3 ms·
In 10 seconds it's only possible to write an onliner, and onliners usually get downvoted here. I always recommend to write longer comments, unless it's a very c
by gus_massa 4y ago
In 10 seconds it's only possible to write an onliner, and onliners usually get downvoted here. I always recommend to write longer comments, unless it's a very clear case and you know what you are doing.
Anyway, I agree that it's better to skip the comments when there are like 1000 comments. I try to skip comment sections when there are more than 100.
Many of the top comments here are quite good, and my guess is that they took like 5 or 10 minutes to write, or more.
Some discussion about papers it's necessary to read the press article, and then read the research article, until it makes sense. Add 10 or 15 minutes, or more.
I have to rewrite the comments a few times, my English is horrible (and my Spanish is horrible too), but after a few reviews I can remove all the wavy red lines and write something that makes sense.
Sometimes it's difficult to pick the correct technical level of the comment. To shallow and it's only hand waving. Too deep and only a specialist can understand it. What to cut? What to link to Wikipedia? In which order?
And replies to comments are very difficult. It's easy to post a generic reply, but for a personalized reply explaining why the parent comment is wrong you must understand exactly where is the error.
- vanilla_nut 4y agoWell said. I write, rewrite, and edit most of my comments. They frequently take 5+, even 10+ minutes from the moment I begin to when I hit "reply". I try to upvote and downvote comments based on whether or not they contribute that same level of thought. I suppose enough community members feel the same that we generally keep the comments high quality enough to justify refreshing the page multiple times a day, every day. By the way, your English is quite good for a non-native speaker. Just putting this much conscious effort into writing puts your prose a level above most native English speakers!