4 ms·
Back then people often bought magazines for the ads. I still buy magazines for the ads. For example, I buy Mopar Action for the ads that are targeted towards m
by WalterBright 4y ago
Back then people often bought magazines for the ads.
I still buy magazines for the ads. For example, I buy Mopar Action for the ads that are targeted towards me for things I might want or need for my Dodge. When I open the mag, I want to look at the ads.
This is fundamentally different from guessing what I want to see based on my browsing history. If I open a site on cooking, I don't want to see ads for car parts or kitchen faucets, regardless of my history. I would want to see ads for cooking supplies.
- sumtechguy 4y agoI bought hundreds of computer shoppers. Just because it was ads. I think there was an article or two in there sometimes. It is funny enough where I learned the xor trick. That thing was a monster at least a couple of inches thick of nothing but computer ads.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThe Alice and Bob article... I don't remember the content exactly.
- Turing_Machine 4y agoAs I recall they included just enough editorial material to qualify for the "literature" postage rate rather than the "advertising" postage rate, which was higher. (those might not be the exact terms that were/are used)
- ajross 4y ago> If I open a site on cooking, I don't want to see ads for car parts or kitchen faucets, regardless of my history. I would want to see ads for cooking supplies. Is that not the way it works for you? I mean, I pull up allrecipes.com and see a bunch of food-related stuff like my local supermarket (and one less relevant ad for Iceland Air, no idea). Closer to the subject at hand, the modern "Byte Magazine" might be something like tomshardware.com, where I see lots of tech products being hawked (phones, a tablet, Xfinity service), and ads for the retailers that sell them (lots of Best Buy on the pages I saw). I mean, sure, there are going to be exceptions. But in general ads on the internet seem at least reasonably relevant. It really seems sometimes like sites like HN are turning into information bubbles, where concepts like "advertising in the modern world is a dystopian disaster" are... just taken as faith? The experience of regular people doesn't really agree, and it seems like we're becoming more detached as the years go by.
- WalterBright 4y agoNo, it doesn't work for me. I'd turn on context-sensitive ads on my sites, and then see what ads it supplies. Unrelated garbage. I remember once buying a kitchen faucet, and for months it seems every site I visit showed me ads for faucets. For example, on a programming site it would keep pushing ads for the Batman movie. Phooey.
- ajross 4y agoWith all respect, that sounds like a criticism of internet advertising c. 2008 or so. I mean, sure, weird stuff like that happens and there are always going to be anecdotes. But no, for a long time now advertising on targetted/niche/interest-based sites has followed that niche, for the obvious reason that that's where the best ROI on the advertising is. I mean, sure, there will always be funny hiccups, and on the edges there are genuine issues of privacy and justice and market fairness to be discussed. But the idea that we're in some kind of advertising dystopia is simply not the experience of regular users. It's a meme[1] being perpetuated in the tech community. Regular products purchased by regular people are being advertised very effectively, and on the whole with near-universal approval of the customers. [1] And as mentioned, an increasingly detached and frankly slightly deranged one. Real concerns about privacy are now being short-circuited with nonsense about "But Their Ads", and that's hurting the discourse we actually need.
- lolinder 4y agoHave you considered that your experience may not be representative of everyone else's experience? You can't know the objective facts of what ads Walter sees. You also can't know how people experience ads subjectively. For myself, I have a really hard time focusing on anything in the presence of visual or audio distraction, with ads just being one example. I wear earmuffs all day while working just so I can focus. The equivalent on the internet is adblock. Without adblock and uBlock origin's element zapper, I simply cannot function on the internet today. Are you implying that my sensitivity to distracting noise in every aspect of life is somehow influenced by a meme about internet ads?