4 ms·
Weird. How is it I am feeling nostalgic for the ads?
by JKCalhoun 4y ago
Weird. How is it I am feeling nostalgic for the ads?
- VyseofArcadia 4y agoI was wondering why this thing is 578 pages long, and it turns out it's at least 80% advertising if the first 50 pages are anything to go by.
- mikelevins 4y agoI worked in a bookstore at the start of the 1980s. Its magazine section had many hundreds of titles (I stocked them). All of them were more or less that way: mostly ads by page area and page count, with the ratio of ads to content rising as you got toward the back of the magazine (but with most magazines maintaining the last couple of pages for distinctive editorial content). Magazines are generally much slimmer nowadays. Magazine racks are generally smaller and less ubiquitous. I presume the ad dollars have mostly moved onto the web, and the great majority of magazines have shrunk—many disappearing entirely.
- lymeswold 4y agoBecause leafing through ads for stuff in 1983 was the equivalent of googling for stuff today.
- cxf12 4y agoImagine how I feel! I was heading into my sophomore year in high school in 1983, the same month this article came out. I wasn't a subscriber to BYTE then, but the memories of us learning Assembler and C at the time are almost as vivid now as they were back then.
- winter_blue 4y agoYea, I mean I was born in the 90s, and I have to say the ads are really really enjoyable. I love the amount of depth and detail, and the longer-form article style that they use.
- ryandrake 4y agoAnd the beautiful serif typefaces (including in the titles!) and wild colors too! These days everything is Helvetica and friends, and bland shades of gray.
- dcchuck 4y agoPerusing with the same feelings Funny how the prices haven't changed much (seeing a "new computer" for $1,995), given the change in computing power and purchasing power (of the dollar)
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoBecause it was a time of magic. Every month you could find things that were significantly better, significantly cheaper, or completely brand new. (And by "completely", I do not mean "a new product that does the same old thing". I mean something I'd look at and think "I never even thought of doing that with a computer".) There was just a newness and excitement, and the ads show it.
- b112 4y agoAnd this mirrors the web today. All the new stuff is over, it is all incremental change, rehashing, repeat.
- lordleft 4y agoI was born in the late 80s, but I also feel nostalgic. I think it's because there was more of a sense of play in computing back in the day. I feel a real romanticism for vintage computing.
- galdosdi 4y agoI know it's mostly nostalgia, but the ads also are very qualitatively different from today's. Look how much text and detailed discussion there is compared to today's ads. These ads just seem to respect the reader's intellect more.
- WalterBright 4y agoBack then people often bought magazines for the ads. I still buy magazines for the ads. For example, I buy Mopar Action for the ads that are targeted towards me for things I might want or need for my Dodge. When I open the mag, I want to look at the ads. This is fundamentally different from guessing what I want to see based on my browsing history. If I open a site on cooking, I don't want to see ads for car parts or kitchen faucets, regardless of my history. I would want to see ads for cooking supplies.
- sumtechguy 4y agoI bought hundreds of computer shoppers. Just because it was ads. I think there was an article or two in there sometimes. It is funny enough where I learned the xor trick. That thing was a monster at least a couple of inches thick of nothing but computer ads.
- mixmastamyk 4y agoThe Alice and Bob article... I don't remember the content exactly.
- Turing_Machine 4y agoAs I recall they included just enough editorial material to qualify for the "literature" postage rate rather than the "advertising" postage rate, which was higher. (those might not be the exact terms that were/are used)
- ajross 4y ago> If I open a site on cooking, I don't want to see ads for car parts or kitchen faucets, regardless of my history. I would want to see ads for cooking supplies. Is that not the way it works for you? I mean, I pull up allrecipes.com and see a bunch of food-related stuff like my local supermarket (and one less relevant ad for Iceland Air, no idea). Closer to the subject at hand, the modern "Byte Magazine" might be something like tomshardware.com, where I see lots of tech products being hawked (phones, a tablet, Xfinity service), and ads for the retailers that sell them (lots of Best Buy on the pages I saw). I mean, sure, there are going to be exceptions. But in general ads on the internet seem at least reasonably relevant. It really seems sometimes like sites like HN are turning into information bubbles, where concepts like "advertising in the modern world is a dystopian disaster" are... just taken as faith? The experience of regular people doesn't really agree, and it seems like we're becoming more detached as the years go by.
- pjlegato 4y agoMany ads at the time still used a strategy of "reasoning with the reader": explaining the technical benefits of the product, and how using it would make your life better in some way. Sometime around the 90s, most advertising gradually shifted to emotional manipulation, which is empirically more effective at scale. The famous iPod ads, for example, said nothing at all about the iPod's technical merits, or how you'd benefit by using an iPod instead of other MP3 players. They just showed some vaguely cool-looking person listening to an iPod. The "I'm a Mac, I'm a PC" ads depicted PCs as old, uncool dorks; while the Mac is fun and interesting and young. Not a word about any actual features or benefits of the Mac. Purely associative emotional branding. This actually does work in terms of "selling more iPods at scale," though it is dissatisfying to that small segment of the population that cares about making informed and rational decisions. Most HN readers fall into this category, though there aren't enough of us in the world to carry mass advertising strategies.
- system16 4y ago> Not a word about any actual features or benefits of the Mac. From what I recall almost every "I'm a Mac, I'm a PC" ad's premise was a feature or task that the Mac did easier or better, leaving the PC deflated or envious.
- AnimalMuppet 4y ago> Sometime around the 90s, most advertising gradually shifted to emotional manipulation... Yup. > ... which is empirically more effective at scale. I don't think that's the issue. Back in the 80s, stuff came out regularly that was significantly better than the predecessor (if there was one). Emotional manipulation took over when new versions no longer had significant technical advantages over existing competitors.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoRight IPhones became a fashion accessory. I guess partial reason is that when everybody uses a smartphone you have to appeal to the masses, and pure reason doesn't reach them. The same goes for the high fashion in clothing. Doesn't matter if the clothes are the best to wear and most protective and most resilient against wear and tear. Were' in the era of tech-fashion including wearable computing.
- GuB-42 4y agoI didn't realize it was more than 50% ads, more than most websites we consider terrible nowadays. I think one reason is that back then, it was the way of keeping in touch with the commercial offering. Now, there are millions of review websites and user groups for that. A quick search can least you to the most niche products easily. As a result, ads just try to sell you stuff you are already aware of, instead of informing you about a new product and its capabilities, making them a lot less interesting. And even ads about shady products were kind of interesting.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]