13 ms·
Oberlin College to pay $36M to bakery owners who were falsely accused of racism
- physicsfox 4y agoThese claims of prejudice can be so detrimental for wellbeing, whether it's racism, sexism, homophobia, xenophobia, etc. I personally think that this serves as an example of when woke justice goes wrong. Always fact check individually; if one student in that entire college, she could been the one to do some research and stop it before it came too far. This is a great data point of the bystander effect, in that regard. I'm devastated for the bakery owners. :(
- sn0w_crash 4y agoWe may need laws in place that prevent public accusations of this category of career-ending adjectives.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://cpj.org/reports/2016/03/north-america/ https://cpj.org/reports/2016/03/north-america/ Some states have them, some don’t, and the US Constitution’s First Amendment puts limits on the laws that do exist.
- remarkEon 4y agoIt's 1A but it's also SCOTUS precedent. If NYT v. Sullivan were to be revisited, these limits could change. Justice Thomas has expressed (on multiple occasions, though I don't have the opinions handy) that he wants to do that. Personally I think it should be revisited. The recent case of a Duke volleyball student claiming that racial epithets were yelled at her during a came turned out to be false, but not after the usual cycle of social media enabled outrage. I bring it up because it's another instance where all of the facts are easily verifiable, and journalists seem to not care to actually look at them and report what actually happened.
- puffoflogic 4y agoWell we can't have SCOTUS following the suggestions of racists like Thomas. /s?
- hirundo 4y agoHere's the flyer that was fatal to Oberlin's case: https://firstamendmentwatch.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Screen-Shot-2019-06-17-at-11.27.15-AM.png https://firstamendmentwatch.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/S... "This is a RACIST establishment ...": That's a statement of opinion, not actionable. "... with a LONG ACCOUNT of RACIAL PROFILING and DISCRIMINATION.": That's a statement of fact, and it was therefore actionable and cost Oberlin's insuror millions. That seems like a reasonable way to split the difference between free speech and libel.
- Ferrotin 4y agoAre you a lawyer with experience handling these kinds of cases? "This is a RACIST establishment ..." sounds like a defamatory statement to my naive ears when it is made without any fact behind it.
- jlawson 4y agoThe power of the word "racist" (like all woke-words) is that it has lots of definitions, which the speaker can slip between depending on the needs of the moment. In this case, the two definitions and their purposes would be: Definition 1. "One not actively working to create equal outcomes for non-white groups (even simply being neutral/disinterested is racist in this definition)". This is the definition of racist in the popular How to Be an Antiracist. This would be used to attach the word to the target. Definition 2. "One directly and intentionally harming people of non-white races out of conscious and deliberate hatred". Basically the KKK definition. This is the implication that's attached to the target, after definition 1 is used to "stick" the word onto the target. It's an amazing "stick and stab" tactic that, somehow, we haven't yet developed cultural antibodies against.
- brightball 4y agoWhen did “non-white” get included into the definition of racism exactly? Those definitions are…I can’t find the word…
- 4y ago
- pyuser583 4y agoLaws like that are in place, and they’re what ended McCarthyism. One problem is they are very civilly focused. How much money did you lose? A corporate execute might be out millions, while the guy at MacDonalds might be out a few thousand.
- tbrownaw 4y ago> Always fact check individually; if one student in that entire college, she could been the one to do some research and stop it before it came too far. One of the previous threads here had a link to a pdf somewhere in the comments, that looked like it had excerpts from the court filings. It had quite a few emails saying variants on "my experience with them says these accusations aren't true at all". So no, I don't think one student pushing back would have helped.
- scarab92 4y agoIt's a town of 8000 people, of which 4000 are college students and staff. When you gather that many social justice warriors together in a location where there is no actual injustice to prosecute, they will creatively invent some so that they can do the thing they enjoy doing. You see a similar pattern with firefighters. When there haven't been many recent fires to put out, you start seeing more firefighters getting arrested for arson.
- remuskaos 4y agoCitation needed
- scarab92 4y agoFor the firefighters? Here's a starting point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firefighter_arson https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Firefighter_arson
- polski-g 4y agoFire fighters are 94% volunteers. So not sure why they'd do that...
- timellis-smith 4y agoAs a former volunteer wildfire firefighter we definitely had instances of (former) volunteers engaging in arson for the thrill of putting out fires.
- emmelaich 4y agoIt's a pity that Meredith Raimondo was not personally sued for defamation.
- AussieWog93 4y agoShe probably would have been if she had $36 million in cash. :)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bosswipe 4y agoI don't feel too bad for them and their $36 mill.
- rendall 4y agoThe husband did not have the energy to fight both lawsuit and cancer. They won the lawsuit, but he lost to cancer.
- pipeline_peak 4y agoI think a lot of times the catalyst is if you don’t agree due to insufficient evidence, or choose to shop there then “you’re the problem”.
- llanowarelves 4y agoAnd if you don't join in: "Silence is violence"
- rayiner 4y agoIt’s also worth pointing out that the victims here aren’t the bakery owners. It’s also minority college students who are persuaded to believe they live in a more racist society than they do. After all, if even the local bakery in a famously liberal college town is racist, then the rest of the country must be much worse right? This perception, in turn, negatively affects their mental health, jobs, and interracial friendships.
- onos 4y agoIt seems many of the policies advocated for by “the woke” are motivated by such simplistic logic that they ultimately have the opposite effect of their intentions. We must balance grace with truth. Of course in this case oberlin leadership just acted very poorly and there is no excuse.
- rayiner 4y agoThe "grace" framing makes it sound like it's about being fair to white people. I have some sympathy for people who are falsely accused, but honestly shit happens. My point is different: that exaggerating racism harms non-white people. I know other Asians who say stuff like "oh, I wouldn't want to go to the south because people are racist." And they're missing out on good food, warm weather, and friendly people. Trump won my precinct (which weirdly encompasses just my subdivision) 58-34 in 2016 when I moved there. It's a lovely place to live with lots of kids and friendly neighbors. A minority who is told by authority figures that the local bakery in Oberlin Ohio is a hotbed of racism might be too scared to come where I live. And that's not good for anybody.
- greenyoda 4y ago> I know other Asians who say stuff like "oh, I wouldn't want to go to the south because people are racist." Interestingly, it was southern states that elected the first two governors of Indian descent: Bobby Jindal in Louisiana (2008-2016)[1] and Nikki Haley in South Carolina (2011-2017)[2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Jindal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bobby_Jindal [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikki_Haley https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nikki_Haley
- devwastaken 4y agoOberlin lost because it was the dean and admins themselves that perpetuated it. They printed and handed out flyers about it. If they're federally funded they need to be blacklisted from student loans and grants. Once closed, wipe it clean and start over. Or else that culture will infect and continue to cause irrepairable harm.
- deweller 4y ago> Once closed, wipe it clean and start over This is exactly the kind of cancel culture that Oberlin demonstrated toward the bakery. "They did something unforgivable! Eliminate them!" Organizations have problems. People are imperfect. Society needs justice. But cancel culture is a mob mentality that goes far beyond justice and is harmful to society.
- luckylion 4y ago> "They did something unforgivable! Eliminate them!" They claimed it falsely and without evidence though. The same is not true for any action that would be taking against the college. When someone claims that a random person committed a crime, kidnaps and imprisons them, we call that kidnapping and false imprisonment. But we won't shy away from taking the perpetrator off the street and in turn locking them up so they don't do it again.
- detaro 4y agodupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32774412 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32774412
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- svnpenn 4y agoheres the timeline for any interested: November 2016: Oberlin professors and deans defamed bakery August 2017: lawsuit September 2022: Oberlin agrees to pay 36 million to plaintiff so yes, justice was served, but it took six years. I feel bad for the bakery people. I have filed suit in federal court before. I think my case only lasted a few months, but it was stress I would not wish on anyone. Who knows what these people have been through.
- jfim 4y agoThey've actually written about their side of the story. See https://www.commonsense.news/p/will-i-ever-see-the-36-million-oberlin https://www.commonsense.news/p/will-i-ever-see-the-36-millio... The owner passed away because of pancreatic cancer after the first trial.
- purple_ferret 4y ago>Allyn was beaten up pretty badly, and the three students were arrested. Seems like a farce. The students were never charged with or convicted of assault or anything close to it. Not defending Oberlin, but Bari Weiss is shameful for letting that line stay in.
- tarakat 4y agoShe should remove testimony of what happened by the alleged victim's mother, because the accusation did not result in a conviction? It is also immediately followed by > David was afraid the incident would blow up, since the students claimed to the police that my son had assaulted them—not the other way around. giving the reader testimony of all parties involved. But by your logic, the media could report only on court decisions.
- emmelaich 4y agoRead the wikipedia page. Also, from Salon > Gibson Jr. then took out his phone to take a picture of Aladin, who slapped the phone from his hand and caused the device to strike Gibson Jr.'s face > Before their sentencing, each student read a statement acknowledging that Gibson's was justified in trying to restrain Aladin
- throwoutway 4y agoIt wasn’t just the school, but also the students. They should pay the bakery too for damages. Shameful behavior
- tartoran 4y agoThose students are long gone though..
- umeshunni 4y agoStill well within the statute of limitations I assume.
- johndevor 4y agoWhat crimes did they commit?
- YeBanKo 4y agoLibel?
- tptacek 4y agoLibel isn't a crime. Nobody is going to go after the students, because a defamation case has to establish damages, and no one student will have done any significant damage to the Gibson family. It was straightforward to demonstrate that Oberlin had.
- throwoutway 4y agoSo society & justice should just ignore the masses protests of students because it’s too hard to prosecute? I think we can agree that yes it will be hard, but justice has not been fully served
- 4y ago
- userbinator 4y agoOberlin prides itself on being progressive and inclusive. Now everyone on one entire side of the political spectrum is gloating at what that ideology has lead them into.
- rendall 4y agoWhy is that important? Seems to me the most important detail is how ideological blindness led an entire college to make false accusations against innocent people, and then double down when all facts came to light, to the point of losing $36M and all not apparently acknowledging that they were ever wrong. Isn't that weird? Isn't that really, freaking weird?? What does it imply about academics, society, racism, ideological capture? Gloaters gonna gloat. An "entire side of the political spectrum" would have gloated if the bakery had lost on appeal. Does that matter?
- TMWNN 4y ago>Why is that important? Seems to me the most important detail is how ideological blindness led an entire college to make false accusations against innocent people, and then double down when all facts came to light, to the point of losing $36M and all not apparently acknowledging that they were ever wrong. Isn't that weird? Isn't that really, freaking weird?? What does it imply about academics, society, racism, ideological capture? Indeed. Reading the comments on the New York Times article linked to the other recent HN discussion of the case, there are—among many forthright condemnations of the Oberlin administrators and students that caused this catastrophe for the college—more than a few comments lamenting how the worst outcome of this is that "Trumpists" will gloat. Not that a bakery faced six years of litigation (in the legal and public spheres) against the college with the billion-dollar endowment that is the closest thing to "The Man" in their small town, but that the commenters' own ideological enemies might be pleased by the court case's outcome.
- puffoflogic 4y ago> when all facts came to light Maybe you meant it harmlessly, but this phrase sets off my BS detector. It's invariably used to excuse bad behavior by people who knew better but pretended otherwise for political gain. It conflates when you personally learned the facts with when the involved parties learned the facts. See also: "no one knew Kyle Rittenhouse didn't murder a bunch of black people in a crowd until these facts came to light in the trial!" or "we didn't know that the Biden laptop was real until these facts came to light in 2022!" or "we didn't know the lab leak was a real possibility until new facts came to light!" In each case, the facts were already there for everyone to see, they were just ignored for political reasons until it was too late.
- purple_ferret 4y agoOberlin's response to students: >Dear Obies, >Today, Oberlin College and Conservatory initiated payment in full of the $36.59 million judgment in the Gibson’s Bakery case, an amount that represents the awarded damages and interest owed. Please see the college’s public statement below. >While this outcome is a disappointment, our financial plans for this possibility, which included insurance coverage, mean that this payment will not impact or diminish our academic or student life experience, or require us to draw down Oberlin’s endowment. >Like me, the majority of the campus was not here at the beginning of this matter in 2016. But it is also true that this case has been difficult for all of us who love this institution and its hometown. I am looking forward to all that is ahead, and remain focused on Oberlin’s core mission of providing a truly excellent liberal arts and musical education. Carmen Ambar Signature Carmen Twillie Ambar So they're basically just claiming insurance will cover it
- icelancer 4y agoAs someone who has had insurance cover a nuisance lawsuit's judgment, trust me, the insurer is not very pleased with you. In my case, it was the cost of doing business with the usual trolls going after intellectual property, and even still, the insurer was pretty angry. Oberlin's insurer is going to get them back in the next renewal period considering they were blatantly in the wrong. And all other insurers know; the history is open.
- hilbert42 4y agoIt seems very odd that any insurer would insure under these circumstances. If one did then it seems even odder that it didn't refuse to pay the claim on the grounds that its insurance didn't cover what could easily be deemed as negligence (risky behavior). I wish I had an insurance company that was so lax with its payouts.
- icelancer 4y agoThey might have a tough time getting re-insured after gross negligence, but insurance that covers legal settlements for this kind of thing is normal and expected for almost all medium to large businesses to carry - even my small business carries it (and maybe many more do). It's simply too dangerous to operate in the current American legal environment without this kind of insurance, though it is quite expensive.
- steele 4y ago
- benreesman 4y agoWhatever the right and wrong of the matter, the phenomenology of the Academy is certainly of extreme interest and importance to the users of HN. I haven’t been anywhere near a university in years personally, so I don’t know what credence to lend claims that politics, and in particular non-academic politics, are to an increasing an untenable degree crowding out more knowledge-oriented activities. With that said, one does hear claims like this, which would be worrying if true, and data points / discussion around it is almost certainly on topic for HN right?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prvc 4y agoThis college has been characterized in various places as being "prestigious", but I can't imagine any context where learning that someone is a recent graduate would be a positive signal. Yet, this notion persists.
- userbinator 4y agoIt is prestigious to those who believe in its ideology.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAll colleges are prestigious, or pay others to call them prestigious.
- astrange 4y agoThe music school is prestigious, and if you're going to the symphony you probably aren't going to learn the musicians' politics.
- prvc 4y ago> if you're going to the symphony you probably aren't going to learn the musicians' politics You'd be surprised.
- pyuser583 4y agoI know a graduate of Oberlin who is a wonderful person. Bright, publicly dedicated, wonderful.
- josephcsible 4y agoNobody is denying that wonderful people who graduated from Oberlin exist. The point is that they're wonderful despite that, not because of it.
- pyuser583 4y agoSorry, to be clear, this person ascribed their good qualities to Oberlin. She is a teacher who meant a great deal to myself and many other students.
- bosswipe 4y agoThe type of hot-button political grievances that make it to the HN front page are an indication of the demographics here.
- Gigachad 4y agoBusiness owners worried about baseless accusations funded by megacorp educational institutions?
- orangepurple 4y agoNothing matters until the "check clears"
- yieldcrv 4y agoare there any other takes that the legal system cannot reveal? is it common for other students to attempt to buy alcohol with fake IDs and these students were the ones stopped for it? what I read - my first time reading about this - is that the shop owner correctly identified something sketchy was going on, and this escalated into an altercation with 3 underage patrons that the police got involved in as all 3 were arrested. The initial observation of "assuming theft" is supplanted by "trying to purchase with a fake ID", something common in a college town. How were these two things conflated? This isn't answered. All three people plead guilty to different things unrelated to an assumption of theft, but pleading guilty doesn't reveal anything when understanding just how many people can't defend themselves in court. The college shouldn't have gotten involved at all, regardless. This trend of "using your platform" needs to have counter-deterrents and consequences. The people that actually boycotted and did slander-like things, shouldn't have acted without being more discerning. But there's still something else in between that I can't garner from this. Anybody local have more personal accounts?
- Nicksil 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibson%27s_Bakery_v._Oberlin_College https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gibson%27s_Bakery_v._Oberlin_C... Answers your question. - An attempt to illegally purchase alcohol is made - During the attempt, it became apparent the guy was concealing two other bottles of wine inside his jacket. - The clerk remarked something to the extent of calling the police and pulls out his phone to take a picture. - Underage guy slaps phone out of clerk's hand, hitting clerk in the process, and runs out the store. - Clerk tries to detain the guy when two of the guy's friends show up and join in on beating the clerk until the police show up.
- yieldcrv 4y agoHysterical Outside of that incident are there other grievances against that shop and owner in that town, to lend any weight to the optional actions everyone chose to take?
- frozenport 4y agoWhat value does this school provide compare to let's say Ohio State? Cost 2x more with approximately the same rated programs, and much worse STEM like programs. If I recall a big part of it was kids who couldn't get in anywhere else can took massive loans for a small college experience. And had equally small outcomes. This college is very much a scam that provides an income for its staff at the expense of its student body.
- tartoran 4y agoI don’t believe Oberlin is a scam though I think they messed up quite big with this case. By this logic a lot of private unis are scams which is quite a large brush to paint with.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoAll these little private schools charging $80k/year are part of a scam. The scam is the federal US government lending students a blank check with no underwriting as long as it is spent at an “accredited” school. And then the young adult emerges from the school with $100k and $200k and $300k of debt while only able to earn income of $60k to $80k per year.
- spacechild1 4y agoI don't really know about typical artist's fees in the US, but I would expect most musicians to make less than $60k - unless they play in a renowned orchestra. If someone has some actual numbers or first-hand experience, I would be glad.
- frozenport 4y agoIndeed, a lot of them are scams. At least with private ivy league schools like Cornell you have ranking advantage, but with Oberlin they are tricking kids into paying top-tier tuition for bottom-tier ranking.
- Der_Einzige 4y ago
- pyuser583 4y agoWhen I took a job as RA advisor in college, I was told: “You can’t be a part of the students - if they get drunk or do drugs or anything like that, you can’t be part of it. You’re either the grown up in the room or you leave.”
- _8j50 4y agoI don't think they were racist and I am flad for their victory but for the convicts... yeah this is America we're talking about their confession means something only if there was no plea-bargain and I highly doubt 3 young people will in unison confess to a crime without being under duress (plea-bargain). However, the fact that oberlin couldn't prove their racist history in court is all I need to know about the baker's innocence. Plea-bargains are a mockery of justice as is cops being allowed to lie to get confessions.
- tablespoon 4y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/08/us/oberlin-bakery-lawsuit.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/08/us/oberlin-bakery-lawsuit...: > Oberlin is a small liberal arts college with a reputation for turning out students who are strong in the arts and humanities and for its progressive politics... Tuition at Oberlin is more than $61,000 a year, and the overall cost of attendance tops $80,000 a year. This is why student loan forgiveness is such an important issue.
- Diesel555 4y agoAre you saying that the government should pay off everyone’s loans regardless of the cost of an institution or the value of that education? Or just that college costs are too high in general? I understand loan forgiveness in certain situations, even as proposed by the US current administration [1]. But choosing to attend a small liberal arts college and agreeing to pay more than 80k a year I don’t think is one of those situations. [1]: https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/08/24/fact-sheet-president-biden-announces-student-loan-relief-for-borrowers-who-need-it-most/ https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases...
- tptacek 4y agoIt's an elite private school. Nobody should have their Oberlin debt forgiven.
- closetkantian 4y agoHere are some Facebook posts made by Allyn Gibson (son of the store owners / same guy who chased the black shoplifter): “I wasn’t racist ever … but this ** and the way people treat me now because I am “white” is racist and is making me racist,” Allyn Jr. wrote. “I don’t owe a damn person a damn thing. If these lazy *** want to start working then they could earn their own money. That’s what my family does for money… work.” /// So yes, he is a racist, and the family could well be. Just thought I'd throw that out there.
- noworriesnate 4y agoWhen people are attacked because of their race, they do tend to become racist as a self-defense mechanism.
- tptacek 4y agoSee: the Rule of Goats.
- Beltalowda 4y ago
- pvaldes 4y ago"if people treat me bad and call me racist by being white, then I'm racist" is not a definition of real racism. Is another case of: "if all is racism, then nobody is racist". The term has been abused to defend thievery, so now is devoid of any real meaning. This is a big problem in itself.
- tptacek 4y agoThis case has really not much of anything to do with whether Allyn Gibson is racist. You can't sue someone for calling you racist.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qsymmachus 4y agoOberlin native here. I've been going to Gibson's since I was a kid. You're getting an incomplete picture of this sad drama and the Gibson family does not deserve your sympathy. I'll preface by saying that no one in this story comes out looking good – certainly not the shoplifters, who expected get out of jail free cards despite being thieves; nor the college, whose greatest fear is offending its fragile student body, with predictable results like this. What you're not going to read in this article or others like it is that the Gibsons aren't heroes either. There are two important details I'd bring to your attention: 1. Allyn Gibson, the man who tackled the shoplifters, really is a confirmed racist. I know this both first hand (we are peers), and from his many social media posts in which he casually rags on immigrants and black people (expect he identifies them using the n-word). The judge in this case declared that evidence inadmissible, for some reason. 2. The Gibsons are not a put-down, working class family who were nearly bankrupted by this protest. They're one of the wealthiest families in town, and were millionaires before this all happened. Gibson's Bakery is a hobby business; they turn a modest profit selling some baked goods and beer. Their actual livelihood comes from rent – they're the second largest landowners after the college, and own most of the commercial and residential rental property in town. The idea that they were impacted by this protest in any consequential way is frankly laughable to anyone who knows anything about them and their business. Once again, the judge declared evidence of their wealth to be inadmissible in court. This doesn't absolve the college of blame. But this isn't the black-and-white, "David vs Goliath" story the media is making it out to be. Unfortunately this story just fits too neatly into a national narrative about "woke" politics going too far, so you're not going to see any nuance from the media.