3 ms·
The actual title is > Widespread misperceptions of long-term attitude change Not "Study: Americans consistently overestimate how much culture has changed." An
by godelski 4y ago
The actual title is
> Widespread misperceptions of long-term attitude change
Not "Study: Americans consistently overestimate how much culture has changed." And from the abstract
> Participants overestimated the amount of change on 29 attitudes (57%), underestimated change on 10 attitudes (20%), estimated change in the wrong direction on 10 attitudes (20%), and estimated change correctly on only two attitudes (4%). (out of 51 different attitudes)
Maybe we can change the title. When I read this abstract I got the feeling that Americans just don't know what's going on. Which honestly makes far more sense. Things are changing rapidly recently. It especially makes sense when you consider we're isolating our social groups more (internet makes this easier but isn't a sole contributor) and so there would be a biased estimate for over estimation.
What's also really interesting is that going through some of these is that it seems that people in the 70's greatly underestimated many things. For example when asked about abortion with there was serious risk people estimated (in 72) that only 49% of people were in favor but actually 87% were in favor. Now perception has changed to 71 and actual to 90. Another example is concerns about climate change. In 1990 people estimated 28% were concerned but actually 61% were concerned. Now it is 65.5 vs 65.
If you just came here for the title it really does look like there is a lot more interesting data than what the title says. It does seem like some things we've gotten better at getting estimates on while others are more difficult. Worth at least looking at the figures. But definitely could be some interesting followup analysis.
- larsiusprime 4y agoSorry, I based the submission title from a press repost, but wanted to link the original source, which apparently had a different title.
- phantom_of_cato 4y agoThat shouldn't be permitted, otherwise everything can be submitted with any arbitrary title: you just submit the original with the title you used to link to it in your personal blog.
- larsiusprime 4y agoI'm copping to a goof is what I'm saying. I was submitting the article then thought, "oh, I should probably deep link the actual research article" but still used the original title I had typed in.
- godelski 4y agoThe rules are that you are supposed to keep the original title. OP linked a different title. You are allowed to edit within a small timeframe because we're humans and mistakes happen. Same goes with comments. We work on good faith here (another rule) and so don't abuse it. Bad faith actors do get warned. Dang is a dang good moderator and underappreciated for the amount of work he has.
- godelski 4y agoI think you might be able to edit. I'm unsure, if not maybe Dang will come around and do it for you.
- larsiusprime 4y agoIs title editing a new feature? Little nervous, didn't expect it to rocket immediately to the #1 spot, trying my best not to get trouble in here
- pvg 4y agoNot a new feature, you can fix it or if the time has passed, a mod will eventually fix it. But you're not going to get in trouble either for making an honest mistake or trying to fix it.
- larsiusprime 4y agoFound the button! Fixed ^_^ Sorry for the trouble
- godelski 4y agoNo worries, things happen. Good post btw.
- joe-collins 4y agoI don't know the statistical tools to properly validate it, but to my eye, it looks like the study participants actually tend to do a solid job of estimating the rate of change within the past handful of years. Their awareness of the absolute values is more scattered, but their knowledge of very recent relative change is better than I would have guessed from the abstract.
- 4ududjwhe 4y ago> It especially makes sense when you consider we're isolating our social groups more I wouldn't really pin this one on the internet. Consensus Spaces are the new normal, people have realized the dialogue is a waste of time at best and a trap to give the other side a soap box at worst. Everyone laughed at the lgbt community for it at first but the reality is that those same people took notes and realized that it was actually an extremely clever way to help propagate ideas amongst a target demographic. This strategy is popular irl and in cyberspace now (anyone coming from a college campus recently will have some experience with spaces designed to this attitude) it's just much easier/faster to make Consensus Spaces online.
- impalallama 4y agoThe fact that it’s been 30 years and only 4% of people are more concerned about climate change is pretty damn grim
- michaelmrose 4y ago
- mistermann 4y agoRelevant: https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/05/28/bush-did-north-dakota/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2020/05/28/bush-did-north-dakota/
- michaelmrose 4y agoThis is interesting but young earth creationism isn't a default answer to any question its a very specific deeply held belief highly correlated with a low IQ and inability to engage in complex thinking.
- mistermann 4y agoEngaging in complex thinking while keeping one's imagination in check is indeed difficult.
- runamok 4y agoI am a little confused by that. AFAIK climate change wasn't even discussed in popular culture 30 or so years ago. I wonder if they are equating "concerned with the environment" with climate change. The concern back in the day was pollution, nuclear waste, the ozone layer, the rainforest, species going extinct, etc. Perhaps my memory is poor.
- logifail 4y ago> Another example is concerns about climate change I'm not sure that measuring respondants expressing "concern about X" in isolation is a good metric. It costs nothing to express concern. Aside: I'm afraid I can't stop thinking of Channel 4's Brass Eye show from 2001 about the (fictional) drug "cake" (https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/cake-channel-4-controversy_uk_57978408e4b06d7c426de84f https://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/cake-channel-4-contro... Instead, how about asking what respondants what steps they have taken - if any - in response to their concerns about X?
- somenameforme 4y agoLook at the methods. The most accurate title would be: "Americans taking online surveys for pennies consistently overestimate how much culture has changed." I went into more detail here [1], but the sample is based on Amazon Mechanical Turk/Prolific. This survey is not just only Americans (or at least those that can pass for such; they had to be able to answer: "students in their second year of high school are called sophomores, that granola would be an unusual dish to serve at a Fourth of July barbecue, and that dialing 911 connects the caller to emergency services"), but an extremely biased subset of such. [1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32775623 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32775623
- godelski 4y agoYeah this does seem like a pretty significant bias. Though different than the normal significant bias of college age students that many of these frequently sample from.
- galaxyLogic 4y agoI think the point is that people form their opinions based on what they think other people think.
- dang 4y agoOk, changed now. Thanks! Submitted title was "Study: Americans consistently overestimate how much culture has changed".