4 ms·
An idle thought I had related to this is that the real trick to scaling up fusion power may be to not try and extract the energy "through the walls", as you sai
by jiggawatts 4y ago
An idle thought I had related to this is that the real trick to scaling up fusion power may be to not try and extract the energy "through the walls", as you said.
You know how they tell you to "visualise success" because you need to know what it looks like to aim for it?
Along those lines I was visualising what it would look like if someone like Elon Musk was on YouTube showing off some sort of future fusion reactor that's "not just a piece of lab equipment", but something that would be dramatically better than any extant fission reactor or similar technology.
I visualised it as an enormous stationary rocket engine, where cooling water was pumped through a relatively narrow (~50cm) "reactor tube". The water needs leave a hole in the middle for the fusion fuel gases. The hole is achieved by imparting a rotation to the water, so it "spins out" to the sides. Fusion would occur not throughout a large volume, but at a small number of "pinch points" along the axis set up using powerful magnets -- and not necessarily superconducting magnets! To get sufficient current through the coils, the charged exhaust is allowed to expand through a magnetic "rocket engine bell", producing moving (and accelerating) electric charges. This current is recirculated through the engine to provide the enormous magnetic field strengths required, via thick copper conductors aggressively cooled with water.
Essentially it would be a magneto-hydrodynamic-fusion jet engine, using fields instead of impellers to achieve compression, expansion, and energy recovery to run the whole cycle.
The bulk of the energy would be in the super-heated steam produced, which could be used as in traditional power plants, or used as a bone-fide rocket in space.
Obviously there would be "challenges" to making this work, to put it mildly!
But consider that with the kind of computer power we can throw at modelling physics these days, it may be possible to use "topology optimisation" style tricks to figure out the required geometry of the parts to achieve the conditions required for fusion while staying within material design constraints.
If you ask me, a Manhattan-project style attempt at something like this would be a better way to "waste money" than yet another aircraft carrier, or whatever...
- randmeerkat 4y ago> “You know how they tell you to "visualise success" because you need to know what it looks like to aim for it? Along those lines I was visualising what it would look like if someone like Elon Musk was on YouTube showing off some sort of future fusion reactor that's "not just a piece of lab equipment"” The money went to his head, he’s not the innovator he was, now he’s just a billionaire that got bored with Mars and wants to own social media instead.
- wpietri 4y agoI do wonder how much of an innovator he actually is on his own. He's known for his time at Paypal, but he was only there for 6 months, during which his big effort was to switch their Unix servers to Windows NT. He bought his way into Tesla. And speaking as somebody who used to work at Twitter in anti-abuse engineering, I can confidently say that he displays a very poor understanding of the problems he's in theory buying Twitter to solve. And that's before we even get to his terribly handled attempt to buy the company, which could literally cost him billions to get out of, or billions more if he's forced to buy and run the company.
- philwelch 4y agoHe bought his way into Tesla very early on, oversaw the design of the first Roadster, and took over as CEO before the first Roadster launched. He’s also been at SpaceX from the start and has apparently been involved at a technical level from the start.
- wpietri 4y agoI've had some bosses/clients that were "involved at a technical level". Let's just say that their being "involved" in a successful project is not a perfect indicator that they are particularly skilled innovators. For example, consider Steve Jobs. He was hugely involved, but not particularly technical. He was very strong at marketing, and also very strong at understanding certain kinds of user need and then berating people until he got something that met his high standards.
- ncmncm 4y agoCorrect: he is not. All the success he has had comes from lots of bucks to start from, and lucky hires. You can tell from all his obvious duds, and the idiotic things he says whenever he goes off-script. Gwynne Shotwell probably deserves the credit for SpaceX, and probably all of that for her personnel actions.
- baq 4y ago
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoI like the visualization. There’s too many hyperrationalist over analytical minds here to appreciate it. Tesla could imagine his inventions and leave them running in his imagination and if they still worked a few weeks later he knew it would work in the real world. Allegedly anyway. Your visualization reminds me of some geometry I’ve seen and studied in ancient Vedic architecture/temples. There is this cavern with what looks like something is poured into in a cylindrical room, with holes in various places. The Egyptian story is also peculiar as some areas also complement this visualization. Especially the granite statue that was “never completed” and has a hole on its side next to a trench and is quite long vertically. Probably for water, but either way just reminded me of what you said. I personally think you’re onto something with the pinch.
- alcover 4y agoThis greying-out voting system is unfortunate. It just impedes reading and looks bad. Please HN remove it already.