3 ms·
> If climate change is is going to be a civilization-ending force, why would someone who ought to be well-informed sink a large amount of wealth into an at-risk
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> If climate change is is going to be a civilization-ending force, why would someone who ought to be well-informed sink a large amount of wealth into an at-risk property?
If it is going to be a civilization-ending force, wealth won't matter and all properties (and even the very concept of “property”) are at risk.
Your question makes more sense if the conditional is changed to “if climate change is going to have little effect on society at large but severe, highly localized effects... ”
- gspetr 4y agoWhy would the concept be at risk though? Will the species go extinct or would communists take over?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Why would the concept be at risk though? Property—at least real, as opposed to personal—property seems to be unlikely to survive as a thing in the absence of civilization, even the species survives, and “civilization-ending” was the scenario being discussed. > Will the species go extinct or would communists take over? Well, species-ending would be compatible with civilization-ending, but not necessary to it. Ideological communism probably wouldn't survive the end of civilization, either; the problem it addresses would no longer exist nor would there be means to implement most forms of it, nor would any people that survived probably have much energy for theory.
- gspetr 4y agoThis seems like too much of a stretch. "A civilization is any complex society characterized by the development of a political state, social stratification, urbanization, and symbolic systems of communication beyond natural spoken language (namely, a writing system)." Even in most post-apocalypse antiutopia science fiction, all of these attributes are present except perhaps urbanization. E.g. a roving gang with a warlord at its helm has a political state and social stratification, and they would still have access to pencils.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Even in most post-apocalypse antiutopia science fiction, all of these attributes are present except perhaps urbanization. That's the key one for real property (well, settled agricultural society probably more than urbanization per se, but if you have one you probably have the other.) > E.g. a roving gang with a warlord at its helm has a political state and social stratification, and they would still have access to pencils. But probably not have a system of real (as opposed to personal) property. Which is my point.