4 ms·
This is similar to "we're all just a simulation" - sure, maybe consciousness isn't in our brain and it's actually all in another dimension. But then how's it wo
by astrange 4y ago
This is similar to "we're all just a simulation" - sure, maybe consciousness isn't in our brain and it's actually all in another dimension. But then how's it work over in the other dimension? It's gotta eventually actually be somewhere.
- Animats 4y agoThat rabbit hole leads to a line of thinking. From the article: "Federico Faggin starts with the assumption that reality emerges from the free-will communications of a vast number of conscious entities". If we're living in a simulation, either it's insanely inefficient, uselessly simulating subatomic activity for hundreds of light years around. Or only stuff being looked at by some active entity is being simulated. Lots of games work that way. Most of the world is turned off most of the time. When two active entities previously running in unsynchronized simulations get close enough that their simulations have to sync, there can be artifacts as they sync up. Those should be noticeable. Some of the larger virtual world systems actually have that problem. But this is all probably bogus. There's a lot of wishful "consciousness must be special so that humans are important" in this line of thinking. As I point out occasionally, the place where AI does badly is not around "consciousness", whatever that is. It's around common sense and manipulation in unstructured situations. Or, as I like to put it, not screwing up in the next 30 seconds. Recently someone commented on here that octopi have those abilities. They're good at figuring out their environment, learn from others of their own kind, and are good at escaping. They're at least at dog level. Octopi are interesting because they are a separate evolution from mammals, with a much more distributed brain and a completely different vision system. This tells us there's more than one way to do it.
- nullish_signal 4y ago>If we're living in a simulation, either it's insanely inefficient, uselessly simulating subatomic activity for hundreds of light years around. OK, how much RAM and Energy did your PC consume to send this text, versus the 10 Chrome tab Virtual Machines, 20 svchost processes, Windows Defender scanning for malware.... How many predictive branch instructions does your CPU errantly run, and discard, every hour? How many of your thoughts contribute positively to the external or internal environment? How many in-fighting cells and viruses in yoir body contribute to you as a Person? And yet, what effort would it take to re-design Everything to completely avoid Parasitic Events? If the Greys spin up Universes and Conscious Agents to stab at un-solvable problem, I'd wager they need those Systems to be Realistic, not Efficient
- wruza 4y agoI agree. The inefficient simulation argument implies that a host has limited time and energy, but it doesn’t have to. Maybe phenomenons vaguely corresponding to our time and energy are abundant there (or even replenished so regularly that you must “spend” them) and the problem the simulation solves lies elsewhere. E.g. they naturally experience that consciousness is universal and simultaneous and is only separated by means of poor communication, unavailable in their primary continuum. Therefore if they stop simulating universes with laws that prohibit efficient communication, they’re doomed to eternally exist in a tedium. (Just sci-fying here please don’t get these details serious)
- whateveracct 4y agoI've got a whole science fiction premise about how consciousness is something our biology taps into and psychedelics actually enhance or modify our biology. Kind of a psychonaut-y world. It's fun to think about.
- gremlinsinc 4y agoIn a way that makes sense. Whether we happily go to work, or decide we've had enough and go 'postal' with an ak47 has a LOT to do with hormonal chemicals bouncing around in our brain. If those chemicals get too far out of whack, we end up depressed, anxious maybe even psychotic or sociopathic. We could even be bipolar, where perhaps the chemicals transition so fast that we can be in a good mood one moment and bad the next. Our consciousness, and reality is painted by our experiences, and our feelings and we cannot separate feelings easily from conscious thought, perhaps with deep meditation and then only for a time. Other things in our body contribute also to our awareness/experience: Pain/pleasure signals, sight, sound and other senses, proprioception, random thoughts, inner monologues (or lack thereof - some people have on inner voice), and then there's the brain itself which can have physical impairments or just differences in how one thinks or experiences the world based on how big one section of the brain is. There's also brain matter inside the intestines, and its possible some part of our consciousness is derived from that, but our total 'self' or 'ego' ... that is a system that encompasses the 'current state' of all the tangentially related things. All those hormones, sensors, etc. Ego is only a state, and it's one that exists in the now. It's hard to quantify because every moment we're a new person than we were before, with a lilttle less, or a little more dopamine, or seratonin, right now i'm getting bored of this topic, 5 minutes ago I was fascinated enough to spend 5-10 mins on a comment... Excited me 5 mins ago vs bored me now are two separate conscious experiences about the same topic/event from the same being but over different time scales and only minutes at that. There's also possibility that there could be some psycho extra-cellular stuff going on, or subatomical stuff we don't know about that perhaps our entire 'energy' around our body could form a 'soul' per se, or if we're in a simulation then our body doesn't even exist and our 'conciousness' or awareness really is the only thing we are, and our body is just a manifestation we created to make ourselves feel real. One thing i found weird as an agnostic is energy. If you make an energy ball in your hands, you can shape it, and feel it and focus on it. Maybe focus some breathing into growing it... eventually it's the size of a basketball and the more you do this the more solid it feels, is it real, or is it imagined? Did I really create an energy ball? It feels as real as a real ball, when I run it over my arm the hairs standup like if it were a balloon with static electricity. I have a feeling we may never know what consciousness really is, I hope it lives on though, it'd be a shame if it doesn't, even though I don't believe in a higher 'being' I believe in energy that is part of consciousness being able to move beyond the physical being.
- programmarchy 4y agoThinking that it has to be located somewhere in space might just be an artifact of a classical mechanics model of the universe, with atoms bumping into each other like billiard balls in a long causal chain all the way back to the Big Bang. But reality doesn’t appear to actually work that way, at least according to modern physics. Not all things seem to necessarily have a location in space. For example, where is the color red, or where is “red-ness”? I’m not talking about light waves radiating at a certain frequency but rather the experience of red we have in our minds. Plato gets at this concept with his ideal forms, which transcend space and time, yet can be “materialized” within space and time as matter and observed by consciousness. In other words, there is no difference between “red-ness” and the experience of “red-ness” we have in our minds, rather they are one in the same. Yes, there may be interference with our perception of the ideal form e.g. color blindness, or other impairments analogous to a radio with a damaged antenna. However it’s still plausible that there is a transcendent form that exists independent of space and time, yet which is accessible within space time via the organs of consciousness we experience as matter. Anyway, just some musings, but I have found that ancient metaphysics are not incompatible with modern physics. It gets interesting because if you accept the metaphysics about “red-ness”, then you can extend this line of thought more broadly to concepts like “good-ness”, and what is the good, and how we could possibly know this.