3 ms·
If the rest of the world cut back to India's per capita levels of fossil fuel use it would be a tremendous improvement. India's greenhouse gas emissions are 12%
by tzs 4y ago
If the rest of the world cut back to India's per capita levels of fossil fuel use it would be a tremendous improvement. India's greenhouse gas emissions are 12% of those of the US per capita (around 50% total).
Even cutting back to China levels would be a great improvement. China is around 50% of US emissions per capita.
And yes, per capita is the correct way to distribute whatever total greenhouse gas allowance we decide we need to live with because the atmosphere is a shared resource that doesn't care about arbitrary political boundaries. For an illustration of why per country makes no sense see the hypothetical here [1]. Where countries are relevant is enforcement, and in developing some sort of system to allow people to trade (directly or indirectly) some of their share of the global greenhouse gas allowance, such as by some sort of cap and trade system or some sort of carbon tariffs on imports/exports.
Most countries seem to recognize that to successfully address climate change the rich countries will have to give aid to the developing countries to help them move off of fossil fuels. The big hold out is the US.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31935567 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31935567
- candiodari 4y agoPer-capita doesn't work because denying AC doesn't have the same effect in Nevada and Alaska ... and heating the reverse. There are a lot of places where humans can live "for free" energy-wise, and most places where they can't. I think the energy crisis in Europe makes it very clear that when the choice is between people's livelihoods and climate change: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/08/germany-reactivate-coal-power-plants-russia-curbs-gas-flow https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/jul/08/germany-reacti... So let's get real: we need to get all humans up to at least European per-capita energy expenditure levels. Timing can be discussed, but it's when, not if. And lowering per-capita energy expenditure ... more than 10-20% is just not in the cards.