3 ms·
I think they clearly state that the fresh versions are not open source, they are "source available". After 3 years since release the code automatically gets re
by nine_k 4y ago
I think they clearly state that the fresh versions are not open source, they are "source available".
After 3 years since release the code automatically gets relicensed under Apache 2.0 and becomes open source. This is a nice provision that prevents the code from being completely lost if the company loses interest in it.
- capableweb 4y agoThey state that BSL + Apache re-license after 3 years is "open source". It's not, it's delayed open source if anything. But doing BSL is not open source, at least as what we know open source to be today.
- arinlen 4y ago> I think they clearly state that the fresh versions are not open source, they are "source available". To me it reads like they chose to switch to a proprietary license but don't want to be subjected to the natural consequences of betraying the trust of their userbase.
- froh 4y agoisn't their point the breach of trust of large (>25mio revenue) business users of their software to not contribute financially to the developer staff (subscription)? open source creators are systematically abused by large companies who free ride despite being able to financially contribute, and they just don't because they can. "why give the creator a fair share if you can keep them alive with a few graceful breadcrumbs" seems to be such corporations way of thinking, highly profitable formally but the FOSS creators. thus an agpl, thus the new Akka license.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoFrom my perspective the challenge is, what happens if there is a critical bug found after 3 years and you're on the Apache version? Do they backport the fix (out of kindness)? I've jumped through many hoops in the past to pay for fixes to older open source systems - because the systems weren't properly updated - to get a patch, and it was never easy (and fixing this yourself is nearly impossible if the bug isn't obvious, and you don't want to break things in such a core technology).
- dudul 4y agoI believe a section of the FAQ mentions that the previous versions (released under Apache) will no longer receive any updates and you're not allowed to integrate the changes to the newer versions into the older codebase.
- PeterZaitsev 4y agoYes but also they claim "We Believe In A Model Of Sustainable Open Source" where their actions say what they believe what you can't built Sustainable Business around Open Source and Source Available License is required. I've seen companies claiming "but you can use our buggy unsecure code after 3 years" but reality I'm yet to see actually anyone using this with BSL software.