4 ms·
The premise of the Green New Deal is that the solution to climate change just happens to be the same things democratic socialists have wanted the whole time. Is
by rayiner 4y ago
The premise of the Green New Deal is that the solution to climate change just happens to be the same things democratic socialists have wanted the whole time. Isn’t that a coincidence.
- boppo1 4y agoYeah, this was hard not to notice.
- jandrese 4y ago
- rayiner 4y ago> You seem very angry at the idea that planet might be saved or that people may have access to good paying jobs. No, my concern is that climate change has become a new vehicle for ideas with a poor track record. I worry that the economy will stagnate and people won't have access to good paying jobs, and the planet won't be saved anyway. Will socialists have a "are we the bad guys" moment where they introspect about how capitalism has lifted country after country out of poverty--including nominally socialist ones like China, Vietnam, and Bangladesh? https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyssaayres/2014/10/28/bangladesh-capitalist-haven/?sh=63f143b4145e https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyssaayres/2014/10/28/banglade...; https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/columnists/nolan-finley/2019/03/21/finley-vietnam-capitalism-creeps-up-communism/3212628002/ https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/columnists/nolan-f...
- olddustytrail 4y agoNo coincidence. It's because right wing politicians decided to align themselves with corporate interests rather than embracing the idea of decentralized energy independence. And then right wing voters went along with it because "that's my team".
- xyzzyz 4y agoWhat is “corporate interests”, exactly? Biggest corporations today are overwhelmingly aligned with the Democratic Party, though in fact the oil industry is pretty much the only exception. Look at who they donate money to. At best, you might ask why Republican Party is putting their oil interests ahead of everyone else.
- helen___keller 4y agoYou mean a climate and social justice policy proposed by the party of climate and social justice contained provisions for achieving climate and social justice? How strange
- bandyaboot 4y agoIt's right there in the name. They're not exactly hiding the fact that they've wrapped up their climate and social goals into it. The Green New Deal was essentially nothing more than the democratic socialists' platform written down in the form of a non-binding resolution.
- tzs 4y agoIn the US the explanation is simple: the far right conservatives in Congress don't want to do anything to address climate change or even want to do things to make it worse (less renewables, more fossil fuels), and the Republicans who are not far right and are open to dealing with climate change are afraid to go against the far right because the far right voters are the ones that most turn out for primaries. And so it is only Democrats proposing anything that seriously addresses climate change. Like most big bills in Congress such proposals end up with other things attached. Normally what would then happen is that there were would be bipartisan negotiations to get a bill with mostly just the parts that both parties could agree on, but the far right wants nothing to do with that and so few or no Republicans in Congress will have anything to do with the drafting of the bill.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoHell the further right you go in the democratic party the more you support big oil and coal over green initiatives just look to Manchin as an example.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIf the democratic socialist faction of the american Democratic Party invented the whole concept of Climate Change, just so they could do what they wanted the whole time, which apparently was "Build Offshore wind turbines bigger than the Eiffel Tower and also capture the energy of the sun via quantumn mechanics to cheaply power highly efficient union-made Electric Vehicles and stop funding some of the most regressive nations on earth via fossil fuels" then that is seriously inspiring in a solarpunk kind of way. I'm not sure there's much evidence for that view unfortunately. But I may now pretend it is true because it would be a much more interesting world to live in if it was.
- tptacek 4y agoCouldn't you just write this honestly and without snark? You're actually mostly right here, but if you're writing to persuade or educate, all the air goes out of your comment with the last sentence. You have an interesting thing to say, and instead of saying it, you're sneering at the room for not already knowing it --- if they did, your comment wouldn't have been interesting!
- rayiner 4y agoWhat's not honest about it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 4y ago"Isn’t that a coincidence", implying that all your readers know what's "coincidental" about it, which further implies that there was no point to the comment --- it was obvious all along. But, in fact: there's nothing obvious about what you want to say, which is why you should take the time to say it properly, and in detail, instead of sneering at the room. You wrote a Facebook comment, not an HN comment. Certainly part of what pisses me off about this is that when you're writing well, you're a valuable corrective to a lot of groupthink that would otherwise go unchallenged here. Instead, you're writing stuff that anyone from the Sunrise Movement could knock down with a meme.
- idlewords 4y agoOkay, but you accused the guy of dishonesty. Be more honest in your tone policing!
- tptacek 4y agoHe has a series of reasons he doesn't buy the Green New Deal. I know he must, because I'm a liberal, and I can rattle off a bunch of reasons. But he didn't state them. Instead, he just sort of acted like everyone knows what those reasons are. But lots of people don't. They don't because nobody will talk to them honestly and just lay out the problems. That's why I used the word. This is part of a longstanding psychodrama of mine regarding late-period Rayinerism, though. You might just need to be read in on it.