6 ms·
I was born in the UK, in 1963. Because of my step-father's love of first-wave UK punk, the first thing I did on hearing this news was to play the Sex Pistol's "
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
I was born in the UK, in 1963. Because of my step-father's love of first-wave UK punk, the first thing I did on hearing this news was to play the Sex Pistol's "God Save the Queen".
It is remarkable how much the Queen's standing has improved during the time since that song (1977). My (UK) family are (as far as I know) staunch republicans, but the last couple of decades have seen all of us soften our disgust with the monarchy as Elizabeth represented it. We might still want the whole concept destroyed, but there is nothing close to the vehemence of Johnny Rotten (Lydon)'s lyrics from that song.
Nevertheless, that is how a bunch of people felt in 1977, and as our memories become even more gilded and rose goggled now that she has died, it may be worth remembering those feelings too:
God save the queen /
The fascist regime /
They made you a moron /
A potential H bomb /
God save the queen /
She's not a human being /
and There's no future /
And England's dreaming
These days, I think even us staunch republicans/anti-monarchists would begrudgingly admit that "She could have been worse" and that she actually was a human being.
Maybe Charles will have the guts to end it all, but it doesn't seem likely.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tuoret 4y agoI put on the song as soon as I heard the news and it took Spotify something like 15 seconds to load it. There's a very stressed server out there right now.
- colechristensen 4y ago
- rhplus 4y ago> "the opaque procedure of Queen’s consent has been exercised far more extensively than was previously believed" https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/08/royals-vetted-more-than-1000-laws-via-queens-consent https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/feb/08/royals-vette...
- daedalus_f 4y agoThe article does a good job conflating the parliamentary process of Queen’s consent and lobbying of the government by the Royal family. You may think both are bad/outdated, I do, but there’s a lot of journalistic spin going on here. Right at the bottom of the article there is a quote: “Consent is always granted by the monarch where requested by government. Any assertion that the sovereign has blocked legislation is simply incorrect.” The journalist never provides any evidence to the contrary.
- waqf 4y agoBut the quote does not address the question of whether the government felt that the sovereign were threatening to block legislation, if it were not modified in accordance with the Royal Family's wishes (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyqnu6ywhR4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pyqnu6ywhR4).
- scaramanga 4y agoOr whether the monarch was threatening to oust the government, using the army which is loyal to the monarch.
- scaramanga 4y agoBecause it could not exist, because it is secret. Also, the government has to request it. Another problem the UK has is: massively corrupt governments.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoThey are in an odd spot of having extreme de jure power (Charles could disband parliament tomorrow) while having a completely unknown de facto power (would they listen? It didn't work out too well for another Charles).
- wyldfire 4y agoIt seems as if in Elizabeth's life (if "The Crown" has any bearing on real life events) she was able to wield some amount of de facto power either due to her reputation/prestige personally or from her role as monarch. > Charles could disband parliament tomorrow Elizabeth had some amount of real world power perhaps via the potential threat of this.
- bambax 4y agoIt would be quite funny if he tried. I don't think he has it in him though.
- Beltalowda 4y agoKing Baudouin of Belgium tried to exercise his power in the 90s by refusing to sign the abortion law, citing his catholic faith. The law got signed in to effect anyway. The "trick" was that parliament can sign laws in to effect if the king is incapacitated. They declared him incapacitated, signed the law, and declared him "capable" again the next day. Whether that was truly legal and in accordance to the letter of the law was a matter of some debate (in my reading of the text, it's not), but I expect things will go in a similar fashion for the British monarchy if Charles really tries to use his "hard power" (rather than "soft power"/influence) in any way.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe queen says "tut tut" to the prime minister when the prime minister does something bad. That is not a role that you can underestimate. The queen reminds the prime minister that there is someone above them, and someone that they answer to. In comparison, a lot of US presidents seem like they need a few "tut tuts."
- jamiek88 4y agoUS presidents answer to the people. It’s completely different.
- pclmulqdq 4y agoDoes Joe Biden agree? Does Donald Trump agree? I would wager that neither man feels particularly accountable to the unwashed masses that both of them openly disdained. Edit: Does George Bush agree?
- tcmart14 4y agoIn theory. But theory and practice are different things.
- garren 4y agoIt’s completely different, that’s without a doubt. Whether or not a US President “answer[s] to the poeple” is debatable. W Bush taking the country to Iraq again, against a significant majority of the people comes to mind.
- JAlexoid 4y agoThey make a lot of money off "the little things"... Like owning large swathes of Westminster(land and revenue generating properties) You can be assured that Royal Family Inc will fight tooth and nail to keep their privileges intact.
- msabalau 4y agoGiven that Dang has decided that exploring the negative aspects of monarchy are "ranting" and "malignant", it is hard to imagine how you could get an comprehensive assessment of the institution on HN. A curious person can probably find that sort of information elsewhere.
- dang 4y agoNo, I said that about shallow-indignant internet comments, aka flamebait, which are what we don't want here. Thoughtful critique is a different matter—though the bar for "thoughtful" on this topic has to be pretty high, because it's so full of bombast and an internet forum is the worst genre for that. I don't care about monarchism or anti-monarchism, nor would I ever take a position about anything like that in a moderation comment. The moderation comments are always about the same thing—avoiding tedious repetition (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32771818 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32771818). The irony is how tediously repetitive they are!
- hazeii 4y agoNot so black and white, but I still thing the Sex Pistols GSTQ is a great song (also Anti-Nowhere Leagues 's "So F*king What!", much more FTW). Never a fan of the Diana bandwagon either. Yet, likewise to me the Queen always earned the respect shown her. Colouring the establishment by the actions of some is just too black and white thinking for me.
- Normille 4y ago>the Sex Pistols GSTQ is a great song (also Anti-Nowhere Leagues 's "So F*king What!".. Don't forget New Model Army's '51st State'
- hazeii 4y agoGreat song (albeit sort-of not written by them, fits the band perfectly though). Lucky enough to see NMA live a couple of times pre-lockdown, no option but to settle for the live stream for the 40th anniversary.
- Beltalowda 4y agoThis is interesting especially with the whole thing surrounding Prince Andrew. You might expect a huge backlash against the royal family as an institution, and there has been some of that, but mostly: it's been relatively mild (against the royal family that is, not prince Andrew). In the 90s (the only era I can remember) things were quite different too: there was the whole hubub about Camilla who was (IMO unfairly) extensively vilified in the media, had private telephone conversations with Charles were leaked. I'm not sure that would happen today; or if it did, it would get considerably less attention. Then there was the whole bruhaha about Andrew and Fergie, and let's not even start about Diana. Maybe today Kim Kardashian or whatnot have taken the place for the "gossip inclined". Or maybe I just don't pay as much attention to these things as I did back in the day. But it seems like reporting is completely different. As for punk: that's basically intended to offend innit? I'm not sure if you can really tell the general mood of the country from punk.
- ryanbrunner 4y agoI think there has been plenty of (unjustified) scandal around Harry and Meghan, to a far lesser degree Kate, and as you said Andrew. But you're right that these have had less of an effect on the royal family itself and especially QEII
- citilife 4y agoNot to dive into politics particularly; but there are advantages and disadvantages to every form of government. What are the particular disadvantages your family dislikes? Is it the principal of it or something in particular? One clear advantage of monarchs that I can see, are that they have an incentive to grow and expand their tax base. That typically means long-term planning (but doesn't ensure it, which is a disadvantage the UK parliamentary system seems to mitigate).
- nh23423fefe 4y agoCherry picking one dimension and making a supposition, isnt a clear advantage.
- kibwen 4y agoHere's an analogy: in a democracy, first-past-the-post voting is, in a vacuum, about the worst voting system that exists. But the reason that it was adopted in so many places is because it has one advantage: its sheer, utter, bone-headed simplicity. In a context where most constituents are illiterate and unfamiliar with the notion of democratic government, it behooves you to pick the simplest solution that can possibly work, even if it leads to worse results than more complex systems. Hereditary absolute monarchy is the same thing, but for selecting heads of state. Who's in charge? The guy with the biggest army. What powers does he have? All of them. Who succeeds him when he dies? His firstborn. It's dead simple to implement, which made it an attractive solution in times before any semblance of mass communication. But in practice it means the quality of your head of state is totally detached from their actual talent at serving as head of state: the first guy in line was just good at leading an army, and the rest of his descendants are just randos who won the birth lottery. It's not a good solution unless you're willing to make loads of sacrifices in order to have the simplest system possible. (And yes, of course, the UK is not currently an absolute monarchy, but you appeared to be asking in a general sense.)
- bee_rider 4y agoSuccession struggles were like their own whole genre of political strife until the modern era. Multiple parties can have claims of varying legitimacy -- first born might gain some advantage in being near to the previous leader, inheriting the royal rolodex and hopefully some powerful/motivated allies who want to keep the status quo, but it isn't a sure thing. Sure, now that the top position is entirely symbolic in the vast majority of monarchies, nobody fights over it. But the if the UK Monarch was in any sense "in charge" of anything, we'd surely see the US propping up Harry and Meghan as the true legitimate heirs and we might even let them borrow a couple carriers to "persuade" Parliament of the fact. Or whatever.
- nemo44x 4y agoIt's called "getting old". :) I think even John Lydon has respect for the Queen nowadays. [1] [1] https://www.loudersound.com/news/john-lydon-on-sex-pistols-god-save-the-queen-everyone-presumes-that-im-against-the-royal-familyim-actually-really-really-proud-of-the-queen https://www.loudersound.com/news/john-lydon-on-sex-pistols-g...
- dang 4y agoI was wondering if he would appear here, and yes, that makes sense. England was his great theme and the anger in those songs had a lot to do with injured love ("I thought it was the UK").
- worik 4y ago> I think even John Lydon has respect for the Queen nowadays. The person. Not the institution. I have the opposite POV
- bambax 4y ago> We might still want the whole concept destroyed Be very careful what you wish for. As a French, living under the rule of an elected monarch who changes often, but doesn't answer to anyone during their reign, there is something extraordinary to see the British PM bow to the Queen, and do that (I think?) every week.
- ikurei 4y agoI'm curious about this; I don't live in a republic. The PM bows to the Queen, but that doesn't mean they have to listen to the people more than they do in France, no? Doesn't the French Prime Minister answer to the President? How is that worse than having a monarch? Are they often from the same party, thus rendering this answering to the president less powerful? (I know the current PM and President are, not sure if that's the common case.) My impression is that just by being less involved in politics, and generally (not 100%) staying away of corruption and other sorts of scandals (unlike others, looking at you Juan Carlos I) for a few decades, the figure of the Queen can be less jarring or seems more trustworthy than a President usually would. To be honest, I live in a monarchy, and if I could choose we'd transition to a republic... but I've never felt like it would make a huge difference in the quality of our government or our electoral politics, so I just don't really care.
- wwilim 4y agoThe French President just gets a nice office and a limo for a few years, he doesn't inherit hundreds of years of imperial money and retain strange godlike reverence for life.
- bambax 4y ago> Doesn't the French Prime Minister answer to the President? In theory, no, French PM answers only to Parliament. Only Parliament can dismiss them, not the President. In practice, and in normal times, this isn't true at all. When the President tells the PM that their time is up, they immediately resign. (One tried to resist in the 70s and was immediately voted out by Parliament.) This makes the French PM effectively powerless. They simply implement the will of the President. The equivalent to the British PM is the French President, not the French PM. Now there are non normal times where Parliament and the President are on opposite sides. When that happens (1986-1988; 1993-1995; 1997-2002), the PM is effectively in charge of most things, but even in those cases the President still has more powers than an typical constitutional monarch. But my point wasn't about power but about humility. I think it's good and desirable that the ruler has to bow to someone else, and that that person, in turn, has no power whatsoever.
- DontchaKnowit 4y agoI listened to "the queen is dead" by the smith's immediately
- mabil 4y ago> We might still want the whole concept destroyed I am not well versed about republic vs. monarchy apart from my limited experience, which might be more than many people, but not as valuable as someone that have studied that and can pitch in. Coming from BR, have lived in AU, NZ, and UK, and traveled a lot, I would take monarchy over a republic any day, extrapolating on that, and just looking at the current state of affairs of republic countries vs the ones coming from monarchy, which ones look in a better state, and makes you want to move to, live in and raise your family? And mad props to UK for keeping --relatively to others-- really well so far. Thank you and Rest in Peace.
- movedx 4y agoWell said. Look at the HDI: https://hdr.undp.org/data-center/human-development-index#/indicies/HDI https://hdr.undp.org/data-center/human-development-index#/in... Look at the top ten countries. How many are a constitutional monarchy? Which of them would you rather live in? :-)
- volkse 4y agoThe preservation of traditional institutions (like monarchy) does not have a direct influence on HDI. Both high HDI scores and the fact that traditional institutions (no matter how expensive) are preserved has to do with long sustained periods of political stability, physical security and as a result, economic prosperity.
- fsloth 4y agoI think monarchy is irrelevant for HDI and the correlation is more about long term political stability rather than better politics. My country (Finland) could have been a monarchy but ended up not being so. I can’t imagine what could be better with a monarch.
- green_on_black 4y agoPresumably, a life-long monarch would enhance political stability.
- mymythisisthis 4y agoSimilar sentiments from me. I think there is something to be said for, lack of a better word, the continuity of history. 70 years with the same monarch. A system of monarchy, for over a 1000 years. It is a symbolic role, but symbols are powerful.
- scaramanga 4y agoNot to mention wall-to-wall propaganda in any coverage that mentions them across the complete political spectrum of media. Arsenic-laced baby-food would be tolerated, if not vaguely enjoyed, if it received that kind of positive coverage. Mainstream UK press are regularly making North-Korea style calls for people who personally dislike the royals to be excluded from the media, eve when they are making even-handed reportage about them, just on the off-chance that their subconscious biases might seep through in to their work (or something? lol): https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10267447/Amol-Rajans-anti-Wills-Kate-tweets-unearthed.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-10267447/Amol-Rajan... Edit: to indicate irony..