5 ms·
> 43% of the batch were accepted with only an idea I would love to hear more details about this lot. A billion+ people on the planet (including most of this fo
by paxys 4y ago
> 43% of the batch were accepted with only an idea
I would love to hear more details about this lot. A billion+ people on the planet (including most of this forum I bet) have "killer" startup ideas and swear they can successfully execute on them with some money. How exactly does YC judge their merit and fund them without as much as a working prototype? Do you look at past history of successful launches? Education/work pedigree? Personality? It's pretty wild that such founders make up almost half of the batch.
- junofan 4y agoIt’s probably pretty easy to tell with experience.
- whatshisface 4y agoYC can afford to take risks and fund people on first impressions, that's their whole thing if you think about it.
- brudgers 4y agoMy take is that YC can’t afford not to operate that way. My impression is the Decision Matrix looks like. High Low Execution Execution Good Maybe No Idea Bad Maybe No Idea The idea does not matter much because it is easy to use an external source for ideas when a team has a bad idea or no idea. On the other hand, there’s no external way to fix low execution. The other thing is that it is often hard to tell good new ideas from bad new ideas in the context of startups. So idea is often a weak signal. As the GP argued, everyone has startup ideas.
- dzink 4y agoHow many of the idea-only founders were female?
- DelaneyM 4y agoThis is a stat I'd love to see.
- int0x2e 4y agoJust curious - why do assume a correlation (one way or the other) between these two metrics?
- Judgmentality 4y agoBecause humans are imperfect and prone to bias.
- dsr_ 4y agoThey didn't assume anything. They asked. First you get the data, then you can think about correlation.
- YetAnotherNick 4y agoNot sure what correlation do you expect? Do you think it would higher or lower than founders with some progress?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- crhulls 4y agoI may be reading between the lines on something you don't intend, but it seems like this data, in isolation of control variables, could just end up with an incorrect clickbait conclusion that YC is sexist. For example, someone already made the point that many of these founders who could raise on just an idea were likely on their second go around or prior FANG employees. Most founders have historically been male (not saying this is good - just matter of fact) and only 17% of engineers at Google are female (and I think it goes without saying that YC has a bias towards engineers). So if YC has an explicit positive bias towards second time founders and FAANG employees, you could easily see what appears to be anti-female bias, but in reality is just positive indexing towards other attributes that historically skewed male. This may or may not be the case, and there probably are instances where there is implicit bias towards non-positive male-associated traits (macho attitude? unwarranted overconfidence?) but this data in isolation doesn't tell us much. I'm not saying that diversity is bad, or that we shouldn't be looking to increase female representation in the founder community, but we should be careful with understanding cause vs correlation and maintain intellectual honesty when looking at statistics.
- forbiddenvoid 4y agoIt's pretty telling from the replies to this post that people just want to find any excuse they can to pretend the VC boys club doesn't exist. There are obviously some confounding factors, particularly if the batch of idea-only founders includes a large number of people with previous success in VC-backed startups or FAANG companies. The best analysis would be to divide up the group into cohorts and compare against expected populations for the groups. (ie, if only 17% of people with FAANG experience are women, I would expect to see >= 17% of FAANG founders who got in on idea-only to be female). Somehow, I doubt that's the case. Or they'll use the really weaselly language of % of teams with a woman on them, which is what I've seen from most of the big VC firms up to this point.
- ycpivot 4y ago
- mjirv 4y agoMy guess is that about 50% are repeat founders and a majority of the rest are FAANG, Ivy League, or Stanford alums. (This is a genuine guess, not a knock on YC)
- dzink 4y ago44% of Meta employees are women. 51% of Stanford Undergraduates are women. 51% of Harvard Undergraduates are women. MIT is close to that ratio as well. 49% of new businesses in the US in 2021 were started by women. 48%+ all US businesses are owned by women.
- carabiner 4y agoOk?
- boplicity 4y ago> 15% of the companies have a woman founder and 9% of the founders are women.
- kjksf 4y agoPretty sure that in all those cases 10-20% of software engineers are women and you get 50% because in other jobs (marketing, hr) 80% are women. You would have a point about discrimination if 50% of applicants had women but e.g. only 15% of those were accepted. This data is not published but I highly suspect that 15% of applicants included a woman and 15% were funded.
- dusklight 4y agoCan I get a source on this please? In particular I would be curious about what is the breakdown in the % of female engineers and female management in Meta.
- Loeffelmann 4y agoDoes women include trans people?
- 4y ago
- presidentender 4y agoMy cofounder and I raised (not from YC) on a deck. The network was what mattered for this, though. A former colleague (an exec at my previous job) is also a venture partner at a credible firm, who introduced me to his network of VCs and to a number of potential cofounders, including the person with whom I am now building this company. And my cofounder's own network is vast, which led to a ton of investor interest and favorable terms. Again: he made a slide deck and used his network and we started building once we had funding. It doesn't surprise me that YC companies do likewise.
- beebmam 4y agoIt's on a deck AND the individuals who present. If you sent someone a slide deck and nothing else, virtually no one is going to raise funding on just that.
- ycpivot 4y ago