3 ms·
Isn't this the kind of argument that bites the government in the foot? On the one hand, plenty of antitrust people argue that Google is a natural monopoly and
by crazygringo 4y ago
Isn't this the kind of argument that bites the government in the foot?
On the one hand, plenty of antitrust people argue that Google is a natural monopoly and needs to be broken up because the regular rules of competition aren't working.
On the other hand, here's the DOJ seemingly arguing the opposite -- that Google needs to fight so hard to maintain competitive dominance that it's forced to pay billions of dollars just to keep its market position.
You can't have it both ways. And companies strike exclusivity deals all the time, that's normal capitalism. Really this is just ammunition for why Google isn't abusing anything, it's just competing normally.
- scarmig 4y agoSure you can. The ability to establish a noncompetitive monopoly via paying billions of dollars to maintain a market position that allows them to make those payments and still make billions of dollars of profit is perfectly compatible with and even evidence for a monopoly. DDG isn't going to be able to write those checks. Though perhaps simply banning these types of exclusivity deals would be sufficient to return to a competitive market. It seems lighter touch than breaking up Google.
- pessimizer 4y ago> Google needs to fight so hard to maintain competitive dominance These are words you're putting in their mouths. > pay billions of dollars just to keep its market position. This is what they're doing. It's not a desperate fight, it's a bribe of what is a trivial amount for Google. It's a network of patronage run by a monopolist, not desperate street-fighting bribes, or whatever it is that the DOJ can't have both ways. Imagine a similar scenario where a local businessman is paying off local politicians and judges. Would you actually make the argument that the fact that the businessman is paying everyone off shows that his position is so precarious that he can't possibly be running the town? Monopolistic behavior as evidence against monopoly?
- Spivak 4y agoThis argument falls down because if all it took was a few billion in capital to buy a bunch of ads and the right partnerships and then extract 100x the value from your newfound monopoly it would be the easiest business opportunity in all of existence. You can't compare this to government bribes because the bidding process isn't open. If politicians sold their votes publicly to the highest bidder the market dynamics would be different and maintaining power would be ludicrously expensive. If Google really is paying "trivial" amounts of money then those partnerships must not really be as market swaying as argued. Google paying tiny amounts is evidence of a monopoly. Google paying large amounts is evidence of a competitive market.