3 ms·
Clarence Thomas’s Radical Vision of Race (2019)
- chasil 4y agoI was truly surprised by a few things that I read here, and dim memory awakened on much more.
- refurb 4y agoReally great article. I'd encourage anyone - those who like Thomas and those who dislike him to read it. I certainly learned something. His thoughts draw an interesting connection between the radical black politics of the 60's to the conservative views on race today. And it certainly shows how complex a figure he actually is.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI liked the authors book on The Reactionary Mind so will check this out.
- prirun 4y agoI quit reading after this part about his "convictions". He's just like everyone else that sets the rules for everyone until they are inconvenient for themselves. " The Black man does not want or need the white woman. The Black man’s history shows that the white woman is the cause of his failure to be the true Black man. [from their college group's manifesto] [from the article] The last rule caused some playful friction in the group. After the B.S.U. learned that a member was dating a white woman, the group convened a mock trial, found him guilty, and broke his Afro comb as a punishment. Thomas took the rule more seriously, particularly after meeting Kathy Ambush, a black woman, whom he would marry in 1971 and divorce in 1984. In a poem he called “Is you is, or is you ain’t, a brother?” he set out the obligations of black men to black women. Even in that milieu, Kevin Merida and Michael Fletcher reported in their 2007 biography, “Supreme Discomfort,” Thomas’s “edgy race consciousness” stood out. When he saw an interracial couple strolling on campus, he’d loudly demand, “Do I see a black woman with a white man? How could that be?” Until 1986, when Thomas met Virginia Lamp, who is white and would become his second wife, he opposed interracial sex and marriage." With the recent Roe decision, he also wrote that the court should revisit contraception and same-sex marriage: https://www.texastribune.org/2022/06/24/roe-wade-clarence-thomas-contraception-same-sex-marriage/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/06/24/roe-wade-clarence-th... Isn't it convenient that he doesn't think interracial marriage should be re-examined, you know, considering that he's married to a white woman and all.
- rayiner 4y ago> Isn't it convenient that he doesn't think interracial marriage should be re-examined, you know, considering that he's married to a white woman and all. This particular meme takes the cake for both being kind of racist, and also ignorant about the Constitution. There’s an amendment specifically adopted after a bitter civil war to specifically address racial discrimination. Bans on interracial marriage fall easily within its very broad plain terms.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 4y agoDo they? It took almost exactly a century after the ratification of 14A to reach the Loving decision. Thomas was attending Holy Cross at the time.
- dctoedt 4y agoOf the Civil War Amendments, neither the 13th nor the 14th Amendment mentions race, or marriage. The 15th Amendment mentions race, but only in respect of the right to vote.
- monetus 4y agoIf you'd like the context of how extremely weird his life was, there is a 4 part podcast about him from behind the bastards. https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236323/episode/part-one-the-clarence-thomas-story-99759984/ https://www.iheart.com/podcast/105-behind-the-bastards-29236...
- photochemsyn 4y ago> "When he was nearly forty years old, just four years shy of his appointment to the Court, Thomas set out the foundations of his vision in a profile in The Atlantic. “There is nothing you can do to get past black skin,” he said. “I don’t care how educated you are, how good you are at what you do—you’ll never have the same contacts or opportunities, you’ll never be seen as equal to whites.” People from Africa who've recently immigrated to the United States that I've talked to - be it North Africa (Sudan), West Africa (Nigeria) or East Africa (Tanzania) - really don't seem to share this mentality. It seems most prevalent among those born and raised in the USA (possibly this is true in Europe as well). As far as tech perspectives, it might be possible very soon to get CRISPR-type genetic treatments that alter skin pigment expression - proposed as a medical treatment for people with rare albinism that makes them highly sunlight-sensitive. There are a few recent papers on this. Western countries have (more-or-less) accepted trans-gender identification in conjunction with hormone/surgical alteration; I wonder if similar 'trans-racial' identification backed up by artificially altering skin cell pigment expression will ever become a thing.
- rayiner 4y agoThe article is extremely illuminating. It aptly illustrates how minority racial politics do not map neatly into the left-right dichotomy defined by white people. If you think about it, Black nationalism was in many respects quite conservative and patriarchal. It was at odds with white conservatism, but it's often the case that different conservative factions don't get along (e.g. evangelical christians and fundamentalism muslims). I was recently at an event where a historian/community advocate from the Gullah community in Georgia was invited to speak. The audience was expecting a lecture on the evils of slavery. Instead, more than a third of the presentation was about the great "Chief Justice Clarence Thomas." For good measure, the speaker noted at the end how he had been part of George W. Bush's "Pro Life" outreach. The discomfort among the overwhelmingly white and left-leaning audience was palpable. Of course it shouldn't have surprised anyone that a Gullah speaker would share Thomas's social views, or care more that "he's a Gullah like me" than about their respective roles in white politics. In that vein, what I find remarkable about white peoples' reaction to Clarence Thomas is that they hate him much more for his views that are typical of his community, than for the views where he is atypical. It's his views on abortion, etc.--which are shared by for example half of Black people in Georgia--that trigger invectives like "Uncle Thomas." He doesn't get that kind of hate for his views on small government or economics.