3 ms·

> For improvements I commented: Remove setup.py files and mandate wheels. This would make most C extensions impossible to install on anything other than x86_64

• mathstuf 4y ago
  I think it'd make other things impossible too. One project I help maintain is C++ and is mainly so. It optionally has Python bindings. It also has something like 150 options to the build that affect things. There is zero chance of me ever attempting to make `setup.py` any kind of sensible "entry point" to the build. Instead, the build detects "oh, you want a wheel" and generates `setup.py` to just grab what the C++ build then drops into a place where `build_ext` or whatever expects them to be using some fun globs. It also fills in "features" or whatever the post-name `[name]` stuff is called so you can do some kind of post-build "ok, it has a feature I need" inspection.
• urschrei 4y ago
  cibuildwheel (which is an official, supported tool) has made this enormously easier. I test and generate wheels with a compiled (Rust! Because of course) extension using a Cython bridge for all supported Python versions for 32-bit and 64-bit Windows, macOS x86_64 and arm64, and whatever manylinux is calling itself this week. No user compilation required. It took about half a day to set up, and is extremely well documented.