3 ms·
> Or is this all part of an ongoing trend, toward something like the Chinese Social Credit Score system, where the consequences of not maintaining a high rating
by hulitu 4y ago
> Or is this all part of an ongoing trend, toward something like the Chinese Social Credit Score system, where the consequences of not maintaining a high rating are socially crippling?
Something like this.
See captcha for example, it is more and more required to use some websites. See PayPal, see Mastercard and Visa, see Apple, see Google, see Microsoft. They are all in control of your digital life and you have no power whatsoever.
- koenvdb 4y agoCould you explain why captcha is controlling our digital lives? I mean sure they can force me to find a boat on every picture but other than that they don't really control me as far as I know.
- rhn_mk1 4y agoThe point of captcha isn't that you find boats on pictures. It's that you score high enough on some opaque metric. That's why captchas come in different forms: math challenges, sound recognition, snooping on clicks, as well as captchas that will keep serving you challenges forever without ever accepting your answer. If you can't hit the score, you won't be allowed in.
- josephcsible 4y agoIf the CAPTCHA provider deems you unworthy to proceed, the fadeout delay after each action will get excessively long, and the number of CAPTCHAs you have to complete will just keep increasing without bound, until you give up.
- SapporoChris 4y agoI have experienced this. On VPN I have to select specific countries in order to get through CAPTCHAs. Some countries no issue, some countries it's CAPTCHA after CAPTCHA until I give up.
- RockRobotRock 4y agoThey add so much noise to the picture, too. It can take over a minute to solve a single captcha. The funny thing is that by doing this, they're punishing the poor offshore workers I hired to solve captchas for me in the first place.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- keks24 4y agoTest it for yourself: 1. Install Firefox 2. Open Firefox and solve a ReCaptcha 3. Install Chromium 4. Open Chromium and solve a ReCaptcha Notice the difference between Firefox and Chromium? Google's ReCaptcha is gracious with Chromium/Google Chrome. You can even make mistakes and it still valid. With Firefox (and maybe other) browsers on the other hand... why not increasing the difficulty/challenge for them? -.-
- kolme 4y agoThis is worse than the Chinese social credit score system, in my opinion, because: - It's completely arbitrary and opaque. - It's irreversible. With the CSSSS at least you get a notification of what you did, and you can revert it by "behaving".
- captainmuon 4y agoThe Chinese system also applies to companies and government offices. One could imagine in a similar system that Airbnb would get penalized for too many unjustified bans. Maybe this would be a solution to the robo-ban problem that we have with many large SV companies? Make the cost of a mistake higher?
- chaosmarmot 4y agoCompanies do use consumer scores under the innocuous term of Digital Safety and Trust to determine the service you receive. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/business/secret-consumer-score-access.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/business/secret-consumer-... Non paywall: https://archive.ph/FKQ6d https://archive.ph/FKQ6d The article does mention use cases for fraud, however it also states that the consumer score can ...determine how long each of us waits on hold when calling a business, whether we can return items at a store, and what type of service we receive. A low score sends you to the back of the queue; high scores get you elite treatment. The article also mentions usage by social / dating applications such as OkCupid, which would indicate that a score can have an impact on your social life. On one hand, I do understand the need for fraud mitigation. On the other hand, I've had to deal with the negative consequences of incorrect data provided by companies such as LexisNexis, how you can't fix it, and the impacts it has.