mostly empty roads with zero stress. Good thing we can't just decide things like that, right?