2 ms·
Personally I'm pretty cynical about web3. I don't see how it becomes any less decentralized and rather just appears to me an attempted coup where a different se
by godelski 4y ago
Personally I'm pretty cynical about web3. I don't see how it becomes any less decentralized and rather just appears to me an attempted coup where a different set of leaders take over the internet. Decentralization is an incredibly difficult problem, especially when infrastructure is non-trivial. People get mad at me all the time for pointing to email (or even the internet) as an example of this, but we just had a top page post the other day about this exact issue with email AND browsers. Sure, it isn't 100% centralized, but that isn't a requirement for centralization. We consider Coke to be monopolistic but it couldn't even perform a 51% attack, though it could with Pepsi (which has half the market share that Coke has). Decentralization is difficult because momentum is a key principle and there are natural monopolies. These especially arise when there are network effects. So until I hear a compelling reason that this force has been overcome (extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence) then I'm not a believer. If you are still in prototyping and using big names to sell your product, I'm going to think you're a grifter.
I even say this as having a belief in some of the values of cryptocurrenceis and a desire to have what web3 claims to be. I see high value in a private (ZKP), secure, quick, digital currency, but it must also be better than what we already have, meaning that if it doesn't allow for things like clawbacks (being able to play within the judiciary), then it is dead in the water. I really do want to see a decentralized internet like web3 seeks, but I haven't seen any extraordinary evidence. Maybe there is a signal in all the noise that I can't see, but if there is, then maybe the true believers need to rid the space of the grifters (there is zero doubt that there are a large number of grifts making hand over fist) and build trust. If you can't convince a bunch of techies of your cool tech product you're not going to convince the average public. It just builds distrust, which will be almost impossible to recover from. But I'm still waiting to see if there is a signal in all that noise.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y ago> secure > allow for things like clawbacks (being able to play within the judiciary) Pick one.
- godelski 4y agoIs Algorand not secure? It isn't ZKP so still doesn't fit my above criteria, but that's different. I don't see why this isn't possible. Hard, yes, but impossible?