6 ms·
I don't know about others, but what would have been a day one purchase for me is now going to be put off because of this one limitation. Flying into some random
by paxys 4y ago
I don't know about others, but what would have been a day one purchase for me is now going to be put off because of this one limitation. Flying into some random country, buying a prepaid SIM card at the airport or some street corner and popping it into my phone is something I do multiple times a year, but this phone seems to only have been designed with the major US carriers in mind (and not even most MVNOs). eSIM is not at all prevalent in most of the world.
In fact Apple knows this themselves, which is why international iPhone 14 models are going to keep the SIM tray. Removing it from US models is such a bizarre decision to me. Does the target iPhone user in the US just not travel?
- ericmay 4y agoOr maybe you land in a new country, the iPhone is like "hey I see you're in a new country, want a data package?" and you could just opt-in to something straight from your phone and be connected before you even get off the plane without needing to buy a disposable SIM card. With that being said, I think it would be better if carriers were just global tbh. But that's a dream.
- cma 4y agoMaybe Apple could get a 30% cut of plans sold that way. Since they made the phone it's only fair.
- ericmay 4y agoI think that makes sense b/c they’re basically “doing the sale” similar to how a retailer might advertise a product that they up sell from a wholesale price.
- colin_mccabe 4y agoIs this sarcasm, or do you really think Apple should get 30% of the revenue from all phone plans?
- ericmay 4y agoIdk about 30%, but yea whatever they agree to with carriers for integrating this feature into the iPhone seems to make sense to me. I mean are you really going to be upset that one multi-billion dollar corporation is getting a share of the revenue of other multi-billion dollar corporations? Should we be upset that Amazon sells Apple products on Amazon.com? Or do you think Apple and others should just not create features like this or make it easier for you to switch carriers in different countries when the carriers themselves are making billions ripping you off with overpriced throw-away SIM cards? Ultimately if they're developing features like this, I don't care if they do or don't get a cut. My life gets a lot better. If (to use the US as an example) Verizon makes a little less money because they're paying Apple. Whatever. Could not care less. Apple will probably eventually launch their own service anyway unless anti-trust breaks them up. iPhone is so huge that they can truly own the full stack if they so desire.
- cma 4y agoMy post was sarcasm.
- elforce002 4y agoI totally see Apple doing that with some type of arrangement between them and the Telco providers.
- 1659447091 4y ago> I think it would be better if carriers were just global tbh. T-Mobile is pretty close. Most monthly plans get unlimited data and text in 200+(?) countries. Pay $10 extra for better data speeds. Haven't had to buy an airport SIM since I was already covered for the things I use - rideshare apps, google maps, hotel/airline apps, messaging apps and regular sms. Would be nice to get even higher data speeds in places that have it, but it's still very much usable and useful.
- ericmay 4y agoYea I have T-Mobile as well and like it quite a bit. Even if very few customers took advantage of this offering it gives you a sense of safety that taps into the same nerve center that something like the Amex Platinum and lounge access does.
- addicted 4y agoIf I’m traveling to another country, I might want a local number so that people in that country can call me from without incurring a long distance call charge. Also, a lot of 2 factor verification systems have trouble messaging international numbers. A lot of the airport Wi-Fi’s I try to log into, for example, almost never succeed in sending me a pin on my international number. Adding a roaming data plan to my existing number only solves a small number of the problems international travelers face. And even those problems are almost always resolved at a higher cost than getting a local SIM.
- stemlord 4y agoThis already exists based on carrier and plan. However my verizon "Travel Pass" has never ever worked in any country I've tried it in. Even when I ended up getting billed for.the $10/day to use it I still never had service. On the other hand a 70gb Vodafone SIM card was 10 euro and all I had to do was stick it in and wait 30 seconds. It's good to have options, esp tried and true ones
- FireBeyond 4y agoThis can be down to Settings. I traveled to Thailand and had similar issues with AT&Ts service. IIRC there may be 2 or even 3 separate 'roaming' type settings that need to be enabled for everything to work.
- klooney 4y agoVerizon's travel pass works pretty well in Mexico, so there's that at least
- daveoc64 4y agoThat model doesn't work because it relies on you having data available to set up that interaction with the local carrier. With a physical SIM you can insert it into your device, even if there's no connectivity available to you. That's not to mention how likely carriers are to make it difficult to swap eSIMs around.
- csdvrx 4y ago> Or maybe you land in a new country, the iPhone is like "hey I see you're in a new country, want a data package?" And do you think you will always get the best prices/services compared to SIM cards sold to locals? I don't think the incentives go that way. It's more like step 1) limit the visibility of the alternatives in the name of convenience/simplicity step 2) "these are not the alternatives you are looking for" For the phone company, their best bet is that they'll nickel and dime you through roaming, if for some reason you need this exact phone number to receive calls. If you just need to use your skype/google voice number , they know you don't need roaming, as a local company will be less expansive, but they can still try to push you towards their "friendly favored partner" (which bad prices due to generous revenue sharing agreement) If your phone is unlocked and is not ESIM only, there's nothing they can do to let local competition deliver you the cheapest service
- techdragon 4y agoCarriers (at least of the non-MVNO kind) are far too burdened by the transnational legal frameworks of radio regulation to ever really be global. And various legal regulations on companies around the world don’t make it easier for telecommunications providers to form certain kinds of business arrangements. The best we will ever get is if some MVNO gets a good enough deal on their global transit that they can provide some kind of global roaming service like that by way of agreements with physical carriers in many countries.
- baybal2 4y ago
- arinlen 4y ago> Or maybe you land in a new country, the iPhone is like "hey I see you're in a new country, want a data package?" Does having a SIM tray stop you from replying to that prompt? > and you could just opt-in to something straight from your phone and be connected before you even get off the plane without needing to buy a disposable SIM card. Does having a SIM tray remove your ability to choose? Meanwhile, people use multiple SIMs even without leaving their home town as some mobile internet providers offer better services than bundled voice+internet services, having to use multiple cellphone numbers is a reality, and actually subscribing to separate services in multiple countries is a thing as well. For instance, right now I have two SIM cards from two separate operators from two separate countries in one of my phones, and I would have a third if that was an option. Why is this suddenly a bad thing?
- addicted 4y agoOne sees this logical fallacy so often with Apple and its fans. It’s almost certainly encouraged by Apple as well. Let’s say there’s a product that has 2 similar features A & B. For its next version of the product Apple removes feature B. Then folks complain about how there are things they cannot do because feature B is missing. The Apple fans respond by extolling the benefits of feature A. The problem is that I already had all those benefits of feature A when Apple shipped the product with both A and B. The Apple fans convert the actual argument, which is (A AND B) vs (Only A) into a strawman argument, which is (Only B) vs (Only A).
- ericmay 4y agoI think if folks really want the feature of a physical SIM card they have other phone options out there. Maybe it's something available from Samsung or Google? Personally I think going to another country and buying a disposable SIM card and hoping I don't lose my other one and all of these other things is much more of a hassle than something like landing, turning off airplane mode, and then just selecting a plan that works for me all set up with Apple Pay that I could have done before I even get off the plane. Then again, just using a carrier that has global coverage would be even better.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Does the target iPhone user in the US just not travel? AT&T charges me $10/day up to $100/month for unlimited calls, texting, and data while overseas, virtually anywhere in the world. That's low enough I can't be bothered to go to the trouble of SIM purchase, swapping, and giving everyone my temporary number on arrival.
- paxys 4y agoLast time I was in India I paid $3.75 for an unlimited everything 4G plan for a month. I guess the definition of "low enough" can vary.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe average cost of a cell phone plan in the US is over $100/month, so yes.
- paxys 4y agoSays who? Unlimited plans from all major carriers top off at $70-80/mo. If you have multiple lines the per line cost is cheaper still (like $50/mo). Plans with data caps, discount carriers and MVNOs all go as low as $30/mo. If you are paying $100+ for a cell phone plan in the US today you are being taken for a ride.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Unlimited plans from all major carriers top off at $70-80/mo. Until you add the $20-30 in taxes and fees they don’t show on their pricing page. “Regulatory Charge”, “Admin & Telco Recovery Charge”, “Gross Receipts Surchg”, and “Fed Universal Service Charge”, and that doesn’t even include the state/local ones; they’re just Verizon’s set. https://www.verizon.com/support/surcharges/ https://www.verizon.com/support/surcharges/
- Sylamore 4y agoI pay $99.98/mo for 3 lines with unlimited talk and data, including 5G data and a smartwatch with cellular access - that includes taxes and fees, on the Verizon network. That's $29.99/line + $10 for the smart watch. No way in hell I would pay $100/line.
- cyanydeez 4y agoYes. Iphones are Nikes and the major consumers are poor people.
- orf 4y agoI used to do that, now I just use https://www.airalo.com/ https://www.airalo.com/. Cheap and easy.
- zikduruqe 4y agoor Dent Wireless. I buy their 1GB for $9/yr as an emergency backup for when my main carrier has issues. https://www.dentwireless.com https://www.dentwireless.com
- slaw 4y agoI bought 40GB of data for $8.50. Airalo 10GB is $22 for the country I visited.
- orf 4y agoThat doesn't invalidate the point that services exist that allow you to buy e-sims all over the world if you're travelling. And if you're travelling a lot the price difference is miniscule compared to the cost of travel and accomodation.
- slaw 4y agoI was referring to cheap part. It is 5 times more expensive than local sim, it is data only, doesn't have phone number I needed for local services. I am not sure hotspot is not blocked or not. The website doesn't say.
- bubblethink 4y agoHotspot isn't blocked. I'm using it right now. The reason it probably doesn't offer phone services is due to KYC stuff. Most governments love ID cards, address proofs and what not before they let you make phone calls. The data only esim bypasses all that. In fact, even the data is not locally terminated although you are using the local network. It terminates in their network (hosted by OVH in the EU at the moment). So it also effectively acts as a vpn. This is also great because most governments around the world have arbitrary censorship. Overall, I would say that it's a good product although the prices can be lower.
- discostrings 4y agoThis prevents my day 1 purchase as well. My US carrier (Verizon Prepaid) doesn't support eSIM yet, and I don't want a postpaid plan. I see absolutely no reason removing the SIM slot at this time is in customers' interests. Getting a model from Canada is an option, but those don't support mmWave 5G, and I'm often in areas where I'd actually use it.
- wilsonnb3 4y ago> I see absolutely no reason removing the SIM slot at this time is in customers' interests. They want the industry to move on from physical sim to esim, so they are essentially forcing it to. I imagine the odds of Verizon Prepaid getting esim support in the near future have greatly increased since this announcement.
- xenospn 4y agoDownload Airalo. Problem Solved.
- aaomidi 4y agoThere’s a lot of solutions to the problem you’ve mentioned. 1. There are companies specifically doing esims for data effectively everywhere in the world. 2. Google Fi exists 3. Just get an international plan? It’s honestly so much easier than juggling sims.
- diebeforei485 4y agoUS models support 5G mmWave, non-US models do not. So, the US models already have slightly higher cost. The SIM tray adds manufacturing cost and complexity. It's also a structural weak point and makes waterproofing harder - which adds to warranty/applecare+ costs. Therefore it's an easy cost-cutting move to get rid of the SIM tray on US models to bring the costs back in line. I will say this: they should have kept the tray on the Pro Max models, which is what international travelers use.
- fomine3 4y agoAlso possibly Apple decided to implement mmwave antenna for US model on where SIM tray locates for the rest of the world model.
- arinlen 4y ago> The SIM tray adds manufacturing cost and complexity. It's also a structural weak point and makes waterproofing harder - which adds to warranty/applecare+ costs. Please explain then why I have been seeing iPhone 13 ads that showcase how it handles all sorts of drops and spills and sprinkles and kitchen hazards while sporting the SIM tray. Unbelievable.
- addicted 4y agoI love how Apple basically eliminated competition from competitors selling $20 headphones (oh no…you have to deal with a couple of wires…something Apple itself used as the signature motif in its ad campaigns for the iPods for a decade), so they could sell you the same thing for about 10 times the price (sure it has a slight convenience benefit but not everyone cares for it that much) and Apple’s fans will tie themselves into knots to explain how this is a good thing, as opposed to having both, so those who want to spend 10x for the convenience of no wires can do so and those who are happy buying cheap $10 earbuds from their local convenience store’s checkout counter display can also do so.
- diebeforei485 4y agoI didn't say it made waterproofing or structural integrity impossible. It just makes it more difficult and therefore more expensive to manufacture. Most people do not care about the SIM tray. There are apps that can get you e-sims for data in every country in the world. Physical SIM cards are largely a liability. They need to be replaced as the network changes (as T-mobile had to for standalone 5G) and they make phone theft even more of a headache because phone thieves can take your SIM card and use it for SMS-based OTP and password resets. I would rather have mmWave.