8 ms·
I keep seeing people talk about the seriousness of climate change, but when it comes time to propose policy solutions, the answers are "$X trillion of dubiously
by pclmulqdq 4y ago
I keep seeing people talk about the seriousness of climate change, but when it comes time to propose policy solutions, the answers are "$X trillion of dubiously helpful spending and restrict the supply of energy." I think we all agree (even the so-called "deniers") that climate change is a serious potential problem. What our civilizations disagree on is the solution.
When the revealed policy preference of world leaders is to shut down the AC in summer in a desert, turn off the heat in a Scandanavian winter, and restrict energy supplies to developing countries, you don't have a workable solution. Current policy prescriptions are going to kill a lot more people than the warming they are trying to prevent. Further, it suggests that the most ardent activists are not actually serious about solving the problem: If they were serious, they would propose something less anti-human.
Creating more studies about how bad it could be actually hurts the cause of stopping climate change at this point. It doesn't convince anyone.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> I think we all agree (even the so-called "deniers") that climate change is a serious potential problem What gives you that kind of optimism? > shut down the AC in summer in a desert Lower AC in the summer > turn off the heat in a Scandanavian winter Lower the heat in the winter > restrict energy supplies to developing countries Not a thing. > Current policy prescriptions are going to kill a lot more people than the warming they are trying to prevent Incredibly dubious > Creating more studies about how bad it could be actually hurts the cause of stopping climate change at this point. It doesn't convince anyone. Not when people like you pop up to spout strawmen counter arguments at every point.
- starkd 4y agoRestricting access to cheap reliable energy is definitly going to cost lives. Ask any developing nation and they see the effects. It is one of the biggest issues that comes up whenever they try to get a global agreement. It's why China and India still insist on using coal to generate electricity.
- wombat-man 4y agoYeah I kinda wonder if that's ever going to happen. They aren't using coal because they like it, it's cheap and they have a lot of poor people with very real energy needs.
- wongarsu 4y agoBurning coal also costs lives, both directly through pollution, and indirectly through climate change. "X costs lives" isn't a worthwhile argument unless you show that it costs more lives than the alternative.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoWithout considering climate change externalities, the math on coal power is that it is clearly very beneficial for human flourishing. Even considering CO2-related externalities, burning coal as a bridge to nuclear and battery technology does seem to be a good option (China is basically doing this), but I'm not sure I've seen a rigorous analysis.
- jandrese 4y agoChina has been installing more solar than any other nation. Also, continuing to use fossil fuels is going to cost way more lives in the medium and especially long term.
- tzs 4y agoIf the rest of the world cut back to India's per capita levels of fossil fuel use it would be a tremendous improvement. India's greenhouse gas emissions are 12% of those of the US per capita (around 50% total). Even cutting back to China levels would be a great improvement. China is around 50% of US emissions per capita. And yes, per capita is the correct way to distribute whatever total greenhouse gas allowance we decide we need to live with because the atmosphere is a shared resource that doesn't care about arbitrary political boundaries. For an illustration of why per country makes no sense see the hypothetical here [1]. Where countries are relevant is enforcement, and in developing some sort of system to allow people to trade (directly or indirectly) some of their share of the global greenhouse gas allowance, such as by some sort of cap and trade system or some sort of carbon tariffs on imports/exports. Most countries seem to recognize that to successfully address climate change the rich countries will have to give aid to the developing countries to help them move off of fossil fuels. The big hold out is the US. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31935567 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31935567
- YetAnotherNick 4y ago> > I think we all agree (even the so-called "deniers") that climate change is a serious potential problem > What gives you that kind of optimism? I think OP meant that if someone claims that climate change would is not an existential threat, they are claimed as deniers. There is one axis for balancing short term vs long term issues, and so called deniers believes that we are on the in the correct point or right of that in that axis. Activist believes we are in the far left end of the axis, that we are risking long term for fixing short term issues.
- rayiner 4y agoThe premise of the Green New Deal is that the solution to climate change just happens to be the same things democratic socialists have wanted the whole time. Isn’t that a coincidence.
- boppo1 4y agoYeah, this was hard not to notice.
- jandrese 4y ago
- rayiner 4y ago> You seem very angry at the idea that planet might be saved or that people may have access to good paying jobs. No, my concern is that climate change has become a new vehicle for ideas with a poor track record. I worry that the economy will stagnate and people won't have access to good paying jobs, and the planet won't be saved anyway. Will socialists have a "are we the bad guys" moment where they introspect about how capitalism has lifted country after country out of poverty--including nominally socialist ones like China, Vietnam, and Bangladesh? https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyssaayres/2014/10/28/bangladesh-capitalist-haven/?sh=63f143b4145e https://www.forbes.com/sites/alyssaayres/2014/10/28/banglade...; https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/columnists/nolan-finley/2019/03/21/finley-vietnam-capitalism-creeps-up-communism/3212628002/ https://www.detroitnews.com/story/opinion/columnists/nolan-f...
- olddustytrail 4y agoNo coincidence. It's because right wing politicians decided to align themselves with corporate interests rather than embracing the idea of decentralized energy independence. And then right wing voters went along with it because "that's my team".
- xyzzyz 4y agoWhat is “corporate interests”, exactly? Biggest corporations today are overwhelmingly aligned with the Democratic Party, though in fact the oil industry is pretty much the only exception. Look at who they donate money to. At best, you might ask why Republican Party is putting their oil interests ahead of everyone else.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIf by chance, a real "climate change denier" existed, and I know they don't, it's only people who are concerned about government overreach and totalitarian measures enacted by innumerate hippies that will do more harm than good. But, if one did exist, where would you differ from them on actual policy? You don't want people to do studies. You don't want governments to fund stuff. You don't want governments to restrict energy (by which you mean fossil fuels, not cheap renewables). You appear to be suggesting that even the believers don't actually believe. I mean, there's a whole range of opinions on climate change from eco-communists to eco-capitalists to eco-futurists to eco-fascists, even fossil fuel companies have published net-zero plans, but your take seems to be just "don't do stuff". Can you expand on that a bit more, because that response feels very like climate change denial to me, which you say you're not, and indeed no one is, doing.
- shotta 4y agoMy chunk of the planet was suppose to be underwater 20 years ago, 15 years ago, 10 years ago, last year, in 3 years, and in 7 years. We are a naive species that does not understand climate or how and why it changes.
- jandrese 4y agoPlease cite the study in question that called for that much sea level change by 2020.
- shotta 4y agoI never said it was a study. Politicians, movies by Al Gore, the 1972 and 1982 UN conference on the environment. How about a study on studies not being reliable? https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16060722/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16060722/
- jandrese 4y agoWhy are you treating politicians as an authoritative source on climate science?
- bandyaboot 4y ago> When the revealed policy preference of world leaders is to shut down the AC in summer in a desert, turn off the heat in a Scandanavian winter, and restrict energy supplies to developing countries, you don't have a workable solution. Which world leaders have revealed these as their policy preferences?
- hackerlight 4y agoThey haven't. The actual policy preference is to build renewables, but it helps to use rhetorical tricks or cherry pick a few nutjobs to make it appear ridiculous in order to get to the desired conclusion that actually we shouldn't be building renewables.
- pclmulqdq 4y ago"Revealed preference" is about revelation of your preferences through your actions, not about what you say. Politicians around the world have decided, through their policies, that grid stability and increasing energy availability is not important. Gavin Newsom has preferred to have you suffer through the hottest summer on record (and he knew the temperature was going to rise) rather than build a nuclear power plant. Angela Merkel prefers that you suffer through winter rather than recondition an old nuclear power plant. This is why it is "revealed" preference: it's not about what you say you prefer, it is about what your actions show that you prefer. Edit: They also prefer that to coal power, or any other course of action.
- bandyaboot 4y agoYou have fallen quite a ways short of demonstrating those "revealed preferences". All you have demonstrated is that those two people apparently don't agree with your preferred courses of action and that you don't have a particularly good grasp of how long it takes to get a nuclear power plant built in the United States. > They also prefer that to coal power, or any other course of action. Pretty sure Newsom is in favor of increasing grid capacity by way of renewables. Just because you don't agree with a course of action doesn't make it not exist.
- starkd 4y agoIndeed. The use of private jets to assemble all the business leaders to one central location to talk about the issue of climate change does not do much to reassure people the issue is a serious one. I'm not against wealth, but jet engines emit more carbon into the atmosphere than most individuals do in a year. The fact none are willing to forego their private jets for commercial air speaks volumes. Either they don't seriously believe in the threat or they don't think any of these plans are going to have any serious affect. The environmental movement has come to resemble more a corporate marketing campaign than any kind of serious science.
- thelastgallon 4y agoPrivate jets and yatchs are exempt from carbon taxes in Europe [1]! This makes it even more obvious how much business 'leaders' and politicians care. [1] https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/yachts-be-exempt-eus-carbon-pricing-plan https://www.zerohedge.com/markets/yachts-be-exempt-eus-carbo...
- la64710 4y agoWhat about the unnecessary face to face business and company meetings ? They make up the bulk of air travel. Ban all those until zero emission flights are a reality
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoCancel it all, really. But that's the thing, for some reason business leaders are largely immune to any changes necessary to fight emissions, until the politicians decide to pick a specific boogeyman and go hard on it. And even that fails most of the time. Even here, while we technically have a law to keep employers from trying to keep individuals from coming to the office unnecessarily, there are so many social factors and caveats it is very, very difficult for individuals to call upon that law.
- starkd 4y agoBut that's just the point. It's not just business leaders who are disregarding their own actions. The environmental agendas are fully behind them. They've been co-opted as part of this corporate boondoggle. It leads you to believe they don't even truly believe the hyperbole about a catastrophe.
- emddudley 4y agoWe could have implemented less painful solutions 30, 20, or even 10 years ago, but we didn't, so now we only have drastic options remaining. Time is precious and immediate action is needed, even if we don't agree on the best solution. All options should be attempted.
- wongarsu 4y agoI think most people are in agreement that an aggressive CO2 tax (greenhouse gas tax, to be more precise) would be effective. Just make it expensive to cause climate change, and the market will take care of it. The problems are that accounting for all emissions is difficult and that the price points where it would be most effective strongly overlap with the price points where it would be a dramatic shock to the economy. There are milder versions like the cap-and-trade schemes that the EU or California implemented. They aren't perfect, but any perfect solution would be outright rejected for the massive impact it would have.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoIt will be effective, but only if every country agrees to do it. And if I know anything about global politics, it is simply not possible.
- jandrese 4y agoCap and trade is largely a failure. The problem is that a proper carbon market should have sequestration plants on the supply side and carbon emitters on the demand side. The emitters need to buy carbon offsets at the price that the sequestration plants need to pull it back out of the atmosphere. The problem is that right now sequestration is so expensive that it would be ruinous to burn fossil fuels, much of the economy would suffer. But if we aren't funding sequestration it doesn't happen and everybody dies. Our brave politicians see this challenge and immediately bury their heads in the sand and hope that they won't be the one holding the bag as the problem grows steadily worse.
- ryukafalz 4y ago> and that the price points where it would be most effective strongly overlap with the price points where it would be a dramatic shock to the economy Even if it’s a fee and dividend system where the proceeds are redistributed back to everyone evenly?
- lm28469 4y agoWe all know the solutions but for that we need to give up comfort, """progress""" and convenience on many aspects > If they were serious, they would propose something less anti-human. Turns out living in the desert in a 200sqm house and driving a ford f350 to move you 80kg ass and buy 10kg of groceries isn't sustainable If your kitchen is on fire you have to extinguish the fire, not move to the living room, close the kitchen door and start the TV
- pclmulqdq 4y agoIt turns out that when you tell people to give up "progress," a lot of them die. That progress was what was keeping them alive.
- lm28469 4y agoLook around, 90% of the gadgets you use everyday aren't keeping you alive. The vast majority of the things we produce and buy are absolutely not a prerequisite for life, or even comfort in general. Will you die if I tell you the tesla cybertruck won't be released ? Or the iphone 15 will be skipped ? Or that you model S will be capped to 70mph
- foobarian 4y agoI think the problem is that it just so happens that the areas and peoples getting the worst impacts happen to not be part of the developed West. Why worry about a few billion people less in the third world if your home transforms from a frozen tundra into a lush paradise?
- funklute 4y ago> When the revealed policy preference of world leaders is to shut down the AC in summer in a desert, turn off the heat in a Scandanavian winter, and restrict energy supplies to developing countries, you don't have a workable solution. There aren't a huge number of possible solutions here. In fact, there are only two: 1) decrease energy usage, or 2) increase sustainable energy production. Claiming that one of these is not a workable solution is not particularly helpful. > Current policy prescriptions are going to kill a lot more people than the warming they are trying to prevent. Reference for this statement?
- helen___keller 4y agoIt sounds like you want a climate policy that allows us to migrate off fossil fuels while energy remains as cheap and abundant as it was for the past century. Have you considered whether this might be physically impossible? If so, would you prefer no action and dealing with the full effects of climate change, or would you prefer to accept a flawed climate policy that migrates off fossil fuels while civilization deals with the impact of expensive and/or limited energy?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoNuclear energy.
- helen___keller 4y agoNuclear is expensive. Depending on your source this can be a factor of 6 on capital costs for new nuclear projects compared to oil/gas (per kWh), and possibly even a factor of 3 on levelized electricity costs. Rising energy prices means poor folk will have to turn off their AC in the summer and turn off their heat in the winter. Sorry, nuclear doesn’t pass the bar you’ve set. (Note: many sources do suggest nuclear levelized cost is not much higher than other energy sources, but even then it’s a massive capital investment so any nuclear policy would look like “trillions in spending and limiting [fossil fuel] energy”, as earlier derided)
- pclmulqdq 4y agoWright's law is a very powerful force. It brought down the cost of solar and wind below the cost of fossil fuels. It will do the same for nuclear power. Using current energy prices to make predictions about developments in solar power in 1990 would have said the same thing you say about nuclear energy today. By the way, nuclear and photovoltaic solar technologies are about equally old - the trope that nuclear power has had a lot longer to become scalable is incorrect. Solar has become scalable due to the amount of money being poured into it. If you pour a lot of energy into nuclear reactors, the price will go down by a lot, too.
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoMost climate change zealots (note I’m not implying climate change didn’t exist, I’m talking about the activists) believe the decisions that led us to this point are a sin in a religious sense, and require atonement and punishment. They see an era of scarcity and sacrifice as a fundamental necessity and thus any solutions that don’t demand it as I sufficiently putative.
- fredoliveira 4y ago> believe the decisions that led us to this point are a sin in a religious sense, and require atonement and punishment I am yet to see an activist take this stance. What are you talking about?
- jandrese 4y agoMaybe in a metaphorical sense? I've never seen this advocated in real life either.
- AnonHP 4y ago> Current policy prescriptions are going to kill a lot more people than the warming they are trying to prevent. If you think climate change is real, I don’t understand how you can believe that the current prescriptions (which aren’t even addressing the problem head on) will kill more people than the effects of climate change. The effects of climate change will probably kill at least several tens of millions of people and more likely the count may an order of magnitude more through direct and indirect effects (including displacement, riots, disease, etc.).
- la64710 4y agoThey should start with making WFH mandatory wherever possible. Don’t have the stats but it will certainly cut lot of commute related pollution and leverage newer technologies to collaborate.
- t0bia_s 4y agoI guess most convincing would be, for example, to stop manufacturing new phones every year. It's hard to believe that climate change is that bad if biggest companies still produce most environmental damaging products and people enjoy to buying it. I would call it "pure hypocrisy". Who could possibly believe that climate change is problem, when new cars, phones, houses, etc. are still manufactured and there are ton's of ads for buying it.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoThere could have been a viable solution: 1/2 surviving child per person and tech to preserve genetic material of every human being. Climate change is not something we could have stopped or influenced. We could have only made a difference in how we chose to perpetuate our species and the eco system we need to survive as a super apex predator. Our politicians failed us. But it’s our collective fault because we elected them and got our priorities wrong. I also blame the proliferation of religions that chose politics over a search for divinity. The zeal to keep adding members to the flock exploded exponentially. We used science and tech to keep the ageing barely alive but not thriving. It costs environmentally more to create and raise a child than to keep us living longer and maintain lower rates of obsolescence. Our survival/thrive/productivity rates are not efficient. We have just begun to understand the expansiveness of intelligence and it’s knowledge amplification. Automation and AI is just the tip of the iceberg. Too bad we find babies cute and hug the age of retirement. It’s like blowing our lungs out into a balloon that can be the size of the room but we prick it when it’s the size of a grapefruit because we think that’s the limit of it’s expansion. What a waste of air..waste of materials and for such short lived fun. Everyone dies, but we really didn’t have to die like a dumbass species that forgot its collective survival instinct and latent potentials.
- jelliclesfarm 4y ago+ [..]The most insidious threat to humankind is something called “extinction debt.” There comes a time in the progress of any species, even ones that seem to be thriving, when extinction will be inevitable, no matter what they might do to avert it. The cause of extinction is usually a delayed reaction to habitat loss. The species most at risk are those that dominate particular habitat patches at the expense of others, who tend to migrate elsewhere, and are therefore spread more thinly. Humans occupy more or less the whole planet, and with our sequestration of a large wedge of the productivity of this planetwide habitat patch, we are dominant within it. H. sapiens might therefore already be a dead species walking. The signs are already there for those willing to see them. When the habitat becomes degraded such that there are fewer resources to go around; when fertility starts to decline; when the birth rate sinks below the death rate; and when genetic resources are limited—the only way is down. The question is “How fast?”[..] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/humans-are-doomed-to-go-extinct/?amp=true https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/humans-are-doomed...
- lamontcg 4y ago> "restrict the supply of energy." use all the solar, wind, geo and hydro you want. even use as much nuclear as you want and build any nuclear plants that you can build cost competitively (but you probably won't be able to). just stop using carbon-based energy.
- Dunban4 4y agoBased evaluation