3 ms·
VS code has shown that. I couldn’t tell you if an app I’m using is “native” or just a very good electron app.
by Gigachad 4y ago
VS code has shown that. I couldn’t tell you if an app I’m using is “native” or just a very good electron app.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoVS Code is very much the exception and not the rule. It also has the benefit of an excellent, well funded development team which isn't true for even other Electron apps within the company (MS Teams). How many startups and small-to-midsize companies are going to invest as much as MS has into VS Code? Probably not many. Even an investment half or third as large would be unusual.
- soulofmischief 4y agoIt seems silly that you would admonish someone for bringing up exceptional web apps when the entire basis of discussion is the future of web apps. Exceptional web apps are exactly the kind of example you want to look for when discussing potential.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoHow relevant is potential if it’s rarely fulfilled? The point is that building an Electron app of the same caliber as VS Code is a very expensive endeavor and likely not within reach of the vast majority of projects using Electron. That will continue to be true so long as using Electron is seen as a way to cut development costs to a minimum rather than as a way to develop a high quality cross platform app at a cost that’s higher than that of a single native app, but cheaper than multiple native apps. A philosophy shift is required for Electron to shine.
- soulofmischief 4y agoElectron is a stepping stone. This conversation isn't about Electron specifically and its current shortcomings are irrelevant to the topic, which is that cross-platform app adoption is held back by artificial company policy.
- pjmlp 4y agoVSCode has shown that it needs several plugins written in C++, Rust and C#, and WebGL rendering, to achieve some meaningful performance and still fails short of Sublime and Notepad++.
- smoldesu 4y agoIt also ships clients across several OSes and arches. Writing it natively and maintaining it's portability would be a snipe chase, and even then it wouldn't run on locked-down devices like the iPad. Targeting the web/Electron worked out for Microsoft, it's not like Intellij is leading the way with memory-efficient text editors or anything.
- pjmlp 4y agoIf only Microsoft knew how to write portable C++ code for GUI applications. https://cppcon.digital-medium.co.uk/session/2022/how-microsoft-uses-c-to-deliver-office/ https://cppcon.digital-medium.co.uk/session/2022/how-microso... Why wonder how we managed to create applications across 8 and 16 bit platforms with their dedicated hardware and zero help from Web technologies....