4 ms·
I think this is probably reasoning to reach the conclusion you had already decided you wanted. The impact of a dollar in the developing world is so much more t
by whimsicalism 4y ago
I think this is probably reasoning to reach the conclusion you had already decided you wanted.
The impact of a dollar in the developing world is so much more than anyone that you could help who is in close proximity to the typical HN commentator that it would take an absolutely massive amount of graft to equalize the two.
- dahfizz 4y agoI don't think it is so clear cut. Charity money going to third world countries often ends up finding corrupt governments and destroying local markets.
- whimsicalism 4y agoIf you're saying such a large proportion of charity money goes towards graft that it is better to donate locally, I would love a source. If I donate to an organization providing malaria nets, most of that money goes to the malaria nets and some goes to funding rigorous verification that the money is going to malaria nets.
- lupire 4y agoYeah AMF is great. But putting all the money in the world exclusively into malaria nets* won't solve all the world's problems though. * (where by the way they also end up poisoning fish and people when the malaria nets become fishing nets)
- whimsicalism 4y agoI am not sure when we changed goalposts from "is it a better marginal impact for your dollar" to "does it solve all the world's problems."
- citizenpaul 4y agoMost states in the US publish stats on charities operating in their borders. My state has a yearly shame list they publish. One thing I learned from looking at it is that most charities that take in less than $1 mil a year basically are not real charities and keep 99% of the money for 'overhead'
- bheadmaster 4y agoYou're ignoring the impact of your money going into the pockets of the very people who are making the problem worse. Yes, some of charity money actually goes to those in need. But what part of it does go to the people who use that money to further exploit those very people they're helping? What if the total result is actually net-negative? I believe that greed is a much more common motivator than altruism.
- munch117 4y agoIf you don't believe in altruism, then why are you here discussing how best to do it? The kind of charity that is most likely to be fraudulent or completely ineffectual, is a small, local one. The bigger the organisation, the more cost-effective it is to do checks.
- bheadmaster 4y agoI never said I don't believe in altruism. I just see greed as a more powerful motivator. Do you not agree? > The kind of charity that is most likely to be fraudulent or completely ineffectual, is a small, local one. The bigger the organisation, the more cost-effective it is to do checks. It's actually the other way around. The bigger the organization, the more room it has to cook its books and bribe the verifiers. Also, the bigger the organization, the bigger the tax cuts, which means bigger motivation for grifters.