4 ms·
> There have been several proposed bills that would create a pre-filled tax form system, but they always get quietly sidelined by tax industry lobbyists. Not j
by tzs 4y ago
> There have been several proposed bills that would create a pre-filled tax form system, but they always get quietly sidelined by tax industry lobbyists.
Not just industry lobbyists. Another big part is Grover Norquist's "Americans for Tax Reform" and similar groups. They have a lot of influence with about half of Congress.
Here's a PowerPoint presentation [1] Norquist presented to the President's Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform in 2005 explaining their opposition to free filing.
It's short so I'll paste the text from each slide here, with the slide titles marked with dashes, so people don't have to find a copy of PowerPoint (or LibreOffice or Keynote, which also can open it fine).
---- Implementing a “Return-Free” Tax Filing Scheme
Presentation to the President’s Advisory Panel on Federal Tax Reform
Grover Norquist
President
Americans for Tax Reform
May 17, 2005
---- The Current System
Tax filing is citizen-based – taxpayers tell the government what they earned and owe
---- Under Return-Free
Tax filing would be government-based – the burden would be on the taxpayer to challenge the government’s findings -- essentially an audit of every single American taxpayer
---- The Fox Would Guard the Henhouse
The same agency that collects taxes would be the tax preparer – the motivation to maximize revenue would dominate both ends of the process
---- Return-Free is a Tax Increase
The true goal is to increase revenue. The government knows few taxpayers will challenge its findings
---- Taxes Should be Visible
Doing taxes keeps citizens aware of the tax burden imposed upon them by the government. A Return-Free scheme would allow the government to raise revenues invisibly
---- The California Example
The State would not guarantee the accuracy of the returns it prepared – the taxpayer was removed from the process, but left with the responsibility
The pilot program achieved 50% less uptake than planned
Comments by CA officials tell us that the true aim was increased revenue
[1] http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/taxreformpanel/meetings/docs/norquist_05172005.ppt http://govinfo.library.unt.edu/taxreformpanel/meetings/docs/...
- CrendKing 4y agoSo much BS in these lines. For whatever record IRS already has on me, there is nothing my version of the filing can change. It's not like I can arbitrarily remove an 0 from my AGI and "challenge" IRS to accept my version. Then why demand me to repeat the duplicate information? "keeps citizens aware of the tax burden" - Sure if some people want to be aware, but I'm sure many people don't care about and can't reason about every tax change. Seriously, how many of you ever read a news about a new tax and "talked to your congress representative"? All these are just giant waste of time to majority of the population in the country.
- akira2501 4y ago> there is nothing my version of the filing can change. The IRS can say "this is not a valid business expense." You can say "it clearly is a valid business expense and should be deducted!" The IRS can say "this is contractor income." You can say "it clearly is an down payment for subcontractors, you can see the money leaving here!" These are two obvious problems you could have, and it doesn't even require dishonesty on the IRS' part. Maybe one of your subcontractors is trying to cheat the system and is jamming you up?
- totony 4y agoFor most people, you won't have these issues. For those that do, what difference does it make to fix it vs making it all on their own?
- freedomben 4y ago> what difference does it make to fix it vs making it all on their own? That sounds like a big difference to me. The former would require government knowledge of every single transaction you make/receive, while the latter does not.
- totony 4y agoIt isn't. Most people only pay tax on their income, which is already sent to the IRS. Just pre-file it and ask the payee to approve it. If you have more complicated taxes, you can just decline the pre-filed and file your own, like you already do.
- akira2501 4y agoWell, you've flagged the point. These people, about 10% of the population, that own small businesses are in the minority. They're likely to be an explicit disadvantage in this system. This is a segment that you probably want to use tax policy to protect, not harm. Further.. it feels like the goalposts have moved on this since it last came up. I don't need the IRS to do my taxes for me, I just need to be able to login to the IRS, pick a form, fill it, and submit it. E-filing should be free and available to everyone. If you have that, I'm not sure what the value of having it prefilled for me is. In particular, if you just have a single W2 to work from, there could be a 1040-SUPER-EZ where you just enter a serial number from your W2, have it fill from that, and then submit. You can make this easy without putting everyone under the thumb of the IRS.
- stephen_g 4y agoVery interesting - basically none of that is the case in most countries that have a pre-filled system...
- yowzadave 4y agoThis is a point that I return to often—on so many issues, Americans feel compelled to argue using speculation informed by their particular ideologies, when there is no need to speculate. We can just observe the effects of various policies around the world, assuming of course that we are somewhat curious and willing to be proven wrong by reality.
- jandrese 4y agoThis is such a load of horsecrap. If you need to file deductions then you do that, the government just pre-fills everything they already know. If you want to hire an accountant to be creative with your exceptions you can still do that.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThe nice thing about Norquist is you can choose an optimal policy set by simply doing the exact opposite of everything he says.
- iso1631 4y agoIn the UK the vast majority of national tax take is either baked into the price of goods (things like VAT, alcohol, petrol taxes) or taken off by your employer. Each month I get a payslip saying I've earned £xxxx and £yyyy has been taken in various taxes and other deductions (from pension to [optional] healthcare, some of which comes off pre tax, some post tax), and the balance is transferred into my nominated bank account each month. At the end of the year I get a summary from my employer called a P60, which shows how much tax I've paid. If I have complex needs I then have 9 months to go to a gov.uk website, fill in that data, and either get a rebate or a bill. If it's a bill then they adjust my tax code (which defines the deductions) the next year it takes about 10 minutes (or I can just pay straight away), if it's a rebate they pay it direct to my account (or they can adjust next years deductions) For self employed people then, but you likely have an accountant who handles everything, and pay yourself via dividends, making large enough tax savings to easily pay accountant fees (which for a small business is pretty low) I don't consider tax a burden, I consider it the cost of living in a western society. I don't have to pay them - I could move to Svalbard or a country that would take me and pay taxes in that country. Even Americans can do this (and get rid of their US citizenship - saying "no I don't want the benefits of American society")