5 ms·
Top comment there is: > The experience taught me a lot about business and business leadership. Many times I’d ask myself “what would McKinsey or BCG do here?”
by runnerup 4y ago
Top comment there is:
> The experience taught me a lot about business and business leadership. Many times I’d ask myself “what would McKinsey or BCG do here?” Then I’d go do the exact opposite. That’s proven a good course of action at many critical junctures.
While this agrees with my personal impression “in bulk” it’s worth noting that there are exceptions. McKinsey is currently focusing heavily on hiring actually accomplished top engineers from production environment…specifically targeting those with 6-10 YOE who may have hired into a “lesser” company during a recession or market downturn than they should have qualified for their graduation year of college. They’re hiring engineers who have had outsized / personally unexpected (by the engineer) success with changes to processes or best engineering practices that ended up being rolled out to wide swaths of their company, or globally across the org.
They are also specifically looking among those effective engineers for who can also speak competently with many layers of an org - not just the business people but also lend help and expertise on the technical side and gain trust through competence.
The experienced engineers I know that they’ve picked up are among the best industrial / process / manufacturing engineers that I’ve ever known and are insanely technically competent.
But I also think these are hired into relatively small, niche groups and offices. The bulk of the consultant pool are still fresh MBAs, maybe with limited but glamorous resume fillers.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoYes even McKinsey had to realise at some point that the bulk of the money was now in IT consulting, prestige be damned. But I have to give you that they have spun a good tale around it as usual.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoCurrent McKinsey. It's a big decentralized firm so it's hard to say definitively what other groups are doing but I don't think we're doing "IT consulting" if you mean the body shops that do implementation work like Accenture. The engineers and folks are mostly because we need to do a lot of stuff with analytics and working with different platforms as needed.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoI knew it would touch a nerve but yes, McKinsey is currently doing things which are not very far from what Accenture is doing minus the putting developers in seats part and that’s very much what I would call IT consulting - quotes non included because I still don’t like smelling my own fart enough to despise actual work. You could try to spin it and say they only touch the high value complex parts of issues – I will concede that if there is one thing McKinsey is good at invoicing aside it’s putting a shiny coat of paint on things – but the reality is they do relatively unglamorous and low brow things for the money.
- spywaregorilla 4y ago> I knew it would touch a nerve but yes Am I supposed to be upset if you think some parts of the company I work at do IT consulting?